Tractates on the Books of Holy Scripture (Tractatus Origenis) 9.1–10.5

Latin text: Batiffol-Wilmart 1900 (Latin text: Batiffol and Wilmart (Paris, 1900), Internet Archive scan, public domain).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 9

9.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 96–98

Locutus est Dominus ad Moysen dicens : Loquere filiis Israel et dices ad eos : Mensis hic vobis sit initium mensium, primus in mensibus anni. Omnia quae divino consilio et iudicio statuta sunt habent sua principia quibus orta et inchoata sunt, habent causas propter quod significari eas necesse fuit, nec expertes sunt rationis, sed certos habent ordines temporum, ne indiscreta permixtione turbentur. Paschae itaque sacramentum, dilectissimi fratres, quod nunc in dominici corporis passione celebratur, non derepente nec improvisum fuit. Quodcumque enim novum atque praeclarum atque magnificum est, hoc ante tempus per legem priscam in similitudine monstrabatur, ut facti fides de praeterita significatione commendabilior haberetur. Unde si Domini nostri passionem per imaginem retro olim demonstratae similitudinis velitis attendere, tunc invenietis agnum hunc, qui immolabatur in pascha, Xpisti fuisse figuram, qui percussit Aegyptum et liberavit Israel. Denique et Hieremias receptissimus prophetarum agnum hunc Deum et Salvatorem nostrum appellat, cum dicit : Ego quasi agnus immaculatus sine malitia adductus sum ad mortem, et consors ipsius Isaias : Velut ovis, inquit, ad occisionem adductus et velut agnus coram tondente se, sic non aperuit os suum : in humilitate iudicium eius sublatum est, generationem eius quis enarrabit? O qualis est hic agnus cuius nativitatem dicit scriptura enarrari non posse ? Ovis, inquit, masculus anniculus maturus erit, ab ovibus et haedis sumetis eum. Et erit vobis reservatus in quartam et decimam mensis huius diem, et occidet eum omnis multitudo synagogae filiorum Israel ad vesperam. Ecce magna nimis et paene inextricabilis quaestio, ut talis agnus quaeratur qui ab ovibus et haedis fuerit generatus, cum discordium animalium in coniunctione communis fetus minime congruat. Unde si talis agnus qualis scribitur in pascha non potest inveniri, quomodo pascha geri potest cum desit talis agnus qui immoletur in pascha? Et quia iam probavimus agnum istum Dei et Salvatoris nostri habuisse imaginem, qui, non solum propter innocentiam, sed et propter laniciem, eo quod humani generis corpora de transgressione[...] veste immortalitatis indueret, agnus est dictus. Ab ovibus, inquit, et haedis sumetis eum : ab ovibus et haedis sic debemus accipere quomodo ipse Salvator in euangelio docuit : Statuam, inquit, iustos ut oves ad dexteram, peccatores autem ut haedos ad sinistram. Et quia breve spatium horarum non sinet nos multa exempla proferre, compendio assignanda est ratio quemadmodum ab ovibus et haedis agnus iste nascatur.

"The Lord spoke to Moses, saying: 'Speak to the sons of Israel and say to them: This month shall be for you the beginning of months, the first among the months of the year.'" All things established by divine counsel and judgment have their beginnings, from which they arose and started; they have causes on account of which they had to be signified; they are not without reason, but have fixed orders of times, so that they are not thrown into confusion by indiscriminate mixing. So the mystery of the Passover, dearest brothers, which is now celebrated in the passion of the Lord's body, was not sudden or unforeseen. For whatever is new and splendid and magnificent was shown beforehand in likeness through the ancient law, so that faith in the deed might be the more commended by the past signification. Hence, if you are willing to attend to our Lord's passion through the image of the likeness shown long ago, you will find that this lamb, which was sacrificed at the Passover, was a figure of Christ, who struck Egypt and set Israel free. Indeed Jeremiah, the most accepted of the prophets, calls our God and Savior this lamb when he says: "I, like a spotless lamb without malice, was led to death"; and his companion Isaiah says: "Like a sheep he was led to the slaughter, and like a lamb before its shearer, so he did not open his mouth. In humiliation his judgment was taken away; who will tell his generation?" O what kind of lamb is this, whose birth the Scripture says cannot be told? "A sheep," it says, "a male, a year old, mature it shall be; from the sheep and the goats you shall take it. And it shall be kept for you until the fourteenth day of this month, and the whole multitude of the congregation of the sons of Israel shall kill it toward evening." Here is a very great and almost inextricable question: that such a lamb should be sought as has been begotten of sheep and goats, since a common offspring of animals that do not agree in mating is hardly possible. So if such a lamb as is written for the Passover cannot be found, how can the Passover be kept when such a lamb is lacking to be sacrificed at the Passover? And we have already proved that this lamb bore the image of our God and Savior, who is called a lamb not only because of his innocence but also because of his wool, since he would clothe the bodies of the human race, [stripped] by transgression, with the garment of immortality. "From the sheep," it says, "and the goats you shall take it": we must take "from the sheep and the goats" as the Savior himself taught in the Gospel: "I will set," he says, "the righteous like sheep at the right hand, but the sinners like goats at the left." And since the short span of the hours will not let us bring forward many examples, the account must be given in brief of how this lamb is born from sheep and goats.

Exod 12:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:2 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:12 (allusion, medium confidence) · Jer 11:19 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 53:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 53:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Acts 8:32 (echo, medium confidence) · Exod 12:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:6 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 25:33 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The Passover lamb, to be taken 'from the sheep and the goats', is a figure of Christ, the lamb of whom Jeremiah and Isaiah speak; the puzzle of its double origin is posed.

  • "I, like a spotless lamb without malice, was led to death": Jer 11:19 in Gregory's form. A leaked marginal reference ("LR XIILO:") is removed.
  • A word is missing in the digital text after "by transgression" (marked [...]); "stripped" supplies the sense.
  • The Gospel saying is a paraphrase of Matt 25:32–33.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; leaked footnote mark; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; leaked marginal reference; OCR slips; punctuation slip): Mensis hic eobis sit initium mensium, primus in mensibus anni !. → Mensis hic vobis sit initium mensium, primus in mensibus anni.; nec improvisum fuit, Quodcumque → nec improvisum fuit. Quodcumque; priscam 1n similitudine → priscam in similitudine; Xpisti fuisse figaram → Xpisti fuisse figuram; sine LR XIILO: malitia adduetus sum ad. mortem → sine malitia adductus sum ad mortem; Velut oeis, inquit, ad. occisionem adductus et eelut aenus → Velut ovis, inquit, ad occisionem adductus et velut agnus; quis enarrabit ?* → quis enarrabit?; dicit seriptura → dicit scriptura; Et erit eobis resereatus → Et erit vobis reservatus; filiorum Israel ad eesperam → filiorum Israel ad vesperam; discorditorum animalium → discordium animalium; Ab ovibus, inquit, e£ haediís sumetis → Ab ovibus, inquit, et haedis sumetis; ad sinistram, Et quia → ad sinistram. Et quia; agnus Iste nascatur → agnus iste nascatur.

Topics: Christology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 9.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 96–98; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/9-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-9-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

9.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 98–100

Ruth itaque Moabita fuit de gente peccatrice, quam beatus Moyses abdicaverat dicens : Moabitae et Amanitae non intrabunt in ecclesiam Dei usque ad decimam generationem ; Booz autem Israelita homo iustus ex generatione patriarcharum de tribu Iuda. Hic ergo, ut scriptura testatur, Moabitam nomine Ruth post decimam generationem duxit uxorem, de quo nascitur Obeth, de Obeth Iesse, de Iesse David, de David autem secundum ordinem generationum nascitur sancta Maria, unde Xpistus carnem adsumpsit, habens scilicet eiusdem carnis bifariam originem, id est de haedis peccatorum gentis Moabitarum unde Ruth matrem Obeth fuisse docuimus, et ab ovibus patriarcharum ex quibus Booz pater ipsius homo iustus erat, ex genere scilicet Abraham de tribu Iuda, unde hic agnus immaculatus, id est Xpistus Dominus noster, leo de tribu Iuda est appellatus : Vicit enim, inquit, leo de tribu Iuda, radix David. Et Isaias : Prodiet, inquit, virga de radice Iesse, et flos de radice eius ascendet : hic est Iesse pater David ex cuius radice, id est genere, virga, id est Maria orta est, unde flos Xpistus ascendit. Denique et beatus Moyses, sciens hoc sacramentum nativitatis Xpisti, hunc agnum ab ovibus et haedis immolandum esse dicebat, quia si tantummodo ex Israel, quod lex oves appellat, corpus hominis Dominus induisset, et non ex gentibus peccatorum, quos haedis comparat, nec credere gentes in Xpisto nec salvari meruissent, quia arrham carnis suae in Xpisti corpore non haberent. Nunc vero ideo gentes salvantur in Xpisto, quia pignus redemptionis suae ex origine Ruth in Xpisti corpore habere meruerunt. Et ideo talis agnus qualis quaerebatur in pascha de ovibus et haedis, solus Xpistus inventus est, qui non amplius quam semel occiditur ut verum pascha Domini celebretur : Pascha, inquit, Domini est : non dixit populi, ut quia pascha ex passione nomen accepit, ideo pascha Domini dicatur, quia non plebs sed Dominus in figura agni est immolatus. Denique et beatus Paulus apostolus : Pascha, inquit, nostrum immolatus est Xpistus. Sed illud mirari me fateor, dilectissimi fratres, ut cum ovem diceret, masculum nominaverit. Nemo enim ovem masculum appellat : hic vero sic ait : Ovis autem maturus masculus anniculus erit vobis ab agnis et haedis. Cum enim ovem nominat carnem Xpisti indicat, quam Ecclesiam esse apostolus definivit dicens : Caro, inquit, Xpisti quod est ecclesia, ex qua omnes credentes in Xpisto generati sumus, cuius fetus sancti appellantur. Masculum autem ideo dicit, ut carnem ipsam non femineam sed virilem, id est perfecti viri, esse ostenderet, quia non est masculus et femina, sed omnes unum sumus in Xpisto Iesu. Et ideo hic talis agnus immaculatus eligitur, ut simplicitas et innocentia Xpisti sub agni istius figura monstretur : masculus quaeritur, ut invicta virtus ipsius comprobetur : anniculus dicitur, quia ex quo in Iordane baptizatus est a Ioanne, quando dixit : Ecce agnus Dei, ecce qui tollit peccata mundi, expleto et exacto praedicationis tempore, passus est Xpistus, sicut David de hoc praedixit : Benedices, inquit, coronam anni benignitatis tuae. Perfectus est quoque quia, ut apostolus ait, Omnis plenitudo divinitatis corporaliter in illo inhabitat : mense primo, quia necesse erat ut qui peccata mundi auferre venerat eo tempore pateretur quo mundi fuere principia, finem ad originem revocans, ut omnia quae in Adam perierant restaurarentur in Xpisto. Qui enim eversurus est aliquid ortum naturae ipsius insequitur, et spem redivivi vigoris interfecta penitus radice praecidit. Et ideo in ipso ortus sui tempore passione Domini mundus oppressus est, ut cum omnium malorum semine frangeretur, sicut ipse Dominus apostolis suis in euangelio ait : Gaudete et exultate, quia ego vici mundum.

Ruth, then, was a Moabite, of a sinful nation, which blessed Moses had excluded, saying: "Moabites and Ammonites shall not enter the assembly of God until the tenth generation"; but Boaz was an Israelite, a righteous man of the line of the patriarchs, of the tribe of Judah. He, as the Scripture testifies, after the tenth generation took as wife the Moabite named Ruth, and from him is born Obed, from Obed Jesse, from Jesse David, and from David, according to the order of generations, holy Mary is born, from whom Christ took flesh, having, namely, a twofold origin of that flesh: from the goats, the sinners of the Moabite nation, from whom we showed that Ruth, mother of Obed, came; and from the sheep of the patriarchs, from whom Boaz his father was, a righteous man, of the race of Abraham, of the tribe of Judah. Hence this spotless lamb, that is, Christ our Lord, is called the lion of the tribe of Judah: for "the lion of the tribe of Judah," it says, "the root of David, has conquered." And Isaiah: "A rod," he says, "shall come forth from the root of Jesse, and a flower shall go up from his root": this is Jesse, the father of David, from whose root, that is, race, the rod, that is, Mary, arose, from whom the flower, Christ, went up. Indeed blessed Moses too, knowing this mystery of Christ's birth, said that this lamb was to be sacrificed from the sheep and the goats, because, if the Lord had put on a human body only from Israel, which the law calls sheep, and not from the Gentiles of sinners, whom it likens to goats, the Gentiles would not have been found worthy to believe in Christ or be saved, because they would not have the pledge of their flesh in the body of Christ. But now the Gentiles are saved in Christ because they were found worthy to have the pledge of their redemption, from the origin of Ruth, in the body of Christ. And so the only such lamb as was sought for the Passover, from the sheep and the goats, was found to be Christ, who is slain no more than once, so that the true Passover of the Lord may be celebrated. "It is the Lord's Passover," it says; it did not say "the people's," so that, since the Passover took its name from the passion, it might be called the Lord's Passover, because not the people but the Lord was sacrificed in the figure of the lamb. Indeed blessed Paul the apostle says: "Christ our Passover has been sacrificed." But I confess, dearest brothers, that I wonder that, in saying "sheep" (ovis, feminine), he named it male. For no one calls a sheep male; but here he says: "The sheep shall be for you mature, male, a year old, from the lambs and the goats." When he names a sheep, he indicates the flesh of Christ, which the apostle defined as the Church, saying, "the flesh of Christ, which is the Church," from which all of us who believe in Christ have been begotten, whose offspring are called saints. He says "male" in order to show that that flesh is not feminine but manly, that is, of a mature man, because there is not male and female, but we are all one in Christ Jesus. And so such a spotless lamb is chosen, so that the simplicity and innocence of Christ may be shown under the figure of this lamb; a male is sought, so that his unconquered strength may be proved; it is called a year old, because from the time he was baptized in the Jordan by John, when John said, "Behold the Lamb of God, behold him who takes away the sins of the world," Christ suffered when the time of his preaching was completed and fulfilled, as David foretold of this: "You will bless the crown of the year of your kindness." It is also mature, because, as the apostle says, "all the fullness of the divinity dwells in him bodily"; in the first month, because he who had come to take away the sins of the world had to suffer at the time in which the beginnings of the world took place, calling the end back to the origin, so that all that had perished in Adam might be restored in Christ. For whoever means to overthrow something attacks the very birth of its nature, and cuts off the hope of renewed vigor by killing the root completely. And so the world was overcome by the Lord's passion at the very time of its birth, so that it might be broken together with the seed of all evils, as the Lord himself says to his apostles in the Gospel: "Rejoice and exult, for I have overcome the world."

Deut 23:3 (quotation, high confidence) · Ruth 4:13 (allusion, high confidence) · Ruth 4:17 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 1:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Rev 5:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 11:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:11 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 5:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Col 1:24 (quotation, medium confidence) · Gal 3:28 (allusion, high confidence) · John 1:29 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 65:11 (64:12 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Col 2:9 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 15:22 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 16:33 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:12 (echo, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Christ is the lamb 'from sheep and goats' because he descends from Boaz the Israelite and Ruth the Moabite; the male, year-old, mature lamb of the first month figures his strength, ministry and passion.

  • "Until the tenth generation": Deut 23:3.
  • The one-year ministry ("crown of the year", Ps 65:11) is Gregory's reckoning.
  • "The flesh of Christ, which is the Church": a free form of Col 1:24.
  • "Rejoice and exult, for I have overcome the world" combines Matt 5:12 with John 16:33.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; leaked footnote mark): usque ad decimam generationem? ; → usque ad decimam generationem ;; Hie ergo → Hic ergo; de lesse David → de Iesse David; homo 1ustus erat, ex genere scilicet Abraham de tribu luda, unde hice agnus → homo iustus erat, ex genere scilicet Abraham de tribu Iuda, unde hic agnus; /eo de tribu Iuda, radix Dayid, Et Isaias : Prodiet, inquit, eirea. de radice lesse, et flos de radice eius ascendet* : hic est lesse → leo de tribu Iuda, radix David. Et Isaias : Prodiet, inquit, virga de radice Iesse, et flos de radice eius ascendet : hic est Iesse; nec crelere gentes → nec credere gentes; carnis suae 1n Xpisti → carnis suae in Xpisti; Pascha, inquit, Domini est! : → Pascha, inquit, Domini est :; immolatus est Xpistus *. → immolatus est Xpistus.; anniculus erit eobis → anniculus erit vobis; quod est ecclesia ?, → quod est ecclesia,; in Xpisto lesu → in Xpisto Iesu; annieulus dicitur, quia ex quo 1n Iordane → anniculus dicitur, quia ex quo in Iordane; corporaliter in illo inhabitat? : → corporaliter in illo inhabitat :; in Ádam → in Adam; in 1pso ortus → in ipso ortus; ego eici mundum → ego vici mundum.

Topics: Christology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 9.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 98–100; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/9-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-9-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

9.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 100–102

Sed azyma, inquit, cum amaritudinibus edetis, quia ipsis Iudaeis amarum esset futurum quod Dominum suum et vitae principem occisuri erant, cuius, ut ita dixerim, viva mors excitavit mortuos : amarum utique eis quod quasi ad latronem nocte venerunt : amari clavi, quibus eum confixerunt : amara azyma ab ipsis semper edenda, amara verba quibus clamabant : Sanguis eius super nos et super filios nostros : amarus Iudas Iscariotes, quem mercede conduxerunt : amarae spinae, quibus caput eius ad deludendum coronarunt : amarae manus quibus Domini sanguinem effuderunt. Ideo cum amaritudinibus hoc edendum esse praecepit, quia omnia amara eis futura essent quae in agni, id est Xpisti, passione, facturi essent. Et quia, ut apostolus ait, crux Xpisti pereuntibus stultitia est, salvis autem futuris virtus Dei est, et odor Xpisti aliis odor vitae in vitam, aliis odor mortis in mortem, proinde ut illis amarum fuit filium Dei persequi, sic peccatorum nostrorum amaritudines fellis et aceti potio expiavit. Limina quoque domus ut agni sanguine liniuntur, ut posset Aegypti vastator angelus assignatis agni sanguine domibus prohiberi, sic et nos non possumus aliter saeculi istius clades evadere et Dei regnum intrare, nisi per signum sanguinis dominicae passionis. Sanguis enim Xpisti credentibus salus est, non credentibus paena. Aegyptus enim in similitudine istius saeculi fuit, Pharao diaboli. Populus Israel typum nostrum gerebat. Proinde sicut ille populus de Aegypto per agni immolationem, per sacramentum paschae est liberatus, ita et nos credentes in ipso de captivitate saeculi istius et Pharaonis, id est diaboli, tyrannide liberamur. Et ut Pharao qui persequebatur filios Israelitarum in aqua oppressus interiit in qua est populus liberatus, ita et nunc in eadem aqua baptismatis in qua nos liberamur, Pharao, id est diabolus, ... naufragio perit. Sed igne, inquit, assum comedetis. Dei enim sermo semper ignitus est. Et nihil praetermittatur de eo, quia nihil est quod reprobari possit in Xpisto : ossa non confringentur, quia Xpisti virtus invicta est : si quid autem superfuerit igne consumetur, id est si quid de Xpisto homo capere non potest Sancto Spiritui reservetur, quia Spiritum Sanctum sicut ignem super credentes advenisse scriptura testatur. Sic, inquit, manducabitis caput et pedes et quae sunt interiora eius. Triplex hic ratio, sed pro celeritate subtile disserendum est : caput initium, interiora media, pedesque sunt futura : docti haec et eruditi intellegunt. Caput enim Xpisti Pater est; interiora vero ipse sermo divinus qui sinum Patris enarravit; Spiritus autem paraclitus pedes habuit apostolos, per quos cucurrit adnuntians veritatem. Sic autem, inquit, manducabitis : lumbos vestros succinctos habebitis, et calciamenta in pedibus vestris sint, ut firmo gressu et stabili devotione in fide gradiamur. Baculus sit in manibus vestris, ut firmissimum stylum crucis

"But you shall eat unleavened bread," it says, "with bitter herbs," because it was going to be bitter for the Jews themselves that they would kill their Lord and the prince of life, whose living death, so to speak, raised the dead. Bitter for them, certainly, that they came by night as if against a robber; bitter the nails with which they fixed him; bitter the unleavened bread always to be eaten by them; bitter the words they shouted, "His blood be on us and on our children"; bitter Judas Iscariot, whom they hired for a fee; bitter the thorns with which they crowned his head in mockery; bitter the hands with which they shed the Lord's blood. Therefore he commanded that this be eaten with bitter herbs, because everything they were going to do in the passion of the lamb, that is, of Christ, would be bitter for them. And since, as the apostle says, the cross of Christ is folly to those who are perishing but to those who are to be saved it is the power of God, and the fragrance of Christ is to some a fragrance of life to life, to others a fragrance of death to death, therefore, as it was bitter for them to persecute the Son of God, so the drink of gall and vinegar expiated the bitternesses of our sins. And as the thresholds of the house are smeared with the lamb's blood, so that the angel who laid Egypt waste might be kept from the houses marked with the lamb's blood, so too we cannot otherwise escape the disasters of this world and enter the kingdom of God except through the sign of the blood of the Lord's passion. For the blood of Christ is salvation to believers, punishment to unbelievers. For Egypt was in the likeness of this world, Pharaoh of the devil. The people of Israel bore our type. So, as that people was freed from Egypt through the sacrifice of the lamb, through the mystery of the Passover, so we too who believe in him are freed from the captivity of this world and from the tyranny of Pharaoh, that is, the devil. And as Pharaoh, who was pursuing the sons of the Israelites, perished overwhelmed in the water in which the people was freed, so now too in the same water of baptism in which we are freed, Pharaoh, that is, the devil, perishes ... in shipwreck. "But you shall eat it roasted with fire." For the word of God is always fiery. "And let nothing of it be left over," because there is nothing in Christ that can be rejected; "its bones shall not be broken," because the strength of Christ is unconquered; "but if anything is left over, it shall be consumed with fire," that is, if a man cannot grasp something of Christ, let it be reserved to the Holy Spirit, because Scripture testifies that the Holy Spirit came upon believers like fire. "So," it says, "you shall eat the head and the feet and the inner parts." The meaning here is threefold, but for speed it must be explained concisely: the head is the beginning, the inner parts the middle, and the feet the things to come; the learned and instructed understand these things. For the head of Christ is the Father; the inner parts are the divine Word himself, who has made known the bosom of the Father; and the Spirit, the Paraclete, had the apostles as feet, through whom he ran announcing the truth. "So," it says, "you shall eat: you shall have your loins girded, and let there be sandals on your feet," so that we may walk in faith with firm step and steady devotion. "Let there be a staff in your hands," so that it might show the firmest pillar of the cross,

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Exod 12:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Acts 3:15 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 27:25 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 26:15 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 27:29 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 1:18 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Cor 2:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 27:34 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 12:7 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 12:23 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 14:28 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 10:2 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 12:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Jer 23:29 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 12:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:46 (quotation, high confidence) · Acts 2:3 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 11:3 (allusion, high confidence) · John 1:18 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 12:11 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The bitter herbs foretell the bitterness of the Jews' deeds in the passion; the blood on the doorposts, the Red Sea and the details of eating the lamb are read of Christ, baptism and the Trinity.

  • "Head, inner parts and feet" are read of Father, Son and Spirit; this is Gregory's allegory.
  • Gregory's statements about the Jews in the passion are his own, translated as written.
  • The digital text has a gap before "in shipwreck" (marked ...).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; stray point): cum. amaritudinibus → cum amaritudinibus; occisurl erant → occisuri erant; super filios nostros! : → super filios nostros :; crux. Xpisti → crux Xpisti; odor mortis 1n mortem → odor mortis in mortem; credentbus salus → credentibus salus; in Ipso de captivitate → in ipso de captivitate; Pharaonis, 1d est diaboli, tyrannide hberamur → Pharaonis, id est diaboli, tyrannide liberamur; superfuerit 1gne → superfuerit igne; Sc, inquit, manducabitis → Sic, inquit, manducabitis; interiera vero → interiora vero; Sic autem, mquit, manducabitis → Sic autem, inquit, manducabitis; in fide . gradiamur → in fide gradiamur; in manibus eestris → in manibus vestris.

Topics: Baptism, Trinity

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 9.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 100–102; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/9-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-9-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

9.4Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 102–104

quo fulciamur ostenderet. Et azymam, inquit, edetis, et quicumque manducaverit fermentatum morte morietur. Numquid iustum videbatur ut si quis fermentatum manducasset morte moreretur, quippe quia, si fermentum hominem polluebat, non solum in pascha sed et omni tempore prohibendum erat, quia Deus servos suos non solum in die paschae sed et omni tempore mundos et expurgatos permanere iubet ? Sed quia diximus pascha ex passione nomen accepisse, hoc ergo indicabat quod quicumque in passione Domini credidisset et pascha sacri corporis accipere meruisset, is iam fermentum malitiae et nequitiae a sensu suo abicere deberet, sicut beatus apostolus ait : Abicite vetus fermentum, ut sitis nova conspersio in azymis sinceritatis et veritatis. Qua de re, dilectissimi fratres, hoc pascha Domini per legem praefiguratum, per comminationem admonitum quod qui non egisset morte moreretur, praedictum prophetica voce, exspectatum per antiquorum spem, impletum per apostolicam praedicationem, receptum per euangelicam fidem, consecratum per Xpisti sanguinem, ordinatum ad futuram resurrectionem, quis non cum omni religione et votivo pavore suscipiat, quippe cum scriptura dicat : Pascha Domini est, hoc est passio Domini ? Qua passione redemptus est mundus, prostratus est diabolus, clarificatus est Xpisti triumphus. Hoc est, inquam, venerabile ac salutiferum sacramentum paschae, quo sol iustitiae Xpistus mortis quidem legem occidit, sed novum nobis diem solis aestu clariorem resurgendo monstravit, quo immitis inferus horruit, quo resurgente Xpisto caelum patuit. Hoc ergo tanti muneris sacramentum qui legitima observatione celebrat consors est apostolorum, socius prophetarum, implet legem, custodit euangelicam fidem, honorat Xpistum, magnificat Patrem Deum, spem sibi propagat ad perpetuam salutem, gloriosam sibi adquirit rationem. Servat enim depositam ordinationem ab ipso Deo Patre, quam in Xpisto et custodiri voluit et iussit,

with which we are supported. "And you shall eat unleavened bread," it says, "and whoever eats what is leavened shall die the death." Did it seem just that whoever ate what was leavened should die the death? Surely, if leaven polluted a man, it should have been forbidden not only at the Passover but at all times, since God commands his servants to remain clean and purged not only on the day of the Passover but at all times. But since we have said that the Passover took its name from the passion, this indicated that whoever believed in the Lord's passion and was found worthy to receive the Passover of the sacred body must now cast away from his mind the leaven of malice and wickedness, as the blessed apostle says: "Cast out the old leaven, so that you may be a new lump, in the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth." Therefore, dearest brothers, this Passover of the Lord, prefigured through the law, urged by the threat that whoever did not keep it should die the death, foretold by the prophetic voice, awaited through the hope of the ancients, fulfilled through the apostolic preaching, received through the faith of the Gospel, consecrated through the blood of Christ, ordained for the future resurrection: who would not receive it with all reverence and devout awe, since the Scripture says, "It is the Lord's Passover," that is, the Lord's passion? By this passion the world was redeemed, the devil laid low, Christ's triumph made glorious. This, I say, is the venerable and saving mystery of the Passover, by which Christ, the sun of righteousness, killed the law of death and, by rising again, showed us a new day brighter than the heat of the sun, at which cruel hell shuddered, at which, as Christ rose, heaven opened. Whoever, then, celebrates the mystery of so great a gift with lawful observance is a sharer with the apostles, a companion of the prophets; he fulfills the law, keeps the faith of the Gospel, honors Christ, magnifies God the Father, extends his hope toward everlasting salvation, gains a glorious account for himself. For he keeps the ordinance laid down by God the Father himself, which he willed and commanded to be kept in Christ,

Exod 12:15 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 5:7 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 5:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 12:11 (quotation, high confidence) · Mal 4:2 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The ban on leaven teaches believers who share in the Lord's passover to cast out the leaven of malice; the passover, fulfilled in Christ's passion and resurrection, is to be kept with reverence.

  • A leaked marginal reference at the start ("l. Ex. XII, 8 et sq.") is removed.
  • The section, and the tractate, breaks off mid-sentence in the digital text.
  • "Whoever eats what is leavened shall die": a free form of Exod 12:15, 19.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; leaked apparatus of the edition (variant readings); stray point): l. Ex. XII, 8 et sq. → ; in die páschae → in die paschae; ait :/ Abicite eetus fermentum, ut sitis noga conspersio in azymis sinceritatis et eeritatis. → ait : Abicite vetus fermentum, ut sitis nova conspersio in azymis sinceritatis et veritatis.; sol iustitiae. Xpistus → sol iustitiae Xpistus; Hoe ergo tanti → Hoc ergo tanti; voluit et 1ussit, → voluit et iussit,.

Topics: Eucharist

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 9.4 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 102–104; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/9-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-9-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 10

10.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 105–108

Et locutus est Dominus ad Moysen dicens : Loquere ad Aaron et dices ad eum : Homo quicumque offert, secundum omnem promissionem suam et secundum omnem electionem suam, sacrificium salutare Domino. Scio quidem, dilectissimi fratres, saepenumero de hoc Leviticorum libro me tractasse, et arduas pene et inextricabiles quaestiones, ut potui et, puto, ut debui, caritati vestrae disseruisse. Sed et nunc lectio quae recitata est tam multas habet quaestiones, tam implicitas obscuritates ut vix acies mentis in rerum secreta dimergi queat, et vix intueri et prospicere verborum altitudines possit cavillationesque dictorum advertere : ita enim singula quaeque allegoriae integumentis obvoluta sunt, ita aenigmatum nubilo obscurata ut intellegi explicarique vix queant. Attamen ego non ingenii mei, sed divinae pollicitationis fiducia fretus, qua dicit : Petite et accipietis, omni enim petenti dabitur et pulsanti aperietur, et qui quaerit inveniet, et Nihil obscurum quod non manifestetur et tectum quod non reveletur, audeo per Dominum de hac ipsa lectione facere sermonem, ut quod in aditu secretiori videtur esse reconditum, in lucem cognitionis possit aperiri palamque pronisi hostia laudis Deo fuerit oblata. Unusquisque enim, prout habet aut potest, prout mens credentium sufficit, debet devotionis suae munus offerre. Et ideo ait : Homo quicumque offert hostiam voti sui Domino. Non quod Deus huiusmodi sacrificiis indigeat, cum omnia sua sint et totus sit plenus atque perfectus, sicut scriptum est : Quo mihi multitudinem sacrificiorum vestrorum, dicit Dominus? plenus sum, holocausta arietum et adipem taurorum et hircorum nolo : sed ut homo per obsequium legis Deum sibi propitium faciat et favore Dei ab hoste liberetur. Denique et lob secundum numerum filiorum suorum, ut a peccato mundarentur, hostias Domino offerebat. Sed nunc non eas hostias Deus quaerit quales tunc ex inlationibus pecudum cruente praebebantur, sed mentem et conversationem nostram, et cor circa Dei timorem humiliatum desiderat, sicut scriptum est : Sacrificium Deo spiritus contribulatus, cor contritum et humiliatum Deus non spernit. Est enim sacrificium quod in martyrii devotione immolatur, sicut scriptum est : Et erit cum vos interfecerint, hostiam Deo offerent. Est sacrificium virginitatis, cum quis totum se corpore et spiritu Deo servire devoverit. Est et sacrificium eleemosynae, cum unusquisque prona animi voluntate prout habet pauperibus tribuit, sicut scriptum est : Date eleemosynam, et ecce sunt omnia munda vobis. Est et sacrificium continentiae, quia castos diligit Deus. Est et sacrificium salutare, quia Felices, inquit, puro corde, ipsi enim Deum videbunt. Est et sacrificium timoris Dei et bonae credulitatis. Denique et beatus apostolus Paulus conversationem sanctorum hostiam vivam Deo placentem appellavit dicens : Exhibete corpora vestra hostiam vivam placentem Deo, rationabile obsequium vestrum. Sed et sanctissimus Barnabas : Per ipsum offerimus, inquit, Deo laudis hostiam labiorum confitentium nomini eius. Sic ergo corpora nostra hostiam Deo placentem offerimus, cum in omni sanctitate et pudicitia, innocentia, fide et religione Deo servimus. Denique et templum Dei dicimur, sicut apostolus ait : Templum Dei vos estis, et spiritus Dei in vobis inhabitat. In hoc etenim templo sacrificia pura, munda libamina bonae conversationis, hostiam Deo placentem in odorem suavitatis Deo exhibemus, sicut apostolus ait : Bonus odor Xpisti sumus. Diximus martyrium hostiam vivam esse placentem Deo, sed et virginitatem sacrificium mundum esse. Continentia vero rationabile ministerium est, et oratio de corde puro accepta est Deo. Denique orationes sanctorum velut thymiamata per manum angeli Domino offeruntur, sicut in Apocalypsi est recognoscere. Et de viva hostia dicitur,

"And the Lord spoke to Moses, saying: 'Speak to Aaron and say to him: Any man who offers, according to all his promise and according to all his choice, a sacrifice of salvation to the Lord.'" I know, dearest brothers, that I have often treated this book of Leviticus and have explained to your charity, as I could and, I think, as I ought, its difficult and almost inextricable questions. But the reading that has just been read also has so many questions, such tangled obscurities, that the edge of the mind can hardly plunge into the secrets of the matters, can hardly gaze on and look into the depths of the words and notice the subtleties of the sayings: so wrapped is each thing in the coverings of allegory, so darkened by the cloud of riddles, that they can hardly be understood and explained. Yet, relying not on my own ability but on confidence in the divine promise, in which he says, "Ask and you will receive, for to everyone who asks it will be given, and to him who knocks it will be opened, and he who seeks will find," and "There is nothing hidden that will not be made known, and nothing covered that will not be revealed," I venture through the Lord to preach on this very reading, so that what seems stored away in a more secret recess may be opened into the light of knowledge, and openly ... unless a sacrifice of praise has been offered to God. For each one, as he has or is able, as far as the mind of believers is sufficient, ought to offer the gift of his devotion. And so it says: "Any man who offers the sacrifice of his vow to the Lord." Not that God needs sacrifices of this kind, since all things are his and he is wholly full and perfect, as it is written: "What is the multitude of your sacrifices to me, says the Lord? I am full; I do not want burnt offerings of rams and the fat of bulls and goats"; but so that man, through obedience to the law, may make God favorable to himself and by God's favor be freed from the enemy. Indeed Job too offered sacrifices to the Lord according to the number of his sons, so that they might be cleansed from sin. But now God does not seek such sacrifices as were then offered bloodily from the bringing of cattle; rather he desires our mind and conduct, and a heart humbled in the fear of God, as it is written: "A sacrifice to God is a troubled spirit; a contrite and humbled heart God does not despise." For there is a sacrifice that is offered in the devotion of martyrdom, as it is written: "And when they have killed you, they will offer a sacrifice to God." There is the sacrifice of virginity, when someone has vowed himself to serve God wholly in body and spirit. There is also the sacrifice of almsgiving, when each one, with a willing mind, gives to the poor as he has, as it is written: "Give alms, and behold, all things are clean for you." There is also the sacrifice of continence, because God loves the chaste. There is also the saving sacrifice ..., because "Blessed," it says, "are the pure in heart, for they shall see God." There is also the sacrifice of the fear of God and of good faith. Indeed the blessed apostle Paul called the conduct of the saints a living sacrifice pleasing to God, saying: "Present your bodies as a living sacrifice pleasing to God, your reasonable service." And the most holy Barnabas: "Through him," he says, "we offer to God a sacrifice of praise, of lips confessing his name." So, then, we offer our bodies as a sacrifice pleasing to God when we serve God in all holiness and chastity, innocence, faith, and religion. Indeed we are also called the temple of God, as the apostle says: "You are the temple of God, and the Spirit of God dwells in you." For in this temple we present to God pure sacrifices, clean libations of good conduct, a sacrifice pleasing to God as an odor of sweetness, as the apostle says: "We are the good odor of Christ." We have said that martyrdom is a living sacrifice pleasing to God, and that virginity too is a clean sacrifice. Continence is a reasonable service, and prayer from a pure heart is acceptable to God. Indeed the prayers of the saints are offered to the Lord like incense by the hand of an angel, as can be recognized in the Apocalypse. And it speaks of a living sacrifice

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Lev 22:18 (quotation, high confidence) · Lev 22:21 (quotation, medium confidence) · Matt 7:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 7:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 8:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 1:11 (quotation, high confidence) · Job 1:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 51:17 (50:19 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · John 16:2 (quotation, medium confidence) · Luke 11:41 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 12:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Heb 13:15 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 3:16 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Cor 2:15 (quotation, high confidence) · Rev 8:3 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The sacrifices of Leviticus point to spiritual offerings: martyrdom, virginity, almsgiving, continence, purity of heart and prayer, the living sacrifice of the believer's life.

  • Words are lost in the digital text after "and openly" ("palamque pro..."); the gap is marked "...".
  • Gregory ascribes Heb 13:15 to Barnabas, following the old view (found in Tertullian) that Barnabas wrote Hebrews.
  • "And when they have killed you, they will offer a sacrifice to God": a form of John 16:2.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip; punctuation; OCR slip; words run together; OCR slips; OCR slips; broken hyphenation; broken hyphenation; leaked footnote mark; stray point; words run together; stray points): sacrificium salutare Domino. . Scio → sacrificium salutare Domino. Scio; tam 1implicitas obscuritates ut vix acles mentis → tam implicitas obscuritates ut vix acies mentis; vix intuerl et prospicere verborum altitudines possit cavilla- üonesque → vix intueri et prospicere verborum altitudines possit cavillationesque; qui quaerit ineeniel, et Nihil obscurum quod. non manifestetur et tectum quod non reeeletur → qui quaerit inveniet, et Nihil obscurum quod non manifestetur et tectum quod non reveletur; /7omo quicumque offert → Homo quicumque offert; sacrificiorum eestrorum, dicit Dominus plenus sum → sacrificiorum vestrorum, dicit Dominus? plenus sum; hircorum nolo! : → hircorum nolo :; conversationem nos- Iram → conversationem nostram; munda vobis ^, Est → munda vobis. Est; Est etsacrificium salutare..., → Est et sacrificium salutare,; ipsi enim Deum veidebunt, Est et sacrificium timoris Deietbonaecredulitatis. Deniqueet → ipsi enim Deum videbunt. Est et sacrificium timoris Dei et bonae credulitatis. Denique et; hostiam eieam placentem Deo, rationabile obsequium eestrum → hostiam vivam placentem Deo, rationabile obsequium vestrum; Templum Dei eos estis, et spiritus Dei in eobis inhabitat → Templum Dei vos estis, et spiritus Dei in vobis inhabitat.

Topics: Martyrdom, Prayer

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 10.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 105–108; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/10-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-10-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

10.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 108–111

quia bona conversatio sanctorum speciem mortis, id est signum peccati, in se non habet, dicente apostolo Aculeus mortis peccatum, et Per peccatum mors venit. Per hoc enim ille hostiam vivam Deo exhibet, qui sine peccato vitam agens speciem mortis amisit. Ceterum si quis dicat se virginitatem Deo hostiam obtulisse et virgo non sit, Deum fallere non potest, vel si quis continentiam professus incontinenter vivat, aut eleemosynas faciens aliena fraudetur, ut in aliorum gaudium vertat unde alios videtur fecisse lugere, hoc subdoli est potius quam fidelis non propria sed aliena conferre : istae sunt species mortis. Et ideo conversatio talis hostia viva dici non potest, quae in se opera mortis male vivendo suscepit. Hostia ergo viva caritas est de corde puro et conscientia non ficta. Hostia viva est fides sine maculatione. Hostia viva est lingua sine dolo. Hostia viva est eleemosyna sine fraude. Hostia viva est oculus sine scandalo. Hostia viva est religiosa vita, fides pura, anima sincera. Et ideo rationabile ministerium nostrum, id est conversationem sanctam, hostiam vivam placentem Deo scriptura nominavit. Sed quia lex imaginaria quae spiritaliter gerenda erant prius pro tempore carnaliter observari praecepit, ut pro carnalibus spiritalia, pro terrenis caelestia, pro visibilibus invisibilia monstrarentur, proinde pecorum species quas nominavi retractare debemus. Non offeres, inquit, hostiam caecam : verum est hoc, dilectissimi fratres, quia caecus animus, cum nec Deum videt nec opera eius facit, sacrificium Domino non potest offerre. Multi etenim sunt qui volunt ad praesens hominibus placere : execrantur quidem opera peccati, et nihilominus eadem agunt quae in aliis reprehendunt, obcaecatum habentes cor, nescientes quia in quo alium iudicant semetipsos condemnant eadem faciendo. Et ideo isti caeci dicuntur et merito a sacrificio Dei reprobantur. Sed adhuc adiecit : Abstractum, inquit, aut linguam habens amputatam. Abstractus ille est qui quamvis crediderit Xpisto et per sacramentum baptismatis dominico adhaeserit corpori, sicut apostolus ait : Quotquot in Xpisto baptizati estis Xpistum induistis, nihilominus si appetitor sit avaritiae, quae radix est omnium malorum, appetitor saecularium administrationum , appetitor vitiorum et publicarum potestatum, vivens luxuriose sine respectu religionis, hic abstractus a Xpisto per malam conversationem merito dicitur; et non solum abstractus, verum etiam, sicut in hoc loco scriptum est, et conlisus nuncupatur : sic enim ait : Neque abstractum, neque conlisum. Revolutus etenim de religione ad saeculum conlisus in terra est, dum terrena sapit et terrenis actibus incubat; de caelo in terram ruit, ac proinde conlisus atque vexatus est. Et ideo sicut pecus aut per vim aut per furtum abstractum et conlisum et vexatum sacrificio tunc offerri non poterat, ita et eorum conversatio, si aut vitio saeculi aut iniquitate diaboli a Xpisto abstracta et in terra conlisa et vitiis carnalibus convexata fuerit, in sacrificio Dei deputari non potest.

because the good conduct of the saints does not have in itself the appearance of death, that is, the mark of sin, as the apostle says, "The sting of death is sin," and "Through sin death came." For in this way he presents a living sacrifice to God who, living his life without sin, has lost the appearance of death. But if anyone says that he has offered his virginity to God as a sacrifice and is not a virgin, he cannot deceive God; or if anyone who has professed continence lives incontinently, or, giving alms, defrauds others, so as to turn into the joy of some what he seems to have made others mourn for, this is the act of a deceiver rather than of a believer, to bestow not one's own but another's: these are appearances of death. And so such conduct, which by living badly has taken into itself the works of death, cannot be called a living sacrifice. A living sacrifice, then, is love from a pure heart and an unfeigned conscience. A living sacrifice is faith without stain. A living sacrifice is a tongue without deceit. A living sacrifice is almsgiving without fraud. A living sacrifice is an eye without offense. A living sacrifice is a religious life, a pure faith, a sincere soul. And so the Scripture has named our reasonable service, that is, holy conduct, a living sacrifice pleasing to God. But since the figurative law commanded what was to be done spiritually to be observed first, for a time, in a fleshly way, so that spiritual things might be shown in place of fleshly ones, heavenly in place of earthly, invisible in place of visible, we must therefore go back over the kinds of cattle I have named. "You shall not offer," it says, "a blind victim." This is true, dearest brothers, because a blind mind, since it neither sees God nor does his works, cannot offer a sacrifice to the Lord. For there are many who want to please men for the present: they curse the works of sin, yet do the same things they blame in others, having their heart blinded, not knowing that in judging another they condemn themselves by doing the same things. And so these are called blind and are rightly rejected from God's sacrifice. But he added further: "Torn away," it says, "or having its tongue cut off." Torn away is he who, though he has believed in Christ and through the sacrament of baptism has cleaved to the Lord's body, as the apostle says, "As many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ," nevertheless, if he is greedy for avarice, which is the root of all evils, greedy for worldly offices, greedy for vices and public powers, living luxuriously without regard for religion, he is rightly said to be torn away from Christ by his bad conduct; and not only torn away but also, as is written in this place, he is called crushed; for it says: "neither torn away nor crushed." For one who has rolled back from religion to the world is crushed on the earth, as he savors earthly things and broods over earthly acts; he has fallen from heaven to earth, and so is crushed and battered. And so, just as an animal torn away by force or by theft, crushed and battered, could not then be offered in sacrifice, so too the conduct of those who have been torn away from Christ by the vice of the world or the iniquity of the devil, crushed on the earth and battered by fleshly vices, cannot be counted in the sacrifice of God.

1 Cor 15:56 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 5:12 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Tim 1:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 12:1 (allusion, high confidence) · Lev 22:22 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 2:1 (allusion, high confidence) · Gal 3:27 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Tim 6:10 (allusion, high confidence) · Lev 22:24 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: A living sacrifice is a life without sin; false virgins and fraudulent almsgivers offer appearances of death; blind, torn and crushed victims figure blind minds and believers dragged back to the world.

  • The list of blemished victims follows the Old Latin of Lev 22:22–24; "torn away" (abstractum) and "crushed" (conlisum) are its terms.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; broken hyphenation; punctuation slip; stray points): mors eenit → mors venit; species mortis, Et ideo → species mortis. Et ideo; opera mor-- us → opera mortis; llostia viva est oculus → Hostia viva est oculus; JVon offeres, inquit → Non offeres, inquit; obeaecatum → obcaecatum; Et 1deo isti caeci → Et ideo isti caeci; adiecit :. Abstractum, inquit, aut. linguam → adiecit : Abstractum, inquit, aut linguam; Quotquot in. Xpisto baptizati estis Xpistum. induistis → Quotquot in Xpisto baptizati estis Xpistum induistis; in hoc loco seriptum est, et conlisus nuncupatur : sic enim alt : /Veque → in hoc loco scriptum est, et conlisus nuncupatur : sic enim ait : Neque.

Topics: Ethics, Baptism

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 10.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 108–111; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/10-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-10-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

10.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 111–113

Sed adhuc adiecit : Et linguam habens amputatam. Amputatam linguam habet is qui Deum suum non confitetur et praedicat, qui divinam legem non meditatur, sicut scriptum est de beato viro : Et in lege eius meditabitur die ac nocte. Certe ille vel maxime amputatam linguam habet, qui tempore persecutionis, dum aut fetorem carceris aut supplicia aut postremo ipsam mortem timet, Deum suum non confitetur et laudat. Et ideo huiusmodi qui amputatam linguam habere dicuntur, dum Deum suum non confitentur, a divino sacrificio reprobantur. Sed neque vermigerans. Vermigerans dicitur cuius per membra corporis culpa pruriginis cursus habet. Hi ergo vermes immundi sunt spiritus, qui se plerumque in corporibus hominum inserunt et pruriginem libidinis atque variarum concupiscentiarum excitant; et immittunt pruriginem quoque avaritiae, pruriginem impudicitiae et pruriginem omnium carnalium cupiditatum, nec sinunt corpus vel animam quietam in sanctitate et bonitate durare, sed corrumpunt omnia et usque ad putredinem adulterii producunt. Et ideo hi vermes, id est immundi spiritus, sollicitatores et corruptores animarum et corporum, primum sale verbi caelestis eiecti sunt, ut corpus, divinae sapientiae sale salitum, ad sanctitatem debitam revocarent, sicut discipulis suis Dominus ait : Vos estis sal terrae, ut caro hominis iam non esset terra vermigerans, sed sapiens sal peccati vermem occidens. Sed neque scabiem, inquit, agrestem habentem. Quae sit autem agrestis scabies diligentius debemus advertere. Agrum etenim saeculum esse Dominus in parabolis suis posuit dicens : Domine, tu bonum semen seminasti in agro tuo, unde hic zizania? et postea in exsolutione parabolae : Ager, inquit, saeculum est, et rursum : Simile est, inquit, regnum caelorum thesauro in agro absconso, ut per agrum saeculum indicaret, per thesaurum legem in qua Xpistus absconsus est. Cum igitur iam probatum sit agrum saeculum intellegi oportere, videndum est quae sit ista scabies agrestis. Nulli dubium, dilectissimi fratres, scabiem pro peccato nominari solere, sicut et lolium quod in eodem agro inimicus seminavit. Sed quare agrestem dixerit videamus : Neque, inquit, scabiem agrestem habentem. Peccatum etenim carnis in saeculo generatur. Proinde cum scabiem agrestem nominat, gentilium peccata denotat, id est idololatriam, incestum, adulterium, homicidium, concubitum masculorum ac molles viros qui omnem modum delinquendi excedunt, et non partem corporis sed totum corpus inficiunt. Qua de re, dilectissimi, saecularia ista et turpissima vitia carnis scabiem agrestem nominavit, id est saecularem, ut sicut pecus scabidum a sacrificio prohibetur, ita et quicumque homo ex corpore ecclesiastico, si haec crimina habuerit, a sacrificio Dei reprobetur. Plerumque etenim huiusmodi contagia Xpistianorum se corporibus interserunt. Et ideo a sacrificio, ut iam dixi, Domini reprobantur.

But he added further: "And having its tongue cut off." He has his tongue cut off who does not confess and proclaim his God, who does not meditate on the divine law, as it is written of the blessed man: "And on his law he will meditate day and night." Certainly he above all has his tongue cut off who in time of persecution, fearing the stench of prison or tortures or finally death itself, does not confess and praise his God. And so such people, who are said to have their tongue cut off because they do not confess their God, are rejected from the divine sacrifice. "Nor worm-ridden." Worm-ridden is said of one whose bodily members are overrun by the fault of an itch. These worms, then, are unclean spirits, which often insert themselves into the bodies of men and stir up the itch of lust and of various desires; they also send in the itch of avarice, the itch of unchastity, and the itch of all fleshly greed, and do not let the body or soul remain quiet in holiness and goodness, but corrupt everything and bring it to the rottenness of adultery. And so these worms, that is, unclean spirits, tempters and corrupters of souls and bodies, were first cast out by the salt of the heavenly word, so that they might restore the body, salted with the salt of divine wisdom, to its due holiness, as the Lord said to his disciples, "You are the salt of the earth," so that the flesh of man might no longer be worm-ridden earth, but wise salt killing the worm of sin. "Nor having," it says, "field mange." We must observe more carefully what field mange is. The Lord in his parables set down that the field is the world, saying: "Lord, you sowed good seed in your field; where then do these weeds come from?" and afterwards, in the explanation of the parable: "The field," he says, "is the world"; and again: "The kingdom of heaven is like a treasure hidden in a field," so that by the field he might indicate the world, and by the treasure the law, in which Christ is hidden. Since, then, it has now been proved that the field must be understood as the world, we must see what this field mange is. No one doubts, dearest brothers, that mange is customarily named for sin, as is the darnel that the enemy sowed in that same field. But let us see why he called it field mange: "Nor," it says, "having field mange." For the sin of the flesh is born in the world. So when he names field mange, he marks the sins of the Gentiles, that is, idolatry, incest, adultery, murder, lying with males, and effeminate men, who exceed every measure of sinning and infect not a part of the body but the whole body. Therefore, beloved, he named these worldly and most shameful vices of the flesh field mange, that is, worldly, so that, just as a mangy animal is barred from sacrifice, so too any man of the Church's body who has these crimes is rejected from the sacrifice of God. For such contagions often insinuate themselves into the bodies of Christians. And so, as I said, they are rejected from the Lord's sacrifice.

Lev 22:22 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 1:2 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 10:33 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 5:13 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:27 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:38 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:44 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:25 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 6:9 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The victim with its tongue cut off figures those who deny God in persecution; the worm-ridden figures bodies stirred by unclean spirits; field mange figures the gross sins of the pagan world.

  • The list of sins is Gregory's, translated as written.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); leaked footnote mark; punctuation slip; OCR slip; stray point): confitetur et laudat, Et 1deo → confitetur et laudat. Et ideo; Sed neque eermigerans → Sed neque vermigerans; plerumque 1n corporibus → plerumque in corporibus; et 1mmittunt → et immittunt; unde hic zizania? ? → unde hic zizania?; agrum saeculum. indicaret → agrum saeculum indicaret; videamus : JVeque → videamus : Neque; id est 1dololatriam → id est idololatriam; coneubitum → concubitum.

Topics: Persecution, Ethics

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 10.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 111–113; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/10-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-10-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

10.4Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 113–115

Sed adhuc adiecit : Neque impetiginem, inquit, habentem. Aliud est impetigo, aliud scabies agrestis. Sed iam scabiem agrestem diximus gentilium esse peccata, qui peccandi modum excedunt. Impetigo autem haereticorum collectio est, quae frequenter se in Ecclesiae corpus immergit. Ut enim impetigo circulum rotundum et liquidum facit, ita et haeretici collectiones simul et inlicitas et rotundas faciunt, hoc est, semper discentes et numquam ad scientiam veritatis pervenientes, infinitis quaestionibus volvuntur. Unde et beatus apostolus Paulus infinitas quaestiones et genealogias quae sine fine sunt prohibet. Haec est ergo rotunda collectio haereticorum quam impetiginem vocat, quae semper in quaestionibus volvitur et finem non habet resistendi. Omnis enim rotunditas ubi finem habeat nescit, quia semper volvitur et ubi finierit incipit. Quae licet de corpore sit, tamen corpus non est, sed est macula corpori. Unde beatus Ioannes apostolus de huiusmodi haereticis sic ait : Ex nobis exierunt, sed non erant ex nobis ; si enim ex nobis fuissent, nobiscum utique permansissent. Proinde cum divina scriptura hostiam quae impetiginem habuerit reprobat, haereticorum utique doctrinam execratur. Sed nec hostiam, inquit, amputatam aurem habentem in sacrificio offeres. Quid putatis, fratres, hostiam habentem aurem amputatam intellegi oportere, nisi eum hominem qui habet quidem aures ad audiendum verbum Dei, sed non facit quod iubetur? Unde et beatus apostolus duo ista genera hominum accusat, unum quod euangelio non credit, alterum quod non obaudit. Ita et hic quidem aures audiendi ut credat, sed faciendi non habet voluntatem, et ideo auris amputata dicitur, non quae non fuerit, sed quae videatur abscisa. Hi sunt utique qui audiunt quidem euangelium Xpisti; sed auditum ipsum amputant dum iussa facere contemnunt. Unde et beatus Paulus apostolus non auditores legis, sed factores apud Deum iustificari dicit. Ac per hoc iam planum vobis esse debet, quia, cum lex imaginaria hostiam amputatam aurem habentem sacrificio Dei reicit, non pecudis habitum, sed vitam eorum reprobat qui auditum sibi abscindunt non faciendo ea quae iussa sunt. Sed et hostiam, inquit, habentem caudam amputatam non offeres. Cauda est tutela quaedam animalibus, unde sibi muscas et tabanos et omnia adversa abigunt. Sed in comparatione harum rerum, quia non de pecoribus sed de hominibus lex sacra loquebatur, sicut et beatus apostolus tractat : Neque Deo cura est de bobus, sed pro nobis, inquit, hoc dixit, sic et in hoc loco non de cauda animalis, sed de conversatione hominis loquebatur. Quid enim muscas et tabanos intellegere debemus qui cauda abiguntur, nisi omnes daemones et erraticos spiritus aeris huius, qui plerumque non solum corpora sed et animas credentium vexant? Unde et beatus Paulus apostolus has muscas et tabanos, id est erraticos et volatiles aeris huius spiritus, meminit cum dicit : Non est vobis certamen adversus carnem et sanguinem, sed adversus principes huius mundi tenebrarum harum. Ergo omnia daemonia quae credentium corpora vel animas vexant, cauda religionis abigi debent. Quid est enim cauda nisi gratia fidei? Sicut enim cauda in proximo corpori est, ita et postremis temporibus gratia fidei spiritalis est data. Et ut cauda muscae et tabani abiguntur, ita et spiritali gratia, quae novissimis temporibus credentibus attributa est, omnia ista erratica et per aera huius

But he added further: "Nor having ringworm." Ringworm is one thing, field mange another. We have already said that field mange is the sins of the Gentiles, who exceed the measure of sinning. Ringworm is the gathering of heretics, which often plunges itself into the body of the Church. For as ringworm makes a round and moist circle, so heretics make gatherings both unlawful and round: that is, always learning and never arriving at the knowledge of the truth, they turn in endless questions. Hence the blessed apostle Paul forbids endless questions and genealogies without end. This, then, is the round gathering of heretics which he calls ringworm, which always turns in questions and has no end of resisting. For every circle does not know where it ends, because it always turns, and where it has ended, it begins. Though it is on the body, it is not the body but a blemish on the body. Hence the blessed apostle John says of such heretics: "They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would surely have remained with us." So, when the divine Scripture rejects a victim that has ringworm, it certainly curses the teaching of heretics. "Nor," it says, "shall you offer in sacrifice a victim having its ear cut off." What do you think, brothers, a victim with its ear cut off must be understood to mean, if not the man who has ears to hear the word of God but does not do what is commanded? Hence the blessed apostle too accuses these two kinds of people, one that does not believe the Gospel, the other that does not obey. So this one too has ears to hear so as to believe, but has no will to do, and so his ear is said to be cut off, not one that never existed but one that seems cut away. These are those who hear the Gospel of Christ, but cut off their very hearing when they scorn doing what is commanded. Hence the blessed apostle Paul says that not the hearers of the law but the doers are justified before God. And by this it must now be plain to you that, when the figurative law rejects from God's sacrifice a victim with its ear cut off, it is not the condition of the animal that it rejects but the life of those who cut off their own hearing by not doing what has been commanded. "Nor," it says, "shall you offer a victim having its tail cut off." The tail is a kind of protection for animals, with which they drive off flies and gadflies and everything hostile. But in comparing these things (since the sacred law was speaking not of cattle but of men, as the blessed apostle also explains, "God has no care for oxen, but he said this for us"), so in this place too it was speaking not of an animal's tail but of a man's conduct. What should we understand by the flies and gadflies driven off by the tail, if not all the demons and wandering spirits of this air, which often harass not only the bodies but also the souls of believers? Hence the blessed apostle Paul mentions these flies and gadflies, that is, the wandering and flying spirits of this air, when he says: "Our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers of this world of darkness." So all the demons that harass the bodies or souls of believers must be driven off by the tail of religion. For what is the tail if not the grace of faith? For as the tail is at the end of the body, so in the last times the grace of spiritual faith has been given. And as flies and gadflies are driven off by the tail, so by the spiritual grace that has been granted to believers in the last times all these wandering demons flying through the air of this

Lev 22:22 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Tim 3:7 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Tim 1:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Titus 3:9 (allusion, medium confidence) · 1 John 2:19 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 10:16 (allusion, medium confidence) · Rom 2:13 (allusion, high confidence) · Lev 22:23 (quotation, medium confidence) · 1 Cor 9:9 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 9:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 6:12 (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 2:2 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Ringworm figures heretics' endless circular questions; the victim with its ear cut off figures hearers who do not obey; the tail figures the grace of faith that drives off demons.

  • The tail cut off and the ear are Gregory's Old Latin list (compare Lev 22:23).
  • "God has no care for oxen": 1 Cor 9:9–10.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; broken hyphenation; punctuation slip; punctuation slip; OCR slip; stray point; stray point; OCR slip): genealogias quae sine fine sunt prohibet, Ilaec est → genealogias quae sine fine sunt prohibet. Haec est; finem non habet resistendi, Omnis → finem non habet resistendi. Omnis; ubi finierit. incipit → ubi finierit incipit; Sed nec hostiam, mquit → Sed nec hostiam, inquit; alterum. quod non obaudit → alterum quod non obaudit; dum 1ussa facere → dum iussa facere; iustificari dicit, Ac per hoc → iustificari dicit. Ac per hoc; Aoc dixit, sic et in hoe loco → hoc dixit, sic et in hoc loco; meminit cun: dicit : /Von est eobis certamen adeersus carnem et sanguinem, sed adeersus → meminit cum dicit : Non est vobis certamen adversus carnem et sanguinem, sed adversus; Sicut enim. cauda 1n proximo → Sicut enim cauda in proximo; creden- Uübus → credentibus.

Topics: Heresy

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 10.4 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 113–115; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/10-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-10-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

10.5Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 115–116

mundi volantia daemonia a fidelium corporibus atque animabus abiguntur. Non ergo immerito per comparationem pecudum conversatio hominum monstrabatur, quia sicut animal quod caudam amputatam habet non potest sibi adversantia depellere, ita et homo qui chrisma spiritale postremis temporibus per fidem acceptum amiserit, nullo modo hostia esse potest, sed immundis et erraticis spiritibus obnoxius erit. Et adiecit : Neque castratum, inquit, id est testibus amputatis, neque evulsum, non offeres illa Domino. Testes itaque amputati dicuntur hi qui, cum corpore masculi sint, vice tamen feminarum usum sui corporis praebent. Et ideo cum talem hostiam reprobat, reformatos in feminis viros damnat : eos proicit qui cum masculis coeunt. Unde apostolus huiusmodi homines a regno Dei excludit dicens : Neque molles neque masculorum concubitores regnum Dei videbunt. Sed nec illud munus offerendum dicit quod extraneo fuerit ablatum. Extraneus est qui extra fidem est et deificae disciplinae alienus, quod est diabolus, sicut et Dominus de Antixpisto dicit : Alius cum venerit ipsum recipietis. Et ideo alium, id est alienum, dicit. Ac proinde cum ab extraneo, id est alieno, acceptum hostiam offerri prohibet, eum hominem reprobat qui ab alienigena, id est diabolo, malitiae opera suscipiens, alienam voluntatem exercet. Qualis enim hostia huiusmodi Deo esse potest, qui non quae Dei sunt operatur? Et hoc est quod scriptura dicit de manu alienigenae acceptum Deo offerri non oportere. Sed iam sufficit haec hucusque tractasse.

world are driven off from the bodies and souls of the faithful. Not without reason, then, was the conduct of men shown by the comparison with cattle: for just as an animal whose tail is cut off cannot drive off what attacks it, so too a man who has lost the spiritual chrism received through faith in the last times can in no way be a sacrifice, but will be exposed to unclean and wandering spirits. And he added: "Nor castrated," it says, that is, with testicles cut off, "nor with them torn out; you shall not offer these to the Lord." Those are said to have their testicles cut off who, though they are males in body, give the use of their body in the place of women. And so, when he rejects such a victim, he condemns men re-formed into women; he casts out those who lie with males. Hence the apostle excludes such men from the kingdom of God, saying: "Neither the effeminate nor those who lie with males will see the kingdom of God." Nor, he says, is that gift to be offered which has been taken from a stranger. The stranger is he who is outside the faith and alien to the godly discipline, that is, the devil, as the Lord too says of Antichrist: "When another comes, him you will receive." And so he says "another," that is, an alien. And so, when he forbids the offering of a victim received from a stranger, that is, an alien, he rejects the man who, taking up the works of malice from the foreigner, that is, the devil, carries out an alien will. For what kind of sacrifice to God can such a man be, who does not do the things of God? And this is what Scripture says, that what is received from the hand of a foreigner must not be offered to God. But it is enough to have treated these things thus far.

Lev 22:24 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 6:9 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 6:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Lev 22:25 (allusion, high confidence) · John 5:43 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The victim without a tail figures one who has lost the chrism of faith; the castrated victim figures men who lie with males; the gift from a stranger figures works done at the devil's will.

  • The moral reading of the castrated victim is Gregory's, translated as written.
  • "When another comes, him you will receive": John 5:43, applied to Antichrist.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; OCR slips; stray marks; broken hyphenation; stray points): atque ani- : mabus → atque animabus; /Veque. castratum, inquit, id est testibus amputatis, neque eeulsum, non of[feres illa Domino. "Testes → Neque castratum, inquit, id est testibus amputatis, neque evulsum, non offeres illa Domino. Testes; JVeque molles neque masculorum concubitores resnum Dei eidebunt → Neque molles neque masculorum concubitores regnum Dei videbunt; Alzus cum venerit → Alius cum venerit; alium, 1d est alienum → alium, id est alienum; offerri non oportere... → offerri non oportere..

Topics: Ethics

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 10.5 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 115–116; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/10-5). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-10-5) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.