Tractates on the Books of Holy Scripture (Tractatus Origenis) 7.1–8.4

Latin text: Batiffol-Wilmart 1900 (Latin text: Batiffol and Wilmart (Paris, 1900), Internet Archive scan, public domain).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 7

7.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 76–78

Exsurrexit autem rex alius in Aegypto qui non noverat Ioseph. Dixitque genti suae : Ecce gens filiorum Israel magna facta est et potentior quam nos. Itaque venite subdamus illos ne casu superincrescant, et ne forte cum contigerit nobis pugna consentiant hi cum eis, et expugnent nos, et eiciant nos de terra nostra. Longum est et satis enorme de necessitate et de descensione populi in Aegyptum disputare. Manifesta enim est historia et admodum omnibus nota. Sed hoc magis laborandum est mihi, dilectissimi fratres, ut vim, rationem atque mysterium lectionis istius secundum spiritalem intellegentiam disseram. Id enim disputatione dignum est quod futurae veritatis imaginem habet, quippe cum nihil sit in divinis sacrisque litteris quod non vim praecipuam intellegentiae habeat, dum vel praeterita demonstrant, vel praesentia insinuant, vel futura commendant. Aegyptus itaque figura saeculi fuit, Pharao diaboli : filii Israel protoplasti imaginem induerant ex cuius origine censebantur : Moyses autem qui eos missus est liberare typum Xpisti gerebat. Mortuus est, inquit, Ioseph, et coepit populus iugum durissimae servitutis accipere : id est peccavit Adam et corrupta sunt omnia. Nam et ut Israel fame facta de terra repromissionis descendit in Aegyptum, ita et Adam escae causa descendit in saeculo : manducavit enim de interdicto ligno, et extra paradisum factus est. Denique quid subiungat audite : Imperavit, inquit, Pharao, id est diabolus : illis utique imperavit quibus iam imposuerat iugum gravissimae servitutis. Et quid imperavit? Ut ex luto et paleis lateres facerent. Quid mollius aut sordidius luto, quid vero levius aut abiectius paleis esse potest? Hoc ergo indicant paleae cum luto commixtae, quod, inanes et irrationales cogitationes, palearum scilicet similes, cum lutulentis et coenosis corporum vitiis permiscentes, gravissima et sordidissima crimina impulsu diabolicae tyrannidis exercere haberent: erant enim tunc carni et sanguini dediti et inlecebrarum turpitudinibus addicti. Faciebant itaque lateres, ut aut domicilia instruerent aut civitates munirent : id est comprimebant consilia terrena cum actibus vitiorum, ut aut pectora muro infidelitatis instruerent aut habitationes terreni corporis sordido opere ampliarent. Putabat enim Pharao, id est diabolus, ita omnem populum de his operibus praegravari, et ita corda eorum muro incredulitatis obcludi, ut nemo esset qui regnum eius aut debilitaret aut vinceret, nemo qui eum, quasi virum fortem victum ligaret et vasa eius diriperet. Sed bene tu, rex noster, qui adamantina claustra fregisti et seras indomiti ferri minuisti, omnesque munitiones illas diabolica, ut dixi, arte constructas ab omnium corde destruere dignatus es, regnumque eiusdem tyranni immitis passionis superasti virtute, captivam ducens captivitatem et dans dona hominibus secundum davidicam prophetiam, ut omnes tuos de eius potestate liberares!

"Now another king arose in Egypt who did not know Joseph. And he said to his nation: 'See, the nation of the sons of Israel has become great and stronger than we. Come, then, let us subdue them, lest they grow beyond us, and lest, if war should befall us, they side with them and conquer us and drive us out of our land.'" It would be long and very excessive to discuss the necessity and the descent of the people into Egypt. For the history is plain and well known to all. But I must rather labor, dearest brothers, to explain the force, meaning, and mystery of this reading according to the spiritual understanding. For what bears the image of future truth is worthy of discussion, since there is nothing in the divine and sacred writings that does not have a special force of meaning, as they either show things past, or suggest things present, or commend things to come. Egypt, then, was a figure of the world, Pharaoh of the devil; the sons of Israel had put on the image of the first-formed man, from whose origin they were reckoned; and Moses, who was sent to free them, bore the type of Christ. "Joseph died," it says, "and the people began to receive the yoke of the harshest slavery": that is, Adam sinned and all things were corrupted. For just as Israel, when famine came, went down from the land of promise into Egypt, so Adam went down into the world for the sake of food: for he ate of the forbidden tree and was put out of paradise. Hear, then, what it adds: "Pharaoh commanded," it says, that is, the devil; he commanded those on whom he had already laid the yoke of the heaviest slavery. And what did he command? That they make bricks from mud and straw. What could be softer or filthier than mud, what lighter or more worthless than straw? The straw mixed with mud indicates this: that, mixing empty and irrational thoughts, like straw, with the muddy and filthy vices of the body, they were to commit the gravest and filthiest crimes at the urging of the devil's tyranny; for they were then given over to flesh and blood and devoted to the foulness of allurements. So they made bricks, either to build houses or to fortify cities: that is, they pressed together earthly counsels with acts of vice, either to build up their breasts with the wall of unbelief or to enlarge the dwellings of the earthly body with filthy work. For Pharaoh, that is, the devil, thought that the whole people would be so weighed down by these works, and their hearts so shut in by the wall of unbelief, that there would be no one to weaken or conquer his kingdom, no one to bind him, like a strong man defeated, and plunder his goods. But well done, our King, you who broke the bars of adamant and shattered the bolts of untamed iron, and deigned to destroy from the hearts of all those fortifications built, as I said, by the devil's art, and overcame the kingdom of that cruel tyrant by the power of your passion, leading captivity captive and giving gifts to men according to David's prophecy, that you might free all who are yours from his power!

Exod 1:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 1:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 1:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 1:6 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 1:14 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 3:6 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 5:7 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 12:29 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 107:16 (106:16 LXX) (allusion, high confidence) · Isa 45:2 (allusion, medium confidence) · Ps 68:18 (67:19 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 4:8 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Egypt figures the world and Pharaoh the devil; the bricks of mud and straw are vices joined to empty thoughts; Christ, the new Moses, breaks the devil's power.

  • "Bind the strong man and plunder his goods": Matt 12:29. "Bars of adamant ... bolts of iron": Ps 107:16; Isa 45:2.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; stray point; stray points): FExsurrexit autem rex alius in Aegypto qui non noverat loseph. → Exsurrexit autem rex alius in Aegypto qui non noverat Ioseph.; de terra nostra !. → de terra nostra.; dilectissimi. fratres, ut. vim → dilectissimi fratres, ut vim; Mortuus est, inquit, Joseph → Mortuus est, inquit, Ioseph; Zmperaeit → Imperavit; Et. quid imperavit → Et quid imperavit; permüuscentes, gravissima et sordidissima erimina → permiscentes, gravissima et sordidissima crimina; desiruere → destruere.

Topics: Christology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 7.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 76–78; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/7-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-7-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

7.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 78–81

Sed praecepit, inquit, Pharao obstetricibus dicens ut, cum mulieres hebraeae parere coepissent, masculos occiderent, feminas vivificarent. O crudelem et hebetem tyrannum ut masculos iuberet interfici et feminas vivificare! Hoc quidem et Herodes fecit dum Xpistum requirit in pueris. Sed quid est hoc quod iubet immanissimus hostis ut masculi occidantur, feminae vivant? Qui si gentem Hebraeorum extinguere volebat, et feminas pariter cum masculis interfici praecepisset, quia possent iterum feminae quae servabantur masculos procreare, qui hostes eius existerent. Quid te itaque decipis? Quid te circumvenit caeca crudelitas? Saevis et parcis, interficis et indulges. Ingens causa et magna quaedam ratio versatur, dilectissimi fratres. Sed videamus quid sibi velit arcani istius scena composita quae masculos iubet occidi, feminas vivere. Hoc ergo laborabat diabolus ut fortissimos et viriles animi sensus, unde caelestia sapimus et divina, id est rationem, prudentiam, constantiam, innocentiam et fidem, in homine occideret, et illud in eo viveret quod femineum et imbecillum et fragile et pronum ad vitia habebatur, id est cupiditas, libido, avaritia, luxuria, insania et cetera his similia quae in feminarum figura vivere volebat in populo, id est ut interfectis virtutibus vitia remanerent. Sed obstetrices Hebraeorum non oboedierunt Pharaoni. Bene autem faciebat Deus obstetricibus et multiplicabatur populus. Quantum ad spiritalem sensum pertinet, obstetrices istae, quae non oboedierunt Pharaoni, animae sunt mentesque sanctorum quae Pharaoni diabolo non solum non obtemperare volebant, verum masculos, id est virtutes bonorum operum, quasi quemdam divini seminis partum de cordis utero obstetricantes, in lucem cogitationis producebant, ut robur fidei praevaleret. Et ob hoc benefaciebat Deus huiusmodi animis, quae non Pharaoni diabolo, sed iussis caelestibus serviebant. Sed ut complerentur divina mysteria, quemadmodum Moyses, qui typum Xpisti gerebat, funestum illud Pharaonis edictum evaserit videamus. Sumpsit, inquit, mater sua tibin, et linivit eam pice et bitumine, et misit infantem in ea, et posuit eam ad ripam fluminis. Observabat autem soror eius a longe, ut videret quid ei futurum esset. Descendit autem filia Pharaonis lavari ad flumen, et cum vidisset tibin iuxta ripam, mittens puellam sustulit eam. Aperiens autem vidit puerum plorantem in tibin, et pepercit ei, et dixit : De infantibus Hebraeorum est hic. Mater itaque Moysi figura erat Synagogae patrum ac prophetarum, ex quorum origine Xpistus secundum carnem est natus, cuius typum Moyses tunc temporis indicabat. Qui cum natus esset speciosus infans tribus mensibus occultabatur a matre : mirifice dicit speciosum infantem, quia ipse omni pulchritudine pulchrior est, omni formositate formosior, sicut de eo scriptum est : Speciosus forma nimis prae filiis hominum. Sed quid isti tres menses significent videamus. Tres, inquam, menses divinae trinitatis sacramenta portendunt, quia trinitas a Synagoga patrum occultabatur in Xpisto, sicut apostolus ait : Mysterium absconditum a saeculis antiquis, quod nemo principum agnovit, quod nunc manifestatum est gentibus. Sed et ipse Salvator : Simile est, inquit, regnum caelorum thesauro abscondito in agro. Thesaurus hic Xpistus est, qui in agro saeculi ab scripturis veteris testamenti habebatur absconsus, quia illic antiquae legis sacramenta in veteribus monumentis quibusdam imaginibus obvoluta erant, et allegoricae aenigmatis typica mysteria inter ipsas figurarum umbras adhuc abstrusa atque recondita latitabant. Nam et tres isti menses nonaginta dies faciunt, ex quibus quadraginta ante passionem quibus a diabolo tentatur Dominus, et quinquaginta post resurrectionem quibus suppletis Spiritum Sanctum credentibus misit. Denique post haec temporis spatia percepto, ut dixi, Sancto Spiritu, universis gentibus innotuit qui erat apud Israel in lege et prophetis absconsus.

"But Pharaoh commanded the midwives," it says, "that when the Hebrew women began to give birth they should kill the males and keep the females alive." O cruel and dull tyrant, to order the males to be killed and the females kept alive! Herod too did this when he sought Christ among the children. But what is this, that the most savage enemy orders the males to be killed and the females to live? If he wanted to wipe out the nation of the Hebrews, he would have ordered the females to be killed along with the males, since the females who were spared could again bear males who would become his enemies. Why then do you deceive yourself? Why does blind cruelty get the better of you? You rage and you spare, you kill and you indulge. A great cause and a great reason is at work here, dearest brothers. Let us see what the staging of this secret means, which orders the males to be killed and the females to live. The devil was laboring to kill in man the strongest and manly senses of the soul, by which we savor heavenly and divine things, that is, reason, prudence, constancy, innocence, and faith, and to let live in him what was held to be womanish, weak, fragile, and prone to vice, that is, greed, lust, avarice, luxury, madness, and the like, which he wished to live in the people in the figure of the females: that is, that when the virtues were killed the vices might remain. "But the midwives of the Hebrews did not obey Pharaoh. And God dealt well with the midwives, and the people multiplied." As to the spiritual sense, these midwives who did not obey Pharaoh are the souls and minds of the saints, which not only refused to obey Pharaoh the devil but, as midwives delivering from the womb of the heart the males, that is, the virtues of good works, like an offspring of divine seed, brought them forth into the light of thought, so that the strength of faith might prevail. And for this God dealt well with such souls, which served not Pharaoh the devil but the heavenly commands. But so that the divine mysteries might be fulfilled, let us see how Moses, who bore the type of Christ, escaped that deadly edict of Pharaoh. "His mother," it says, "took a basket and smeared it with pitch and bitumen, and put the infant in it, and placed it at the bank of the river. And his sister watched from afar, to see what would become of him. And Pharaoh's daughter came down to bathe at the river, and when she saw the basket by the bank, she sent her maid and took it up. And opening it she saw the boy crying in the basket, and spared him, and said, 'This is one of the Hebrews' infants.'" Moses' mother, then, was a figure of the Synagogue of the fathers and prophets, from whose origin Christ was born according to the flesh, whose type Moses then indicated. When he was born, a beautiful infant, he was hidden by his mother for three months. Wonderfully it says "a beautiful infant," because he is more beautiful than all beauty, fairer than all fairness, as it is written of him: "Beautiful in form beyond the sons of men." But let us see what these three months signify. The three months, I say, foretell the mysteries of the divine Trinity, because the Trinity was hidden in Christ from the Synagogue of the fathers, as the apostle says: "The mystery hidden from ancient ages, which none of the rulers knew, which has now been made known to the Gentiles." And the Savior himself says: "The kingdom of heaven is like a treasure hidden in a field." This treasure is Christ, who was held hidden in the field of the world by the scriptures of the Old Testament, because there the mysteries of the ancient law were wrapped in certain images in the old records, and the typical mysteries of allegorical riddles still lay concealed and stored away among the very shadows of figures. Moreover these three months make ninety days, forty of them before the passion, in which the Lord is tempted by the devil, and fifty after the resurrection, at the completion of which he sent the Holy Spirit to believers. After these spans of time, then, when the Holy Spirit had been received, as I said, he who was hidden among Israel in the law and the prophets became known to all nations.

Exod 1:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 2:16 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 1:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 1:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:3 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:6 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:2 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 45:2 (44:3 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Col 1:26 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 2:8 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 13:44 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 4:2 (allusion, medium confidence) · Acts 2:1 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Pharaoh's order to kill the males figures the devil's attack on the soul's virtues; the midwives are holy souls; the infant Moses, hidden three months, figures Christ hidden in the old covenant.

  • The "forty days before the passion" of temptation is Gregory's reckoning (compare Matt 4:2); the fifty days lead to Pentecost.
  • The contrast of manly virtues and womanish vices is Gregory's allegory, translated as written.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; stray point; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; stray comma; stray point; words run together): feminas veieificarent → feminas vivificarent; interficl → interfici; caeca. crudelitas → caeca crudelitas; quae inasculos → quae masculos; diviniseminis → divini seminis; sed 1ussis → sed iussis; Obsereabat autem soror eius a longe, ut eideret → Observabat autem soror eius a longe, ut videret; laeari ad flumen → lavari ad flumen; eidit puerum plorantem in. tibin → vidit puerum plorantem in tibin; Hebraeorum est hic !. → Hebraeorum est hic.; S3ynagogae → Synagogae; Qui eum natus esset → Qui cum natus esset; Speciosus forma, nimis → Speciosus forma nimis; quid isti (res menses → quid isti tres menses; regnum. caelorum → regnum caelorum; sacramenta 1n veteribus → sacramenta in veteribus.

Topics: Christology, Trinity

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 7.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 78–81; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/7-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-7-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

7.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 81–83

Tibin autem in quo missus est infans et ad ripam fluminis est positus, typum sanctae plebis perspicue indicabat. Tibin enim genus est vasculi in modum scrinii ex virgultis agrestibus contextum. Denique hoc vasculum ex hebraea lingua alii capsam, alii cistolam interpretati sunt, quod nos expressius, ut iam dixi, scrinium appellamus, quia illic omnia legis arcana in Xpisto erant reposita. Nam et sicut hoc vas tibin dicitur [....] duo sunt enim genera ignium, unum ex tentatione maligni quo virtus patientiae nostrae persecutionis aestu probatur, quia Oportet eos, inquit, per multas tribulationes introire in regnum Dei; et alterum ex divini, ut saepe dixi, Spiritus gratia quo fidelium mentes et usque ad finem perseverantium inlustrantur. Sed age nunc videamus cur ad ripam fluminis Moyses infans fuerit expositus. Mirifice sane dictum est hoc, quia non alibi Dominus, cuius Moyses typum induerat, quam ad flumen lavaeri et ad aquam baptismatis a credentibus invenitur. Quod autem plorabat infans significabat quia Xpistus veteris hominis peccata deflebat. Unde et ad resuscitandum Lazarum flevit, Iudaeorum perfidiam deplorans, quia tanta Dei mirabilia credituri non essent. Et adiecit scriptura dicens : Tunc soror ipsius speculabatur a longe ut videret quid ei futurum esset. Quae haec soror ipsius, nisi plebs illa quae in novissimis temporibus sub Elia ex Israel creditura est? Haec enim a longe, id est a fine saeculi, sollicite in spiritu prospicit et observat qui sint qui per lavacrum aquae salutaris Xpistum Dei filium recipere habebunt. Denique adiunxit : Tunc, inquit, descendit filia Pharaonis ut lavaretur ad flumen, et vidit tibin, et collegit, et aperuit, et vidit infantem, et dixit : Hic ex filiis Hebraeorum est. Sed quid haec filia Pharaonis indicet, vel cur collegerit infantem, diligentius advertamus. Filiam ergo Pharaonis non aliam intellego quam ex gentibus Ecclesiam lavaeri vitalis sanctificatione purgatam, quae Xpistum a Synagoga matre carnali expulsum atque expositum quasi infantem, quia tunc parvulus videbatur quando in homine cernebatur, in semetipsa collegit et servat, futurum utique iam non illius matris quae eum expulit et exponit, sed illius quae eum collegit et servat. Denique cum diceretur ei Ecce mater tua et fratres tui, ille respondit : Quae est mater mea aut qui sunt fratres mei? Et respexit ad discipulos suos et ait : Ecce mater mea et fratres mei. Omnes enim qui faciunt praecepta patris mei, hi sunt mihi mater et frater et soror. Itaque Xpisti mater iam non est Synagoga, quae eum in semetipsa servare non potuit, sed Ecclesia ex gentibus veniens, quae eum ab ipso tentationis tempore credendo collegit, et regalibus institutis ut dignum erat Dei filium in mentis suae domicilio educavit, ubi et usque ad mensuram perfecti viri perductus, et rex et iudex vivorum et mortuorum inventus est. Non quod Dei filius aliquando parvulus fuerit, sed tunc parvulus visus est cum semetipsum exinanivit formam servi suscipiendo, et se faciendo ut granum sinapis, quod minus omnibus oleribus in horto pectoris seminatur, sed nihilominus maius omnibus efficitur, cum in futuri aevi regno dinoscitur.

The basket in which the infant was put and placed at the river's bank clearly indicated the type of the holy people. For a basket (tibin) is a kind of small vessel like a box, woven of wild twigs. Some have rendered this vessel from the Hebrew language as "chest," others as "little coffer," which we, as I said, more expressly call a "box," because there all the secrets of the law were stored up in Christ. For just as this vessel is called a basket ... for there are two kinds of fire: one from the temptation of the evil one, by which the virtue of our patience is tested in the heat of persecution, since "we must," it says, "enter the kingdom of God through many tribulations"; and the other from the grace of the divine Spirit, as I have often said, by which the minds of the faithful and of those who persevere to the end are enlightened. But come now, let us see why the infant Moses was exposed at the river's bank. This is wonderfully said, because the Lord, whose type Moses had put on, is found by believers nowhere else than at the river of washing and the water of baptism. That the infant was crying signified that Christ wept over the sins of the old man. Hence too he wept at the raising of Lazarus, lamenting the faithlessness of the Jews, because they would not believe such great wonders of God. And the Scripture added, saying: "Then his sister watched from afar to see what would become of him." Who is this sister of his, if not that people from Israel which is to believe under Elijah in the last times? For she from afar, that is, from the end of the age, anxiously looks out in the spirit and watches who they are who will receive Christ, the Son of God, through the washing of saving water. Then he added: "Then," it says, "Pharaoh's daughter came down to bathe at the river, and saw the basket, and picked it up, and opened it, and saw the infant, and said: 'This is one of the sons of the Hebrews.'" Let us observe more carefully what this daughter of Pharaoh indicates, or why she picked up the infant. By Pharaoh's daughter I understand nothing other than the Church from the Gentiles, cleansed by the sanctification of the life-giving washing, which picked up and keeps in herself Christ, driven out and exposed by the Synagogue, his mother according to the flesh, as an infant (for he seemed a little one when he was seen in a man), he who would now belong not to that mother who drove him out and exposes him, but to her who picked him up and keeps him. Indeed, when it was said to him, "Behold, your mother and your brothers," he answered: "Who is my mother, or who are my brothers?" And he looked at his disciples and said: "Behold my mother and my brothers. For all who do the precepts of my Father are my mother and brother and sister." So the mother of Christ is no longer the Synagogue, which could not keep him in herself, but the Church coming from the Gentiles, which picked him up by believing from the very time of temptation and raised him, as was fitting for the Son of God, with royal training in the dwelling of her mind, where he was brought to the measure of a mature man and was found king and judge of the living and the dead. Not that the Son of God was ever a little one, but he was seen as a little one when he emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, and made himself like a mustard seed, which is sown smaller than all herbs in the garden of the heart, but nonetheless becomes greater than all when it is recognized in the kingdom of the age to come.

Textual problem in this passage: see the notes.

Exod 2:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Acts 14:22 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 10:22 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 2:6 (allusion, high confidence) · John 11:35 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 2:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Mal 4:5 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 2:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 12:47 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 12:48 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 12:49 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 12:50 (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 4:13 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Tim 4:1 (allusion, medium confidence) · Phil 2:7 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:31 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:32 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The basket figures the holy people; the river is baptism; Moses' sister is the Israel that will believe under Elijah; Pharaoh's daughter is the Gentile Church that receives Christ.

  • Several lines are lost in the digital text after "this vessel is called a basket" (marked [....]); they explained the pitch and bitumen, which Gregory reads as two kinds of fire.
  • Christ "made himself like a mustard seed": Gregory's application of Matt 13:31–32.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; stray point; OCR slips; stray point): arcana in. Xpisto → arcana in Xpisto; sicut hoe vas → sicut hoc vas; sollicite in spiritu. prospicit → sollicite in spiritu prospicit; ut eideret quid ei futurum → ut videret quid ei futurum; ut laearetur ad flumen, et eidit tibin, et collegit, et aperuit, et eidit infantem, et dixit : Hic ex filis → ut lavaretur ad flumen, et vidit tibin, et collegit, et aperuit, et vidit infantem, et dixit : Hic ex filiis; quia tune parvulus → quia tunc parvulus; Écce mater tua et fratres tui, ile respondit → Ecce mater tua et fratres tui, ille respondit; Écce mater mea et fratres. mei. → Ecce mater mea et fratres mei.; Dei fillum → Dei filium; filius ah quando → filius aliquando; cum 1n futuri → cum in futuri.

Topics: Baptism

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 7.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 81–83; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/7-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-7-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

7.4Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 83–86

Sed cum vellet, inquit, filia Pharaonis eum nutrire, dixit soror ipsius filiae Pharaonis : Vis ut vocem tibi mulierem nutrientem de Hebraeis, et nutriet tibi infantem? Et dixit ei filia Pharaonis : Vade. Et vocavit, inquit, matrem pueri. Et dixit ei filia Pharaonis : Conserva mihi infantem hunc, et nutri mihi eum. Vide quid dicat : Conserva mihi et nutri mihi, inquit, infantem hunc. Mihi, inquit, non tibi. Ecclesiae enim ex gentibus iam erat necessarius, non Synagogae. Sed interim pro tempore est redditus Synagogae, ex qua per legem et prophetas secundum carnem fuerat procreatus, sicut apostolus dicit : Quorum patres, ex quibus Xpistus qui est benedictus in saecula. Et quia hoc divinitus statutum erat ut non statim gentibus Xpistus traderetur, sed prius populo suo redderetur ut eis regnum Dei praedicaret, sicut ipse dixit : Non sum missus nisi ad oves quae perierunt domus Israel, et Non expedit tollere panem filiorum et dare canibus, proinde non statim eum suscepit filia Pharaonis, id est Ecclesia ex gentibus, sed redditus est matri, quia necesse erat ut prius secundum priscam legem nutriretur et lac eiusdem legis velut potum acciperet, sicut ipse ait Non veni legem evacuare sed adimplere. Quod et fecit, dum omnem legalem munificentiam et implet et servat. Denique cum et leprosum mundasset in sabbato, iussit ei ut ostenderet se sacerdoti et secundum legem offerret ei aut par turturum aut duos pullos columbinos. Hoc est ergo quod redditus est infans matri suae ut eum lactaret, quia Xpistus a nativitate usque ad passionem in Synagoga iuxta observationem legis erat futurus, et sic filiae Pharaonis, id est Ecclesiae ex gentibus, iam adultus, hoc est post resurrectionem, reddendus. Necdum enim, ut euangelista ait, magnificatus fuerat Xpistus, quia necdum fuerat passus. Denique et post ipsam venerabilem resurrectionem statim ad gentes misit apostolos dicens : Ite ad omnes gentes, baptizantes eos in nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus Sancti. Cum ergo Xpistus ad nationes gentium apostolos misit, tunc eum mater sua secundum carnem Synagoga reddidit filiae Pharaonis, id est Ecclesiae ex gentibus. Sed fortassis aliquis dicat : Si Pharao diaboli figura erat, quomodo filia eius in typum Ecclesiae deputatur et Dominum collegisse perhibetur? Accipite rationem. Omnes enim gentes, antequam credant et antequam ex aqua et superna virtute renascantur, filii diaboli et filii irae dicuntur et viperarum natio appellantur, sicuti apostolus ait : Et nos fuimus aliquando filii irae, nunc autem filii Dei, et Ioannes Baptista : Natio viperarum. Videtis itaque per paenitentiam praeteritorum delictorum et lavaeri vitalis sanctificationem filios diaboli et filios irae et viperarum posse filios Dei effici et in Ecclesiae corpore deputari. Et proinde omnes gentes saeculi, quarum typum in se filia Pharaonis gerebat, licet filii diaboli quasi Pharaonis ante fidem nuncupentur, tamen cum Deo credunt et templum ipsius efficiuntur, tunc membra Xpisti et corpus Ecclesiae nuncupantur. Haec interim de multis pauca dixisse sufficiat. Praestabit Deus pater omnipotens et mihi gratiam in adapertionem oris ac sensus mei ad intellegenda divina mysteria, et vobis spiritalium charismatum dona concedat, ut omnia quae in thesauris caelestibus habentur scripta, et ego ratione congrua disseram, et vos possitis, quia lex spiritalis est, spiritaliter assequi quae spiritaliter disputantur.

"But when Pharaoh's daughter wished to nurse him," it says, "his sister said to Pharaoh's daughter: 'Do you want me to call you a nursing woman from the Hebrews, and she will nurse the infant for you?' And Pharaoh's daughter said to her: 'Go.' And she called," it says, "the boy's mother. And Pharaoh's daughter said to her: 'Keep this infant for me, and nurse him for me.'" See what she says: "Keep for me and nurse for me," she says, "this infant." For me, she says, not for you. For he was now necessary to the Church from the Gentiles, not to the Synagogue. But meanwhile, for a time, he was given back to the Synagogue, from which he had been begotten according to the flesh through the law and the prophets, as the apostle says: "Whose are the fathers, from whom is Christ, who is blessed forever." And since it had been divinely ordained that Christ should not be handed over to the Gentiles at once, but should first be given back to his own people to preach the kingdom of God to them, as he himself said, "I was sent only to the sheep that are lost of the house of Israel," and "It is not right to take the children's bread and give it to the dogs," therefore Pharaoh's daughter, that is, the Church from the Gentiles, did not take him up at once, but he was given back to his mother, because he first had to be nursed according to the ancient law and receive the milk of that law as his drink, as he himself says: "I came not to abolish the law but to fulfill it." And he did so, both fulfilling and keeping every bounty of the law. Indeed, when he had cleansed a leper on the sabbath, he ordered him to show himself to the priest and, according to the law, offer him either a pair of turtledoves or two young pigeons. This, then, is the infant's being given back to his mother to be nursed: Christ, from his birth to his passion, was to be in the Synagogue according to the observance of the law, and then to be given back, now grown, that is, after the resurrection, to Pharaoh's daughter, that is, to the Church from the Gentiles. For Christ, as the evangelist says, had not yet been glorified, because he had not yet suffered. Indeed, immediately after his venerable resurrection he sent the apostles to the Gentiles, saying: "Go to all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit." When, then, Christ sent the apostles to the nations of the Gentiles, then his mother according to the flesh, the Synagogue, gave him back to Pharaoh's daughter, that is, to the Church from the Gentiles. But perhaps someone may say: "If Pharaoh was a figure of the devil, how is his daughter counted as a type of the Church and said to have taken up the Lord?" Hear the reason. All nations, before they believe and before they are reborn of water and the power from above, are called sons of the devil and children of wrath, and are named a brood of vipers, as the apostle says: "We too were once children of wrath, but now sons of God," and John the Baptist: "Brood of vipers." You see, then, that through repentance for past offenses and the sanctification of the life-giving washing, sons of the devil, children of wrath, and offspring of vipers can become sons of God and be counted in the body of the Church. And so all the nations of the world, whose type Pharaoh's daughter bore in herself, though before faith they are called sons of the devil as of Pharaoh, yet when they believe in God and become his temple, are then called members of Christ and the body of the Church. Let it suffice meanwhile to have said these few things out of many. May God the Father almighty grant me grace in the opening of my mouth and mind to understand the divine mysteries, and grant you the gifts of spiritual graces, so that I may explain with fitting reason everything written in the heavenly treasuries, and you, since the law is spiritual, may grasp spiritually what is spiritually discussed.

Exod 2:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 2:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 9:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 15:24 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 15:26 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 8:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Lev 14:22 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 7:39 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 28:19 (quotation, high confidence) · John 3:5 (allusion, high confidence) · John 8:44 (allusion, medium confidence) · Eph 2:3 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 John 3:2 (echo, medium confidence) · Matt 3:7 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 3:16 (allusion, medium confidence) · Eph 6:19 (allusion, medium confidence) · Rom 7:14 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 2:13 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Moses returned to his mother to be nursed figures Christ ministering first under the law to Israel, then given to the Gentile Church after the resurrection; Pharaoh's daughter figures nations reborn in baptism.

  • Gregory's "cleansed a leper on the sabbath" conflates Matt 8:2–4 with the sabbath healings; the offering of birds is from Lev 14:22 (compare Luke 2:24).
  • "Children of wrath ... now sons of God" combines Eph 2:3 with 1 John 3:2.
  • A leaked running head ("VIIIJ") at the end is removed.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; OCR slips; leaked footnote marks; leaked footnote mark; leaked running head; stray point): filia. Pharaonis : Vade. Et eocaeit, mquit, matrem pueri. Kt dixit ei filia Pharaonis : Conserea mihi → filia Pharaonis : Vade. Et vocavit, inquit, matrem pueri. Et dixit ei filia Pharaonis : Conserva mihi; Vide quid dicat : Conserea mihi → Vide quid dicat : Conserva mihi; non tibi !. → non tibi.; Xpistus qui est. benedictus → Xpistus qui est benedictus; sicut Ipse dixit : /Von sum missus nisi ad ovees quae perierunt domus Israel, eX Non → sicut ipse dixit : Non sum missus nisi ad oves quae perierunt domus Israel, et Non; Non eeni legem eeacuare → Non veni legem evacuare; /Vecdum enim → Necdum enim; /te ad omnes gentes → Ite ad omnes gentes; dicat : $1 Pharao → dicat : Si Pharao; filia eius 1n typum → filia eius in typum; £t nos fuimus aliquando filü irae, nunc autem filii Dei !, et Ioannes Baptista : /Vatio ezperarum ?. → Et nos fuimus aliquando filii irae, nunc autem filii Dei, et Ioannes Baptista : Natio viperarum.; disputantur. VIIIJ → disputantur..

Topics: Baptism

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 7.4 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 83–86; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/7-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-7-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 8

8.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 86–89

Locutus est Dominus ad Moysen dicens : Loquere filiis Israel et dices ad eos : In mente habetote diem sabbatorum sanctificare eum. Sex dies operaberis et facies omnia tua, septima autem dies sabbatum est Domini Dei tui. Non facies in illo die ullum opus, tu et filius tuus et filia tua et puella tua, bos tuus et subiunctorium tuum et omne pecus tuum, et reliqua. Multa quidem praecepta sunt divinae legis in hac lectione congesta, quae omnia in uno tractatu disserere non tam difficile quam enorme est, nec arduum sed prolixum. Et proinde cetera differentes, de sola interim sabbati observatione tractemus, sine qua Iudaei omnem hominem fore ab spe vitae aeternae alienum putant. Quod quidem vere et merito dicerent, si prius quid sit sabbatum nossent. Sed homines, in solum ventrem profusi et nihil aliud quam caro, totum quidquid scripturis divinis relatum est et spiritaliter intellegendum, quia lex spiritalis est, in solo corporis intellectu traducunt, dum circa officinam ventris addicti nihil nisi carnem colere noverunt. Denique et cum pecoribus hanc legem sabbati acceperunt, ut, dum pari forma utriusque lex datur tam hominum quam pecudum, procul dubio eos homines pecora esse monstraret quibus testamentum cum pecoribus dedit, cum dicit : Non facies in illo die ullum opus, neque bos tuus, neque subiunctorium tuum, neque omne pecus tuum. Unde si in sabbato salus hominis esset, cur et pecoribus par legis forma daretur, nisi forte aeternae vitae gloriam et regnum caelorum pecoribus repromissum existimant? Hanc legem quidem pecoribus comparatam verius credendum est, quia in sabbato otiosis ceteris membris solus pascitur venter. Si autem bonum hominis differt a pecude, ut bonum hominis in sola sit mente, pecudis in carne, et pecudis sit carnem saginare, hominis sit animam divina ratione nutrire, utquid sabbatum quasi pro sacramento divinae religionis attendunt epulis tantum et mensae servientes, nec sic otiosi sunt, quos in percipiendis cibis videas esse occupatos? Sed respondere potest Iudaeus : Si sabbatum observandum non erat, cur scriptum est dicente Moyse : In mente habete diem sabbati sanctificare eum? Quid ergo? Moyses ipse in mente non habuit diem sabbati, qui quadraginta diebus ieiunans frequenter dies sabbatorum transmisit, quos utique profanabat impastus, si sabbato ieiunare non licet : nam si solemnitas huius sic celebranda est ut solummodo serviatur ventri, Moyses ipse legislator, ut iam dixi, in crimine est, qui quadraginta diebus ieiunans sabbatum non servavit. Elias quoque quadraginta diebus et noctibus similiter impastus ventrem tot diebus sabbatorum inopia ciborum exhausit, fatigavit et exercuit : contra legem ergo utique fecit, si sabbati sacramentum est copia ciborum et cruditas ventris. Par accusatio etiam Danielem tenet, non quidem tantos dies sabbatorum secundum istos profanantem, sed et tamen profanantem : hic etenim tribus septimanis ieiunavit. Item Zacharias non tantum quartis et quintis et decimis, sed ipsis quoque septimis ieiunavit, id est sabbato. Et quomodo isti caelestes tot visiones videre digni fuerunt, si profanatorum sabbatorum rei esse meruerunt? Aut si crimen summum est sabbatis aliquid agere, quomodo Iesus Nave successor Moysi octo diebus contextis atque continuis, inter quos erat utique et sabbati dies, exercitum armatum produxit, et castra et arcam Dei cum sacerdotibus et omnibus regionibus movit? Circa muros etiam Hiericho circumduxit agmen, et octavo die ut tubis sacris canerent sacerdotibus imperavit. Et si possit denotari, fortassis dies sabbati fuit quo muri Hiericho ad tubarum murmurantium strepitum sine bello ruerunt, et ad clamorem armati populi civitas tota terrore deposita in ditionem cecidit victoris exercitus, et sanguis fusus est, et spolia capta et praeda ex hostibus reportata est. Unde, inquam, tanta et tam insignis contra hostes victoria, si sabbato nihil agere licebat ? Aut si ex praecepto legis hoc factum est, sciant Iudaei otium sabbati sui, quod longe olim fuerat iussum, postea sine crimine fuisse solutum.

"The Lord spoke to Moses, saying: 'Speak to the sons of Israel and say to them: Keep in mind the day of the sabbaths, to sanctify it. Six days you shall work and do all your tasks, but the seventh day is the sabbath of the Lord your God. You shall do no work on that day, you and your son and your daughter and your maidservant, your ox and your beast of burden and all your cattle,'" and so on. Many precepts of the divine law are gathered in this reading, and to discuss them all in one tractate would be not so much difficult as excessive, not arduous but long-winded. So, deferring the rest, let us for the moment treat only the observance of the sabbath, without which the Jews think every man is a stranger to the hope of eternal life. They would say this truly and rightly, if they first knew what the sabbath is. But men given over to the belly alone and nothing but flesh render everything related in the divine Scriptures, which must be understood spiritually, since the law is spiritual, in a merely bodily sense, since, bound to the workshop of the belly, they know how to cultivate nothing but the flesh. Indeed they received this law of the sabbath together with the cattle, so that, since the law is given in the same form to both men and beasts, it would show beyond doubt that those men are cattle to whom he gave the covenant together with the cattle, when he says: "You shall do no work on that day, nor your ox, nor your beast of burden, nor any of your cattle." So if man's salvation lay in the sabbath, why was the same form of law given to the cattle, unless perhaps they think the glory of eternal life and the kingdom of heaven were promised to cattle? It is truer to believe that this law is likened to cattle, because on the sabbath, while the other members are idle, only the belly is fed. But if the good of man differs from that of a beast, so that the good of man lies in the mind alone and that of the beast in the flesh, and it belongs to the beast to fatten the flesh and to man to nourish the soul with divine reason, why do they observe the sabbath as though it were a sacrament of divine religion, serving only feasts and the table, and are not even idle then, since you see them busy in taking their food? But the Jew may answer: "If the sabbath was not to be observed, why is it written, as Moses says: 'Keep in mind the day of the sabbath, to sanctify it'?" What then? Did Moses himself not keep the sabbath day in mind, he who, fasting forty days, often let sabbath days pass, which he would certainly have profaned by going unfed, if it is not lawful to fast on the sabbath? For if this solemnity must be celebrated only by serving the belly, Moses himself, the lawgiver, as I said, is guilty, who fasting forty days did not keep the sabbath. Elijah too, likewise unfed for forty days and nights, exhausted, wearied, and exercised his belly for so many sabbath days by lack of food: so he certainly acted against the law, if the sacrament of the sabbath is plenty of food and a full belly. The same charge holds Daniel too, who profaned, by their reckoning, not so many sabbath days, but still profaned them: for he fasted three weeks. Zechariah also fasted not only in the fourth, fifth, and tenth months, but also in the seventh, that is, on the sabbath. How were these men found worthy to see so many heavenly visions, if they deserved to be guilty of profaned sabbaths? Or if it is a supreme crime to do anything on the sabbath, how did Joshua son of Nun, Moses' successor, lead out an armed army for eight joined and continuous days, among which there was certainly a sabbath day, and move the camp and the ark of God with the priests and all the districts? He also led the column around the walls of Jericho, and on the eighth day ordered the priests to sound the sacred trumpets. And, if it could be determined, perhaps it was the sabbath day on which the walls of Jericho fell without battle at the noise of the blaring trumpets, and at the shout of the armed people the whole city, having laid aside its terror, fell into the power of the victorious army, and blood was shed, and spoils taken, and plunder carried off from the enemy. Whence, I say, so great and so remarkable a victory over the enemy, if it was not lawful to do anything on the sabbath? Or if this was done by the precept of the law, let the Jews know that the rest of their sabbath, which had been commanded long before, was afterwards broken without crime.

Exod 20:8 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 20:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 20:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Deut 5:14 (quotation, medium confidence) · Rom 7:14 (allusion, high confidence) · Phil 3:19 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 34:28 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Kgs 19:8 (allusion, high confidence) · Dan 10:2 (allusion, high confidence) · Zech 8:19 (allusion, high confidence) · Josh 6:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Josh 6:20 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Against Jewish sabbath observance, Gregory argues that the sabbath law was given with cattle, and that Moses, Elijah, Daniel, Zechariah and Joshua broke the sabbath rest without fault.

  • Gregory's polemic ("those men are cattle") is his own, translated as written.
  • Zechariah's fasts of the fourth, fifth, seventh and tenth months (Zech 8:19) are taken by Gregory as including the sabbath, a wordplay on "seventh".
  • Joshua's march: Gregory counts eight days (compare Josh 6:3–16, seven days).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; leaked footnote number; OCR slips; broken hyphenation; punctuation slip; OCR slip; stray point): Loquere filüis Israel → Loquere filiis Israel; sanclificare → sanctificare; et puella (ua, bos tuus et subiunctorium tuum et omne pecus tuum 1, Et reliqua. → et puella tua, bos tuus et subiunctorium tuum et omne pecus tuum, et reliqua.; in hae lectione → in hac lectione; lex spiritalis est, 1n solo → lex spiritalis est, in solo; cum pecoribus hane legem → cum pecoribus hanc legem; JVon facies in illo die → Non facies in illo die; par legis forma. daretur → par legis forma daretur; S1 autem bonum → Si autem bonum; Iudaeus : S1 sabbatum → Iudaeus : Si sabbatum; /n mente hábete → In mente habete; diebus 1eiunans → diebus ieiunans; non servavit, Elias quoque qnadraginta → non servavit. Elias quoque quadraginta; quin- üs et decimis → quintis et decimis; ieiunavit, id. est sabbato → ieiunavit, id est sabbato; cireumduxit → circumduxit; sciant ludaei → sciant Iudaei; sine erimine → sine crimine.

Topics: Fasting

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 8.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 86–89; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/8-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-8-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 89–91

Aliud exemplum simile connectam. Mulier quaedam fuit in regione Sunamitis, quae quia Elisaeum prophetam hospitio suscepit et fovit, cum sine liberis esset, hospitalitatis mercede filium meruit habere. Hunc iam puerum calentibus maternis affectibus infirmitas inimica subtraxerat et adhuc immaturis legibus festinatae mortis addixerat : repente inter media gaudia insperatae felicitatis mater exultans, dum sibi de filio plura promittit, inopinatum vulnus orbitatis excepit ; et ut fere plus amabantur quae insperata venerant, aggerebat luctum eius ereptus filius quo illum dederat inexspectata felicitas. Sed dolor in muliere prudente nequaquam potuit turbare consilium : exanimem puerum in thoro prophetae absentis hospitis collocat. Quibus actis ad ipsum prophetam ire festinat, ut inde contra mortem filii auxilium peteret, unde filium cum non postularet accepit. Consternit itaque asinum, et quae ad usus itineris erant necessaria instanti velocitate molitur : moras omnes odit et rumpit, cuncta praecipitat, iterum mater esse festinat. Quam cum maritus et propter neomeniam et propter sabbatum retinere gestaret, mulier prudens et totam se votis pietatis impendens, ipsi quoque retinenti profutura, sabbatum illud credebat futurum si doloris in quo solo laborabat otium recepisset recepto filio. Proficiscitur ergo, sabbato venit ad prophetam, rogavit eum ut veniret. Qui cum venisset resuscitavit filium eius a mortuis. Unde si sabbatum itinere profanatum fuisset, nec propheta puerum excitare potuisset, quia contra legem sabbatum violasset. Adnectam adhuc male ab hoste tractatum exercitum Iudaeorum propter otium sabbati, superatum sequendo sabbatum. Iudas Machabaeus, contra hostem cum agmen produxisset, et prostravit inimicum, et populum de victoria non solum tutum sed et gloriosum reddidit. Libet exclamare : si commissum est in religione crimen sabbato aliquid faciendo, unde, rogo, ista tanta victoria, cum bello sabbatum fuerit profanatum ? Sed nec credendum erit [...] Deum omnipotentem, qui in curam hominis sui semper operatur : ad cuius quippe utilitatem, sollicitudinem prospiciendam gerens, dimensis per orbem partibus elementorum munia temperavit, candorem gratissimae lucis infudit, noctem in gratiam quietis aptavit, usus pecorum, opera animalium, quadrupedum officia sustinuit, fecunditates terrae, ubera fontium in alimoniam et refrigerium humanae carnis impressit : ut et homini, in cuius curam tanta prospexerat, in observantiam legis talia praecepta daret ut commoda valetudinis et necessaria humanae condicionis rursus lege prohiberet! Sed cur, inquis, scriptum est : Septima dies sabbatum est Domini Dei tui, non facies in illa die ullum opus? Dico quod sentio : si scelus est sabbato aliquid agere, ergo et creatura omnis in crimine est. Cur enim et sabbato oritur dies, si per omnia omnibus quiescendum est? Cur lux? Cur astra in sabbato consurgunt? Cur mare ipso sabbato suos commovet fluctus? Cur venti perflant, diem nubes obscurant, omnia a turbinibus suis et tempestatibus rotant? Cur fontes exaestuant, amnes commeant, terra fetus suos explicat? Et ne longum faciam per singula discurrendo, cur Iudaeus ipso sabbato plerumque nascitur, nisi quod naturae opera sua exercere permittitur et die sabbati aliquid agere homini divina lege non prohibetur?

I will add another similar example. There was a certain Shunammite woman in the region who, because she received the prophet Elisha as a guest and cared for him, was found worthy, as the reward of hospitality, to have a son, though she had been childless. While her maternal affections were warm, a hostile illness took this boy from her, still young, and bound him over by the laws of a hastened death while still unripe: suddenly, amid the joys of an unhoped-for happiness, the exultant mother, while promising herself much from her son, received the unexpected wound of bereavement; and since what comes unhoped-for is usually loved the more, the son snatched away, whom unexpected happiness had given her, heaped up her grief. But grief could in no way disturb the judgment of this prudent woman: she lays the lifeless boy on the bed of the prophet, her absent guest. Having done this, she hastens to go to the prophet himself, to seek help against her son's death from the one through whom she had received a son without asking. So she saddles a donkey and prepares with urgent speed what was needed for the journey; she hates and breaks off all delays, rushes everything, hurries to be a mother again. When her husband tried to hold her back because of the new moon and because of the sabbath, the prudent woman, devoting herself wholly to the vows of devotion, and to profit even him who held her back, believed that that would be a sabbath if, her son restored, she obtained rest from the grief in which alone she was laboring. So she sets out, comes to the prophet on the sabbath, and asks him to come. And when he came, he raised her son from the dead. So, if the sabbath had been profaned by the journey, the prophet could not have raised the boy either, because he would have violated the sabbath against the law. I will further add that the army of the Jews was badly treated by the enemy because of its sabbath rest, and was defeated for following the sabbath. Judas Maccabeus, when he had led out his column against the enemy, both laid the foe low and brought the people back from victory not only safe but glorious. One may well exclaim: if a crime against religion is committed by doing something on the sabbath, whence, I ask, this great victory, when the sabbath was profaned by war? Nor will it be credible ... that almighty God, who always works for the care of his man; for whose benefit, bearing a care that foresees, he measured out the parts of the world and tempered the tasks of the elements, poured out the brightness of most welcome light, fitted the night for the boon of rest, sustained the use of cattle, the labors of animals, the services of quadrupeds, and impressed on the earth its fruitfulness and on the springs their abundance for the nourishment and refreshment of human flesh, should give man, for whose care he had provided so much, such precepts in the observance of the law as to forbid again by law the comforts of health and the necessities of the human condition! "But why," you say, "is it written: 'The seventh day is the sabbath of the Lord your God; you shall do no work on that day'?" I say what I think: if it is a crime to do anything on the sabbath, then all creation too is guilty. For why does the day rise on the sabbath, if everything must rest in everything? Why the light? Why do the stars rise on the sabbath? Why does the sea move its waves on the very sabbath? Why do the winds blow, clouds darken the day, all things whirl with their storms and tempests? Why do springs boil up, rivers flow, the earth unfold its offspring? And not to be long in running through each thing: why is a Jew often born on the very sabbath, if not because nature is allowed to do its works, and man is not forbidden by divine law to do something on the sabbath day?

2 Kgs 4:8 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:16 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:20 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:21 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:23 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:35 (allusion, high confidence) · John 5:17 (echo, medium confidence) · Exod 20:10 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The Shunammite's sabbath journey to Elisha and Judas Maccabeus's sabbath victory show that the sabbath does not forbid doing good; God and all creation work on the sabbath.

  • Fighting on the sabbath: 1 Macc 2:32–41; the victories of Judas follow (deuterocanonical).
  • A word is missing in the digital text (marked [...]) in "Nor will it be credible ...".
  • The detail that the Shunammite came on the sabbath is Gregory's inference from 2 Kgs 4:23.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; stray point; OCR slips (1 for i); punctuation slip): 1nopinatum . vulnus → inopinatum vulnus; Lurbare → turbare; ad 1psum prophetam 1re → ad ipsum prophetam ire; seriptum est : Septima dies sabbatum est. Domini → scriptum est : Septima dies sabbatum est Domini; in crimine est: Cur → in crimine est. Cur; astra 1n sabbato → astra in sabbato.

Extrabiblical texts: 1 Macc 2:41 (1 Maccabees [in RC, EO canons]; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 8.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 89–91; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/8-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-8-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 91–93

Sed qui non intellegunt quid sit sabbatum nec quid sit otium sabbati, legem ipsam inludunt. Nam constat duo genera esse sabbatorum, unum temporarium, aliud aeternum : unum figuratum, aliud verum : unum pro tentatione, aliud pro salute : unum quod Dominus odisse se dicit, aliud quod profanari vetat. Hoc ergo temporarium sabbatum non pro salute, sed pro tentatione populo fuisse iniunctum probat scriptura divina, dicente ad Moysen Domino : Dic, inquit, eis ut tentem eos utrum in viis meis ambulent : sex diebus manna colligant, septimo autem die requiescant. Illi contra haec contemnentes praeceptum septima die processerunt manna colligere, sed et sabbatis ligna, ut scriptum est, colligebant, ut sciatis pro tentatione populi sabbati istius otium, non pro salute praeceptum. Deus etenim qui mentes obliviosi populi noverat, et quod ingrati caelestium beneficiorum memoriam divini timoris intrinsecus non haberent, imperavit eis otium sabbati, non quia nihil agendum sit, sed ut populus ab sceleribus eius vel uno die sabbati saltem requiesceret. Et ideo religio illi praetenditur, ut frequentatione sabbati legis quoque possit Domini recordari, et recordatione legis ab flagitio coerceri. Alioquin necessarius illis hic dies non fuit, si exemplo veterum patriarcharum vivere voluissent, ut nunquam ab eorum sensibus timor Dei discederet. Denique religiosus hic dies esset, si etiam et superioribus patribus de sabbato praeceptum fuisset iniunctum. Nihil enim de sabbato praecipitur Adae, nihil iusto Abel, nihil Seth, nihil ipsi translato Enoc, nihil Noe qui solus ad conservationem humani generis est reservatus. Unde si causa salutis, ut isti putant, in sabbati observatione consistit, exciderunt ergo a salute superiores qui sabbata non egerunt; aut si salvi sunt sine sabbato, quid prodest sabbatum custodire, sine cuius observatione apud Deum sancti et inlustres viri habentur? Sed dices mihi : Beatus est a Deo hic dies. At ego respondebo : Si ideo benedictus est hic dies quia in eo nihil sit Deus operatus, multo magis illi benedicti sunt in quibus opera sua divina monstravit. Quis enim nesciat plus esse honoris, non ubi nihil agitur, sed ubi humanis commodis aliquid providetur? Quis, inquam, nesciat plus esse gratiae ubi confertur aliquid ex beneficio, quam ubi dies sterilis est ex otio, cui merito collocata est a Deo benedictio? Neque enim qui benedictus in opere non fuerat sine causa institutus esset, si et sine fructu benedictionis solus et otiosus remansisset. Nam et ipsi superiores dies acceperunt benedictionem habentes opera divina, dicente scriptura : Et vidit Deus omnia quae fecit, et benedixit ea ; multo magis et dies ipsos benedicit in quibus quae facta sunt valde bona dicta sunt et benedictionem ab ipso Deo consecuta sunt.

But those who do not understand what the sabbath is, or what the rest of the sabbath is, make a mockery of the law itself. For it is agreed that there are two kinds of sabbaths, one temporary, the other eternal; one figurative, the other true; one for testing, the other for salvation; one which the Lord says he hates, the other which he forbids to be profaned. The divine Scripture proves that this temporary sabbath was laid on the people not for salvation but for testing, when the Lord says to Moses: "Tell them," he says, "that I may test them whether they walk in my ways: let them gather manna for six days, but on the seventh day let them rest." They, despising this precept, went out on the seventh day to gather manna, and even gathered wood on the sabbaths, as it is written, so that you may know that the rest of this sabbath was commanded for the people's testing, not for salvation. For God, who knew the minds of the forgetful people, and that, ungrateful for the heavenly benefits, they would not hold within the memory of the fear of God, commanded them the rest of the sabbath, not because nothing should be done, but so that the people might rest from their crimes at least on the one day of the sabbath. And so religion is held out to them, so that by the frequent recurrence of the sabbath they might also remember the law of the Lord, and by the remembrance of the law be restrained from wrongdoing. Otherwise this day would not have been necessary for them, if they had been willing to live after the example of the old patriarchs, so that the fear of God never departed from their minds. Indeed this day would be a sacred one if the precept about the sabbath had also been laid on the earlier fathers. But nothing about the sabbath is commanded to Adam, nothing to righteous Abel, nothing to Seth, nothing to Enoch himself, who was translated, nothing to Noah, who alone was preserved for the conservation of the human race. So if the ground of salvation, as these people think, consists in observing the sabbath, then those earlier men who did not keep sabbaths fell away from salvation; or if they are saved without the sabbath, what use is it to keep the sabbath, since without its observance men are held holy and illustrious before God? But you will say to me: "This day was blessed by God." And I will answer: if this day was blessed because God did nothing on it, much more blessed are those days on which he displayed his divine works. For who does not know that there is more honor not where nothing is done, but where something is provided for human benefit? Who, I say, does not know that there is more grace where something is bestowed by kindness than where a day is barren from idleness, on which blessing was rightly placed by God? For the day which had not been blessed in work would not have been established without reason, if it had remained alone and idle without the fruit of blessing. For the earlier days too received a blessing, having divine works, as the Scripture says: "And God saw all that he had made, and blessed them"; much more does he bless the very days on which the things made were called very good and obtained a blessing from God himself.

Isa 1:13 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 16:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 16:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 16:27 (allusion, high confidence) · Num 15:32 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 2:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 1:31 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: There are two sabbaths, temporary and eternal; the temporary sabbath was a test for a forgetful people, unknown to the patriarchs; the working days were blessed as much as the seventh.

  • A leaked marginal reference ("JSAEx. GVIS d e526:") is removed.
  • "And God saw all that he had made, and blessed them": a free combination of Gen 1:31 and 1:22, 28.
  • Gathering wood on the sabbath: Num 15:32.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; leaked footnote mark; leaked marginal reference): in eiis meis ambulent → in viis meis ambulent; llli contra → Illi contra; ut scriptum est ?, colligebant → ut scriptum est, colligebant; habentur? JSAEx. GVIS d e526: Sed → habentur? Sed; £t eidit Deus omnia quae fecit, et benedixit ea! ; → Et vidit Deus omnia quae fecit, et benedixit ea ;.

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 8.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 91–93; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/8-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-8-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.4Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 93–95

Sed iam nunc de vero sabbato breviter disserendum est, ut et partem eius et plenitudinem prosequamur. Sabbatum ergo otium vel feriae in latino vocabulo interpretatur. Hoc est autem otium sabbati a malis et pessimis operibus, non a bonis et inlustribus abstinere, non a beneficiis dandis aut commodis conferendis, sed ab sceleribus omnibus detestandisque criminibus abstinendis. Innocentia itaque cotidianum sabbatum est, abstinentia cotidiana religio est. Nam quando singuli dies per continuatum ordinem otiosos nos ab scelere suscipiunt, nihilominus omnes dies illos unum facimus. Alioquin inludit diem sabbati qui ceterorum dierum crimina unius diei otio se putat [...] : innocentes enim otium non facit ad scelera redituros. Quapropter non secundum carnem computandus iste nobis est dies, sed intellegendus spiritu et veritate de vita,.., ut dum tota vita nostra sine opere malo usque ad finem producitur, sabbatum quoque tota vita nostra reddatur. Huc accedit quod beatus David ait : Mille anni tamquam una dies ante oculos tuos, Domine, quae praeteriit. Ac proinde septimum millesimum annum septimum diem Domini, id est verum sabbatum, esse nulla dubitatio est. Et hoc erit sabbatum sanctum quod Dominus custodiri iubet, profanari vetat, id est septimus millesimus annus, in quo nullum opus servile, id est nullum peccatum, homo in regno Dei facturus est, quia qui peccatum, inquit, facit servus est peccati : hoc est sabbatorum sabbatum in quo omnia sancta, pia, pacifica, quieta, secura erunt. Haec sunt sabbata tenera, delicata, ubi non dolor aut labor, non infirmitas, non malitia, non peccatum erit, sed gloria immortalis et aeterna praestabitur. Diabolus enim tunc in abyssis religabitur, ne habeat potestatem ullum seducere; et ibi tunc malitia non erit, mancipe malitiae, id est diabolo, sublato. Nunc ergo veri sabbati otium in fide et sanctitate iustorum colitur, dum a malis operibus abstinetur : perfectio vero sabbati sabbatorum septimo millesimo anno, qui septimus dies est Domini, in resurrectione sanctorum et in regno Dei repraesentabitur nobis. Quid ergo, Iudaee, adhuc umbram futurorum ex lege sectaris, cum iam finis legis Xpistus advenerit, in quo non umbra sed veritas, non figura sed plenitudo religionis est reddita? Tunc enim omnia in imagine quasi per aenigmata gerebantur, nunc veritas inlustrata successit. Et ideo tunc figura futuri sabbati per legem in honore esse iubebatur, ut cum veri sabbati dies, id est malorum operum feria, per euangelicam fidem advenisset, tunc sublata imagine inlustrior veri sabbati honor haberetur.

But now we must briefly discuss the true sabbath, so as to follow out both its part and its fullness. Sabbath, then, is interpreted in the Latin word as rest or holiday. This is the rest of the sabbath: to abstain from evil and most wicked works, not from good and illustrious ones; not from giving benefits or bestowing comforts, but from all crimes and detestable offenses. Innocence, then, is a daily sabbath, abstinence a daily religion. For when the single days, in continuous order, receive us resting from crime, we nonetheless make all those days one. Otherwise he mocks the sabbath day who thinks that by one day's rest he [atones for] the crimes of the other days; for rest does not make innocent those who will return to their crimes. Therefore this day is not to be reckoned by us according to the flesh, but understood in spirit and truth, of the life ..., so that, while our whole life is carried on to the end without evil work, our whole life too may be rendered a sabbath. To this is added what blessed David says: "A thousand years are like one day before your eyes, O Lord, which has passed." And so there is no doubt that the seven-thousandth year is the seventh day of the Lord, that is, the true sabbath. And this will be the holy sabbath which the Lord commands to be kept and forbids to be profaned, that is, the seven-thousandth year, in which man will do no servile work, that is, no sin, in the kingdom of God, because "he who commits sin," he says, "is the slave of sin." This is the sabbath of sabbaths, in which all things will be holy, devout, peaceful, quiet, secure. These are the tender and delicate sabbaths, where there will be no pain or toil, no sickness, no malice, no sin, but immortal and eternal glory will be granted. For the devil will then be bound in the abyss, so that he may have no power to deceive anyone; and then there will be no malice there, since the owner of malice, that is, the devil, has been removed. Now, then, the rest of the true sabbath is kept in the faith and holiness of the righteous, while they abstain from evil works; but the perfection of the sabbath of sabbaths will be presented to us in the seven-thousandth year, which is the seventh day of the Lord, in the resurrection of the saints and in the kingdom of God. Why then, Jew, do you still pursue from the law the shadow of things to come, when Christ, the end of the law, has already come, in whom not a shadow but the truth, not a figure but the fullness of religion has been rendered? Then all things were done in image, as through riddles; now the truth, made clear, has succeeded. And so then the figure of the future sabbath was commanded to be held in honor through the law, so that when the day of the true sabbath, that is, the holiday from evil works, had come through the faith of the Gospel, then, the image removed, the honor of the true sabbath might be held more illustrious.

John 4:24 (allusion, medium confidence) · Ps 90:4 (89:4 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Pet 3:8 (echo, medium confidence) · Lev 23:7 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 8:34 (quotation, high confidence) · Rev 20:2 (allusion, high confidence) · Rev 20:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Col 2:17 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 10:4 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 13:12 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The true sabbath is a whole life at rest from sin, fulfilled in the seventh millennium, the kingdom of the saints, when the devil is bound; the law's sabbath was a shadow ended by Christ.

  • The seventh millennium as the sabbath of the kingdom (with the devil bound, Rev 20:2–3) is Gregory's millenarian reading, translated as written.
  • Words are missing in the digital text in two places (marked [...] and ...); "atones for" supplies the sense.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; stray points): cotidiana religio est... → cotidiana religio est.; Huc aecedit → Huc accedit; quae praeteriit. c proinde → quae praeteriit. Ac proinde; qui peccatum, immquit, facit sereus est peccati? : hoe est → qui peccatum, inquit, facit servus est peccati : hoc est; sectaris, cam iam → sectaris, cum iam; Et 1deo tunc → Et ideo tunc; inlusirior → inlustrior.

Topics: Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 8.4 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 93–95; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/8-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-8-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.