Tractates on the Books of Holy Scripture (Tractatus Origenis) 15.1–16.4

Latin text: Batiffol-Wilmart 1900 (Latin text: Batiffol and Wilmart (Paris, 1900), Internet Archive scan, public domain).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 15

15.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 162–164

Dixit Elisaeus ad populum qui erat in Hiericho : Accipite mihi vas fictile et mittite in eo sal. Et demersit illud in flumine, et statim aquae sanatae sunt. Audistis lectionem, dilectissimi fratres, qua refert beatissimum Elisaeum prophetam, cum rogaretur a populo ut aquas Hiericho steriles et malignas sanaret, quo sacramento easdem aquas ad sanitatem fecunditatemque produxerit : Accepit, inquit, vas rude fictile, et adiecit in eo sal, et demersit illud in flumine, et statim aquae sanatae sunt. Quid in hoc loco dicimus, dilectissimi fratres? Numquid non poterat Elisaeus in nomine Domini aquas verbo curare, qui potuit impetum Iordanis fluminis, refrenatis undarum agminibus, retrorsus ad caput fontis verbo revocare, ut siccum sibi iter per idem flumen transeundi praeberet? Aut numquid plus poterat vas illud fictile plenum sale quam sermo Dei quo etiam et mortuos excitavit et saepenumero virtutes maximas faciebat? Quae ergo causa, quae ratio, quae potestas in vas illud fictile et sale plenum fuerit, diligentius debemus advertere. Elisaeus utique hic beatissimus propheta erat qui, cum rogaretur ut aquas steriles sanaret, non aliunde poterat quam de Xpisto ut baptismatis eius in sacramento remedium quaereret. Vas etenim illud fictile figuram Xpisti corporis portendebat, quod ex protoplastis quorum imago terrena est suscepturus erat. Salem autem ipsum Verbum Dei esse, sapientiam scilicet Patris, nulla est dubitatio : de qua sapientia beatus Paulus apostolus dicit : Xpistus, inquit, Dei virtus est et Dei sapientia; unde et apostoli propter fidem quam in Xpisto habebant sal terrae sunt appellati. Propheta ergo, sciens illud futurum quod postea sanctus Ioannes apostolus refert : Verbum caro factum est et habitavit in nobis, proinde in similitudine Verbi salem, id est sapientiam Dei, in vas fictile, id est in corpus hominis, immittens in aqua demersit. Quod quidem significabat quia omnes aquae quae toto mundo steriles erant, quae filios Dei sine Xpisto generare non poterant, postea baptizato Xpisto fecunditatem et benedictionem accepturae essent, ut Dei filios per lavacri vitalis sanctificationem generarent. Unde advertere debet xpistiana sapientia, sanctissimi fratres, quantum possit nunc veritas baptismatis in Xpisto, huius tantum potuit tunc figura. Ex quo enim Dominus in easdem aquas descendere et baptizari dignatus est, in corpore suo salem Verbi circumferens et in sermone ipso vasis fictilis, id est corporis, materiam gerens : ex eo ubique per fidem Xpisti aquae generare et Dei filios procreare coeperunt, quae retro steriles fuerunt.

"Elisha said to the people who were in Jericho: 'Bring me an earthen vessel and put salt in it.' And he plunged it into the river, and at once the waters were healed." You have heard the reading, dearest brothers, which tells how the most blessed prophet Elisha, when the people asked him to heal the barren and harmful waters of Jericho, brought those waters to health and fruitfulness by a mystery: "He took," it says, "a new earthen vessel, and put salt in it, and plunged it into the river, and at once the waters were healed." What do we say in this place, dearest brothers? Could Elisha not heal the waters by a word in the name of the Lord, he who was able by a word to call back the rush of the river Jordan to the head of its spring, holding back the ranks of its waves, so as to provide himself a dry path to cross through that river? Or could that earthen vessel full of salt do more than the word of God, by which he even raised the dead and often worked the greatest wonders? We must observe more carefully, then, what cause, what meaning, what power lay in that earthen vessel full of salt. This most blessed prophet Elisha, when he was asked to heal the barren waters, could seek the remedy from nowhere else than from Christ, in the mystery of his baptism. For that earthen vessel foreshadowed the figure of Christ's body, which he was to take from the first-formed, whose image is earthly. That the salt is the Word of God himself, namely the wisdom of the Father, there is no doubt; of this wisdom the blessed apostle Paul says: "Christ," he says, "is the power of God and the wisdom of God"; and so the apostles too, because of the faith they had in Christ, were called the salt of the earth. The prophet, then, knowing what was to come, which afterwards the holy apostle John relates, "The Word became flesh and dwelt among us," therefore, putting salt, that is, the wisdom of God, into an earthen vessel, that is, into a human body, in the likeness of the Word, plunged it into the water. This signified that all the waters which throughout the world were barren, which could not beget sons of God without Christ, would afterwards, when Christ was baptized, receive fruitfulness and blessing, so as to beget sons of God through the sanctification of the life-giving washing. Hence Christian wisdom ought to notice, most holy brothers, that as much as the truth of baptism in Christ can do now, so much its figure could do then. For from the time when the Lord deigned to go down into those waters and be baptized, carrying in his body the salt of the Word and bearing in the Word itself the material of the earthen vessel, that is, of the body, from then on everywhere, through faith in Christ, waters which formerly were barren began to beget and bring forth sons of God.

2 Kgs 2:20 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 2:21 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 2:19 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 2:14 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Kgs 4:35 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 15:47 (allusion, medium confidence) · 1 Cor 1:24 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:13 (allusion, high confidence) · John 1:14 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 3:16 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Elisha's healing of Jericho's waters with salt in an earthen vessel figures the Word made flesh, whose baptism made the waters fruitful to beget children of God.

  • Gregory attributes the parting of the Jordan to Elisha (2 Kgs 2:14).
  • The edition's line number (1) after the opening quotation leaked into the digital text and is removed.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; stray point; OCR slips; punctuation slip; stray point; leaked footnote number): Accipite mihi eas fictile → Accipite mihi vas fictile; demersit illud. in flumine, et statim aquae sanatae sunt 1, Audistis → demersit illud in flumine, et statim aquae sanatae sunt. Audistis; baptismatis eius 1n sacramento → baptismatis eius in sacramento; figuram Xpist corporis → figuram Xpisti corporis; imago lerrena → imago terrena; Dei eirtus est → Dei virtus est; habitaeit in. nobis → habitavit in nobis; immittens 1n aqua → immittens in aqua; potuit tunc figura, Ex quo → potuit tunc figura. Ex quo; fictilis, 1d est corporis, materlam → fictilis, id est corporis, materiam.

Topics: Baptism, Christology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 15.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 162–164; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/15-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-15-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

15.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 164–166

Sed ne forte aliquis caelestium sacramentorum ignarus dicat : cur baptizatus est Xpistus, qui Deus erat, cuius caro peccatum non fecerat nec dolus in ore eius inventus est, cum baptismatis gratia non nisi ad remissionem peccatorum sit divinitus procurata ? accipite rationem, et intellegite ad hoc Dominum nostrum baptizari se a Ioanne voluisse non ut remissionem peccatorum acciperet, qui peccatum non fecerat, sed ideo baptizari dignatus est ut aquam ipsam suo lavacro sanctificaret, ut quicumque in nomine ipsius baptizatus fuisset, membrum iam corporis ipsius effectus, filius Dei per adoptionem esse mereretur, renatus scilicet ex aqua et superna virtute. Denique et alibi hoc Xpisti baptismatis sacramentum similiter invenimus esse praemissum : nam in Exodo legimus Merrae fontis aquas amaras immisso ligno ad dulcedinem sanitatemque fuisse conversas; nullum enim aliud remedium inutilium aquarum nisi de Xpisto prophetae quaerebant. Lignum etenim illud dominicae passionis mysterium perspicue demonstrabat, qua indulcatas baptismatis aquas possent sitientes salubriter bibere; unde et ipse Dominus stans in templo dicebat : Qui sitit veniat et bibat aquam virtutis gratis. Sic populus in eremo cum sitis periculum pateretur, tunc Moyses virga, id est ligno, petram percussit et fluxerunt fontes aquarum : quo factum esse sacramentum baptismatis indicabat. Petram enim illam figuram Xpisti habuisse probat beatus apostolus cum dicit : Bibebant enim de spiritali sequenti petra, petra autem erat Xpistus. Petram ergo illam imaginem dominicae carnis habuisse nulla est dubitatio : quae caro, crucis ligno percussa, aquam vivam sitientibus tribuit, sicut scriptum est : Flumina de ventre eius procedent. Dicebat hoc itaque de Spiritu Sancto quem credentes accepturi erant. Et proinde aquae illae, de petra productae, flumina de ventre Xpisti in sacramento baptismatis manantia et ad salubre sitientium poculum de Xpisti latere cursura, iam tunc typica praefiguratione monstrabant. Quis etenim nesciat Dominum nostrum, qui est fons aquae vivae saliens in vitae perpetuitatem, cum in crucis ligno suspensus fuisset, non tantum de vulnere lateris sui sanguinem, sed aquas largo cursu manantes profudisse, ostendens sponsam, id est Ecclesiam, exemplo protoplastorum de latere suo constare, sicut constitit et Eva de costa Adae, habentem scilicet duo baptismata, id est aquae et sanguinis, unde fideles in Ecclesia et martyres fiunt? Sed quia necesse erat ut cum sacramento baptismatis etiam et sanctorum apostolorum imaginem praefiguratam ostenderet, proinde apud Elim, qui locus in Exodo legitur, in duodecim fontibus duodecim apostolorum figura monstratur. De quibus fontibus David in psalmis ait : Laudate, inquit, Dominum de fontibus Israel, eo quod ex populo Israel fontes isti apostoli procedentes gratiam baptismatis essent credentibus praebituri. Et nequis beatum apostolum Paulum ab eorum consortio putaret exclusum, subiunxit dicens : Illic Beniamin adulescentior, eo quod Paulus apostolus de tribu Beniamin inventus erat, et pariter cum ceteris apostolis baptismi donum cunctis nationibus praebiturus : qui ideo adulescentior dicitur, nequis hoc de illo antiquo patriarcha Beniamin dictum esse putaret.

But lest perhaps someone ignorant of the heavenly mysteries should say, "Why was Christ baptized, who was God, whose flesh had committed no sin, nor was deceit found in his mouth, since the grace of baptism was divinely provided only for the forgiveness of sins?": hear the reason, and understand that our Lord willed to be baptized by John not to receive forgiveness of sins, he who had committed no sin, but deigned to be baptized so that he might sanctify the water itself by his washing, so that whoever was baptized in his name, now made a member of his body, might deserve to be a son of God by adoption, reborn of water and the power from above. Indeed elsewhere too we find this mystery of Christ's baptism similarly foreshown: for in Exodus we read that the bitter waters of the spring of Marah, when wood was thrown in, were turned to sweetness and health; for the prophets sought no other remedy for useless waters than from Christ. That wood clearly showed the mystery of the Lord's passion, by which the thirsty could drink healthfully the sweetened waters of baptism; hence the Lord himself, standing in the temple, said: "Whoever thirsts, let him come and drink the water of power freely." So too, when the people in the desert was in danger from thirst, Moses struck the rock with his rod, that is, with wood, and springs of water flowed: by which it indicated that the mystery of baptism was accomplished. For the blessed apostle proves that that rock bore the figure of Christ when he says: "For they drank from the spiritual rock that followed them, and the rock was Christ." There is no doubt, then, that that rock bore the image of the Lord's flesh, which flesh, struck by the wood of the cross, gave living water to the thirsty, as it is written: "Rivers will flow from his belly." He said this of the Holy Spirit, whom believers were to receive. And so those waters, brought forth from the rock, already then showed in typical prefiguration the rivers flowing from Christ's belly in the mystery of baptism, which would run from Christ's side as a healthful drink for the thirsty. For who does not know that our Lord, who is the fountain of living water springing up to everlasting life, when he had been hung on the wood of the cross, poured out from the wound in his side not only blood but also waters flowing in an abundant stream, showing that the bride, that is, the Church, after the example of the first-formed, consists from his side, as Eve too was formed from the rib of Adam, having two baptisms, namely of water and of blood, by which the faithful and the martyrs are made in the Church? But since it was necessary that, together with the mystery of baptism, it should also show the image of the holy apostles prefigured, therefore at Elim, a place read of in Exodus, the figure of the twelve apostles is shown in twelve springs. Of these springs David says in the psalms: "Praise the Lord from the springs of Israel," because these apostle-springs, proceeding from the people of Israel, were to give believers the grace of baptism. And lest anyone think the blessed apostle Paul excluded from their company, he added: "There is Benjamin, the younger," because the apostle Paul was found to be of the tribe of Benjamin, and was to give the gift of baptism to all nations together with the other apostles; he is called "the younger" so that no one should think this was said of the ancient patriarch Benjamin.

1 Pet 2:22 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 3:13 (allusion, high confidence) · John 3:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 15:23 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 15:25 (allusion, high confidence) · John 7:37 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 55:1 (quotation, medium confidence) · Exod 17:6 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 10:4 (quotation, high confidence) · John 7:38 (quotation, high confidence) · John 7:39 (allusion, high confidence) · John 4:14 (allusion, high confidence) · John 19:34 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 2:22 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 15:27 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 68:26 (67:27 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 68:27 (67:28 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Phil 3:5 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Christ was baptized not for forgiveness but to sanctify the water; the sweetened waters of Marah, the struck rock, the water and blood from his side, and the twelve springs of Elim all figure baptism and the apostles.

  • A leaked marginal reference ("TS TOÀ VIE: 37.") is removed.
  • "Whoever thirsts ... freely": John 7:37 combined with Isa 55:1; "the springs of Israel" and "Benjamin the younger": Ps 68:26–27 (LXX 67:27–28).
  • Two baptisms, of water and of blood: a common patristic theme (compare Tertullian, On Baptism 16).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; leaked footnote mark; OCR slips; OCR slips (1 for i); OCR slips; punctuation slip; leaked marginal reference; punctuation slip; stray comma; stray mark; stray point): membrum 1am corporis 1psius → membrum iam corporis ipsius; immisso lieno ad, dulcedinem sanitatemque fuisse congersas; nullum enim aliud remedium inutilum → immisso ligno ad dulcedinem sanitatemque fuisse conversas; nullum enim aliud remedium inutilium; Qui sitit eeniat et bibat aqua eirtutem gratis, Sic → Qui sitit veniat et bibat aquam virtutis gratis. Sic; dominicae:carnis → dominicae carnis; sicut scriptum. est → sicut scriptum est; manantia et, ad salubre → manantia et ad salubre; praefiguratione monstrabant, Quis → praefiguratione monstrabant. Quis; saliens 1n vitae → saliens in vitae; lateris su sanguinem → lateris sui sanguinem; habentem scilicet duo TS TOÀ VIE: 37. baptismata → habentem scilicet duo baptismata; de fontibus [srael → de fontibus Israel; //lie Beniamin adulescentior?* , → Illic Beniamin adulescentior,.

Topics: Baptism, Martyrdom

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 15.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 164–166; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/15-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-15-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

15.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 166–168

Et quia nunc de sacramento baptismatis sermo est, etiam et illud debemus ostendere quod una sit omnibus accipientibus gratia, nec alium plus, alterum minus posse consequi in baptismatis dono. Mentior nisi probavero omnes servos in euangelio singulos denarios accepisse, et manna illud quod colligebatur pro omnibus fuisse mensuram, quia qui amplius, inquit, non abundabit et qui minus non indigebit. Nam quando in baptismate omnia peccata donantur, et ubi sine modo indulgentia, cessat omnis cum sua computatione mensura, nec redigitur in numero cum divina bonitas porrigat totum. Ideo et omnes servos, ut iam dixi, refert scriptura singulos denarios accepisse, ut ostenderet omnium peccatorum remissionis unam esse mensuram, et sine cuiusquam iniuria per omnia paria bonitatis Dei cucurrisse iudicia, ne in reprehensionem divinae indulgentiae caderet bonitas si circa omnes non fuisset aequalitas. Non enim ad mensuram dat Pater Spiritum, et sic nec ad mensuram porrigitur baptismi gratia ut tantum conferatur quantum aquae abundantia vel exiguitas fuerit, quia nec aqua est quae delicta dissolvit, sed per aquam Deus est qui omnia peccata dimittit. Et quamquam omnes unum indulgentiae munus in baptismate consequamur, ut nullum peccatum exceptum sit quod non baptismatis sacramento diluatur, tamen postea actibus, moribus, operibus in conversatione distinguimur. Sicut enim in euangelio seminator quidem semen divini verbi aequaliter seminavit, sed non ubique similiter profecit ad messem : aliud enim inter spinas cecidit et suffocatum est ; aliud in terra petrosa, quod statim quidem mortuum est, sed quia nec radices altas nec humorem quo aleretur habebat, orto sole exaruit; aliud iuxta viam, et aves diripuerunt illud; aliud in terram bonam, et fecit fructum, aliud tricies, aliud sexagies, aliud centies. Sic et una est quidem gratia baptismatis omnibus, sicut una est seminatio verbi, sed postea pro actuum qualitate singulorum merita in iudicio discernentur.

And since we are now speaking of the mystery of baptism, we must also show that the grace is one for all who receive it, and that one cannot obtain more and another less in the gift of baptism. Call me a liar if I do not prove that all the servants in the Gospel received one denarius each, and that the manna that was gathered was one measure for all, because "he who gathered more," it says, "will not have too much, and he who gathered less will not lack." For when in baptism all sins are forgiven, and where there is pardon without measure, every measure with its reckoning ceases, nor is it reduced to number, since the divine goodness offers the whole. Therefore the Scripture also tells, as I said, that all the servants received one denarius each, to show that the forgiveness of all sins has one measure, and that the judgments of God's goodness ran equal in all things without injury to anyone, lest goodness fall into the reproach of divine indulgence if there had not been equality toward all. For the Father does not give the Spirit by measure, and so neither is the grace of baptism offered by measure, so as to bestow as much as the abundance or scarcity of water; for it is not water that dissolves offenses, but it is God who through water forgives all sins. And though we all obtain one gift of pardon in baptism, so that no sin is excepted that is not washed away by the sacrament of baptism, yet afterwards we are distinguished by acts, conduct, and works in our way of life. For just as in the Gospel the sower sowed the seed of the divine word equally, but it did not everywhere advance alike to harvest: some fell among thorns and was choked; some on rocky ground, which, though it at once sprang up, yet, since it had neither deep roots nor moisture to be nourished, withered when the sun rose; some by the road, and the birds snatched it away; some on good ground, and it bore fruit, some thirtyfold, some sixtyfold, some a hundredfold. So too the grace of baptism is one for all, as the sowing of the word is one, but afterwards the merits of each will be distinguished at the judgment according to the quality of their deeds.

Matt 20:9 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 16:18 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Cor 8:15 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 3:34 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:4 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:5 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:7 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 13:8 (allusion, high confidence) · 2 Cor 5:10 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The grace of baptism is equal for all, forgiving every sin, like the one denarius and the equal manna; afterwards believers are distinguished by their deeds, as in the parable of the sower.

  • "Statim quidem mortuum est" in the sower parable is as printed (literally "at once died"); translated by the sense of the parable ("sprang up").
  • "The Father does not give the Spirit by measure": John 3:34.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slips (1 for i); stray point): ut lam dixi → ut iam dixi; cucurrisse 1udicia, ne 1n reprehensionem → cucurrisse iudicia, ne in reprehensionem; non ubique similiter. profecit → non ubique similiter profecit.

Topics: Baptism

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 15.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 166–168; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/15-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-15-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 16

16.1Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 168–172

Visio quam vidit Isaias filius Amos adversus Iudam et adversus Hierusalem. Maximum quidem praeclarumque munus est, dilectissimi fratres, et revera insigne disputationis genus propheticos sensus, allegoriae integumentis obvolutos, in lucem verae cognitionis aperire. Sed quia non tam affatim haec gratia cunctorum mentibus inlabitur ut id quod magnificum et divinum est cito agnosci possit, merito in ipsa inquisitione torquemur. Attamen quia Dominus Salvatorque noster fiduciam requirendi dedit sic dicens : Petite et accipietis, pulsate et aperietur vobis, quaerite et invenietis, et Nihil est obscurum quod non reveletur, et tectum quod non manifestetur, proinde fertur hac pollicitatione cognitor de lectione facere sermonem. Sed ante omnia requirendum nobis est cur praetitulatio ista cum subsequenti sermone non congruat. Ait enim : Visio quam vidit Isaias in regno Oziae, Ioatham, Achaz, Ezechiae, regum Iuda. Cum utique una haec visio quattuor regum temporibus ostensa non fuerit, quasi una visio uno tempore visa est : non enim dicit visiones quas vidit Isaias, quasi plures, sed visio, inquit, ut unam visionem ostenderet; quae si una est, uno ut dixi tempore visa est, non tamen quattuor regum temporibus una et eadem visio ostensa est. Deinde videte quod in subsequenti sermone visionem ipsam non insinuat, sed gravissima intentione populum obiurgat. Ait enim : Audi caelum, et auribus percipe terra: filios genui et exaltavi, ipsi autem me spreverunt. Hoc non est visionem referre, sed cum magna indignatione eadem populum increpare : aliud est enim visionem dicere, aliud invectionis verba proferre; visio etenim oculis ostenditur, verba auribus intimantur. Denique Habacuc propheta non se dixit vidisse sed audisse : Domine, inquit, audivi quod audivi ex te esse, et timui : crediderat enim quod de Deo audierat, et ideo timebat quia de Deo audierat. In hoc autem loco, quare visionem in titulo ponat, et non ipsius visionis sed invectionis verba subiunxit, diligentius debemus advertere. Sed quoniam praetitulatio obscura ponitur, verbum autem Dei propheta adnuntiat, proinde necesse fuit ut prius verbum Dei pro quo propheta missus fuerat indicaret et sic visionem suam opportuno loco et tempore diceret. Nam et scriba ideo visionem in libri capite titulavit quia prius visionem ipsam propheta viderat quam verbum mittentis audiret. Sic enim ait : Anno quo mortuus est Ozias rex, vidi Dominum sedentem super thronum excelsum, et haec est visio quam vidit Isaias filius Amos, quia vidit Dominum sedentem super thronum excelsum, quo tempore omnia ei ostensa sunt quae futura erant. Unde et scriba recte prius visionem posuit quam prophetae invectionem indicaret, nequis Isaiam non missum a Domino in convicium potius populi Israel exsurrexisse quam verbum Domini nuntiasse putaret; sed mirifice propheta ante verbum Domini populo intimavit quam visionis suae textum exponeret. Sed cum ita sit nihilominus et de praeposterato ordine disserendum est, quoniam saepenumero in scripturis divinis ita invenimus scriptum ut quod prius factum est postea ponatur, et quod postea futurum est prius adnuntietur. Audite consilium Sancti Spiritus. Haec enim in omnibus fere scripturis dispositionis ratio invenitur ut non directo ordine series digeratur. Hac ergo de causa praeposterantur verba divina, sed et multa figurate dicuntur : alia enim aenigmatice referuntur aut typice indicantur, vel allegorice enarrantur aut in parabolis obscurantur, ut, quia aliquando seductus serpens verbis subdolis hominem in paradiso deceperat, dum ea quae simpliciter Deus homini iusserat observare ille mala interpretatione contraria persuaderet, et quia tunc homini evidens praeceptum fuerat quod ipse diabolus possit agnoscere, ideo hominem male suadendo decepit : quare necesse fuit ut ex eo iam provideret Spiritus Sanctus homini et per parabolas et figuras loqueretur, praeposteraret quoque, ut iam dictum est, ordines prophetiae, nequando iterum accepta occasione peccatum per mandatum induceret et per ipsum rursus hominem occideret. Hac ergo de causa in parabolis et obscuris verbis et praeposterata serie scripturae digestae sunt, ut et ipse ignoraret et obscuritate verborum irrideretur inimicus et de praeposterato ordine tempora ignoraret, et nemo alius intellegeret Sancti Spiritus sensum nisi is qui eumdem Spiritum habuisset qui locutus est in prophetis, alienus vero spiritus scire non posset. Denique et ipse Dominus per parabolas locutus est, ut sui tantum quae loquebatur agnoscerent, qui vero sui non essent audientes non audirent, sicut scriptum est : Ne auribus audiant et corde intellegant et convertantur et sanem eos, dicit Dominus. Non quod Deus nollet eos convertentes sanare, sed quia peccatorum illorum enormitas praecesserat, ideo non merebantur neque converti neque sanari.

"The vision which Isaiah son of Amoz saw against Judah and against Jerusalem." It is indeed a very great and splendid task, dearest brothers, and truly a remarkable kind of discourse, to open into the light of true knowledge the prophetic meanings wrapped in the coverings of allegory. But since this grace does not flow so abundantly into the minds of all that what is magnificent and divine can be quickly recognized, we are rightly tormented in the very search. Yet since our Lord and Savior gave us confidence to search, saying, "Ask and you will receive, knock and it will be opened to you, seek and you will find," and "There is nothing hidden that will not be revealed, and nothing covered that will not be made known," the one who seeks to understand is therefore carried by this promise to preach on the reading. But before all things we must ask why this title does not agree with the discourse that follows. For it says: "The vision which Isaiah saw in the reign of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, Hezekiah, kings of Judah." Surely this one vision was not shown in the times of four kings, as though one vision was seen at one time: for it does not say "the visions which Isaiah saw," as if many, but "the vision," it says, to show one vision; if it is one, it was seen, as I said, at one time; yet one and the same vision was not shown in the times of four kings. Then see that in the discourse that follows it does not present the vision itself, but rebukes the people with the gravest intensity. For it says: "Hear, O heaven, and give ear, O earth: I have begotten and exalted sons, but they have despised me." This is not to report a vision, but to rebuke the people with great indignation: for to tell a vision is one thing, to utter words of invective another; for a vision is shown to the eyes, words are conveyed to the ears. Indeed the prophet Habakkuk said not that he had seen but that he had heard: "Lord," he says, "I have heard what I heard from you, and I was afraid"; for he had believed what he had heard of God, and he feared because he had heard it of God. In this place, then, we must observe more carefully why he puts "vision" in the title and adds not the words of the vision itself but of invective. Since the title is set down obscurely, while the prophet announces the word of God, it was necessary that he first indicate the word of God for which the prophet had been sent, and so tell his vision at the fitting place and time. For the scribe entitled the head of the book "vision" because the prophet had first seen the vision itself before he heard the word of the one who sent him. For he says: "In the year that King Uzziah died, I saw the Lord sitting on a high throne"; and this is the vision which Isaiah son of Amoz saw, that he saw the Lord sitting on a high throne, at which time all things that were to come were shown to him. Hence the scribe rightly put the vision first before indicating the prophet's invective, so that no one should think that Isaiah, not sent by the Lord, rose up to revile the people of Israel rather than to announce the word of the Lord; but the prophet wonderfully conveyed the word of the Lord to the people before setting out the text of his vision. Since this is so, we must nonetheless also discuss the reversed order, since we often find it written in the divine Scriptures that what was done first is placed later, and what is to be later is announced first. Hear the counsel of the Holy Spirit. For in almost all the Scriptures this principle of arrangement is found, that the series is not set out in straight order. For this reason, then, the divine words are put out of order, and many things are also said figuratively: some are related in riddles, or indicated in types, or narrated allegorically, or obscured in parables. For since the serpent once, having seduced him, deceived man in paradise by crafty words, persuading him by bad interpretation of the opposite of what God had simply commanded man to observe, and since the command given to man then was plain, so that the devil himself could understand it, he therefore deceived man by evil persuasion; and so it was necessary that the Holy Spirit should from then on provide for man and speak through parables and figures, and also, as has been said, reverse the order of prophecy, so that the enemy should never again take occasion and bring in sin through the commandment and through it kill man again. For this reason, then, the Scriptures were arranged in parables and obscure words and in a reversed series, so that the enemy himself would not know, would be mocked by the obscurity of the words, and would not know the times because of the reversed order, and so that no one else would understand the sense of the Holy Spirit except him who had the same Spirit that spoke in the prophets, while an alien spirit could not know it. Indeed the Lord himself spoke in parables, so that only his own might recognize what he was saying, while those who were not his, hearing, would not hear, as it is written: "Lest they hear with their ears and understand with their heart and be converted and I heal them, says the Lord." Not that God did not wish to heal them if they were converted, but because the enormity of their sins had gone before, they did not deserve to be either converted or healed.

Isa 1:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 7:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 8:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 1:2 (quotation, high confidence) · Hab 3:2 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 6:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 3:1 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 7:11 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 2:11 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 13:13 (allusion, high confidence) · Isa 6:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 13:15 (quotation, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Gregory asks why Isaiah's book is titled a 'vision' though it opens with rebuke, and explains that Scripture deliberately reverses order and speaks in figures to hide its sense from the devil while revealing it to those with the Spirit.

  • A leaked marginal reference ("Ao Is L.1.") is removed.
  • "Hab 3:2" is quoted in its Greek/Old Latin form.
  • The sentence "proinde fertur hac pollicitatione cognitor" is obscure as printed; translated by sense.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip; leaked footnote mark; OCR slip; leaked footnote marks; OCR slip; stray point; OCR slips; OCR slips; leaked marginal reference; split word; stray hyphen; stray point): adversus ludam et adversus Hierusalem?!. → adversus Iudam et adversus Hierusalem.; allegoriae in tegumentis → allegoriae integumentis; merito in Ipsa inquisitione torquemur. Áttamen → merito in ipsa inquisitione torquemur. Attamen; aperietur eobis, quaerite et inegenietis → aperietur vobis, quaerite et invenietis; in regno Oziae, loatham, Achaz, Ao Is L.1. Eszechiae → in regno Oziae, Ioatham, Achaz, Ezechiae; vidit Isaias, - quasi plures → vidit Isaias, quasi plures; Deiude videte → Deinde videte; Áit enim : Audi caelum, et auribus percipe terra: filios genui et exaltaei, ipsi autem me spreeerunt. → Ait enim : Audi caelum, et auribus percipe terra: filios genui et exaltavi, ipsi autem me spreverunt.; non se dixit. vidisse → non se dixit vidisse; quod audiei ex te esse, et timui? : → quod audivi ex te esse, et timui :; Ozias rez, eidi Dominum → Ozias rex, vidi Dominum; omnia el ostensa → omnia ei ostensa; et quia tune homini → et quia tunc homini; Spiritus sensum nis is qui eumdem Spiritum. habuisset → Spiritus sensum nisi is qui eumdem Spiritum habuisset; qui vero sul non → qui vero sui non; /Ve auribus audiant et corde intellegant et coneertantur et sanem eos → Ne auribus audiant et corde intellegant et convertantur et sanem eos.

Topics: Scripture and canon

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 16.1 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 168–172; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/16-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-16-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

16.2Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 172–175

Denique ob hoc et quattuor regum tempora scriba in titulo posuit, id est Oziam, Ioatham, Achaz, Ezechiam, ut sciretur quanto tempore et quam evidenter populum Israel propheta arguerit et nativitatem atque adventum Xpisti praedicaverit. Et nec ei sic credere voluerunt, sicut apostolus ait : An contemnis patientiam et longanimitatem Dei ignorans quod patientiam Dei ad paenitentiam te adducit ? Tu autem secundum duritiam cordis tui thesaurizas tibi iram in die irae iusti iudicii Dei. Et quia tanti temporis praevaricatio nihil populo profutura erat, in eo invenitur locutum Dominus per prophetam : Audi caelum, et percipe auribus terra, quoniam Dominus est locutus. Audi caelum, et percipe auribus terra, quasi vero caelum hoc aut terra aures proprias haberet, ut possit audire. Sed cum caelum nominaret, caelestes potestates, id est angelos sanctos, et terram, id est homines sanctos, ad audiendum verbum Domini provocabat, eo quod filii Israel contemnere Deum properabant, nec omnino ad paenitentiam post tanta scelera facinoraque redire volebant : proinde testatur caelum et terram, id est angelos caelestes et homines sanctos qui ex terrae substantia constiterunt, ut audirent quid Deus Dominus contulisset et quid ipsi in contemptum divinitatis egissent. Filios, ait, genui et exaltavi, ipsi autem me spreverunt. O grave peccatum et paene inexorabilis venia, ut eos quos Deus a se generatos et exaltatos dixerat ab ipsis spretum esse testetur! Generaverat eos utique per legem et exaltaverat per gratiam, quod de his ultra [...] omnium gentium potestas concessa erat. Et ideo hunc non spernere sed sequi et audire debuerant : in eo est enim materia rerum et ratio virtutum et fons omnium bonorum. Quid enim Deo aut potentia maius est aut ratione perfectius aut claritate luculentius? Qui quoniam eos ad sapientiam et iustitiam procreaverat, non fuerat fas, relicto Deo suo ac vitae datore, vanis fragilibusque simulacris atque idolis famulari, neque gulae ac libidini servientes ab innocentia et pietate discedere. Istae enim vitiosae et mortiferae voluptates, quae opulentium rerum animum hominis in laqueo consueverant, aeterna morte damnatae sunt. Ideo et hic improperans eis dicit : Filios genui et exaltavi, id est verbi semine et legis institutione genui et super omnes gentes exaltavi et extuli ; mirificos reges propter eos occidi, de terra Aegypti manu valida et excelso bracchio liberavi, in columna nubis per diem et in columna ignis per noctem praeivi eos, et interrupta equorum [...] cum circumstarent montes aquarum per medium pelagi sicco pede transire feci ; inimicos quoque eorum, redeuntibus in semet undis, occidi; pane angelorum in eremo satiavi, et disrupta durissima petra copiosam aquam sitientibus praestiti : ecce quibus beneficiis exaltavi, et vos dereliquistis!

Further, it is for this reason that the scribe put the times of four kings in the title, namely Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, Hezekiah, so that it might be known for how long a time and how plainly the prophet rebuked the people of Israel and preached the birth and coming of Christ. And even so they would not believe him, as the apostle says: "Or do you despise the patience and forbearance of God, not knowing that God's patience leads you to repentance? But by the hardness of your heart you store up wrath for yourself on the day of wrath of the just judgment of God." And since a transgression of so long a time was going to profit the people nothing, the Lord is found to have spoken against it through the prophet: "Hear, O heaven, and give ear, O earth, for the Lord has spoken." "Hear, O heaven, and give ear, O earth," as though this heaven or earth had ears of its own, so as to be able to hear. But when he named heaven, he was calling the heavenly powers, that is, the holy angels, and when he named earth, holy men, to hear the word of the Lord, because the sons of Israel were hastening to despise God and were entirely unwilling to return to repentance after such great crimes and misdeeds. So he calls heaven and earth to witness, that is, the heavenly angels and the holy men who consist of the substance of the earth, that they might hear what the Lord God had bestowed and what they themselves had done in contempt of the Godhead. "I have begotten and exalted sons," he says, "but they have despised me." O grave sin, and pardon almost beyond entreaty, that God testifies he has been despised by those whom he said were begotten and exalted by him! He had begotten them through the law and exalted them through grace, since power over all nations had been granted ... to them. And so they should not have despised him but followed and heard him: for in him is the substance of things and the principle of virtues and the fountain of all good things. For what is greater than God in power, or more perfect in reason, or more brilliant in glory? Since he had begotten them for wisdom and righteousness, it was not right for them, forsaking their God and the giver of life, to serve vain and fragile images and idols, nor, serving gluttony and lust, to depart from innocence and piety. For these vicious and deadly pleasures, which used to snare the soul of man with rich things, have been condemned to eternal death. And so here too he reproaches them, saying: "I have begotten and exalted sons," that is: I begot you by the seed of the word and the instruction of the law, and exalted and lifted you above all nations; for your sake I killed wonderful kings; I freed you from the land of Egypt with a strong hand and an uplifted arm; I went before you in a pillar of cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night; and, breaking the ... while mountains of water stood around him, I made you cross through the middle of the sea with dry feet; I also killed your enemies, the waves returning on themselves; I fed you with the bread of angels in the desert, and, splitting the hardest rock, I gave abundant water to the thirsty: see with what benefits I exalted you, and you have forsaken me!

Isa 1:1 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 2:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 2:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 1:2 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 135:10 (134:10 LXX) (allusion, medium confidence) · Deut 5:15 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 13:21 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 14:22 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 14:28 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 78:25 (77:25 LXX) (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 17:6 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The four kings in Isaiah's title show the long duration of his warnings; heaven and earth, angels and holy men, are called to witness Israel's ingratitude toward the God who begot, exalted and delivered them.

  • Words are missing in the digital text in two places (marked [...]): after "power over all nations had been granted" and in the account of the Red Sea crossing.
  • Gregory's rebuke of Israel follows Isaiah's, translated as written.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slips; OCR slips; stray points; leaked footnote mark; stray point; stray space): Án contemnis patientiam et longanimitatem Dei ienorans quod. patientiam Dei ad. paenitentiam → An contemnis patientiam et longanimitatem Dei ignorans quod patientiam Dei ad paenitentiam; Dominus est locutus ?. → Dominus est locutus.; potestates, 1d est angelos → potestates, id est angelos; ut audirent. quid Deus → ut audirent quid Deus; Filios, ait, genui et exaltaei, ipsi autem me spreeerunt. → Filios, ait, genui et exaltavi, ipsi autem me spreverunt.; vanis fragilibusque simulaeris → vanis fragilibusque simulacris; et pietate. discedere → et pietate discedere; Filios genui et exaltapi, 1d est → Filios genui et exaltavi, id est; eum circumstarent → cum circumstarent; et vos dereliquistis ! → et vos dereliquistis!.

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 16.2 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 172–175; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/16-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-16-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

16.3Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 175–176

Et ob hoc qualem comparationem subiunxit audite : Agnovit bos possessorem suum et asinus praesepe domini sui, Israel autem me non cognovit et plebs me non intellexit. Quid ideo dicit quod animalia muta et ratione carentia populo illi praeponeret? Illa etenim nutritores suos et dominos agnoscunt et sequuntur, et vocem dant cum eos vident vel audiunt; populus autem Iudaeorum genitorem suum et dominum et bonorum omnium datorem noluit agnoscere. Non enim dicitur : quia non potuit, ideo non agnovit, sed quia sponte noluit, sicut per Hieremiam ait : Turtur et hirundo cognoverunt tempora introitus sui, populus autem meus me non cognovit. O misera et detestanda stoliditas populi quibus bos et asinus, muta scilicet animalia, et turtur et hirundo, dulces scilicet aves, proponuntur. Sic et in euangelio ipse Dominus propria voce testatus est dicens : Hierusalem, Hierusalem, quotiens volui congregare filios tuos, ut gallina pullos suos sub ascellis, et tu noluisti! Non dixit : et tu non potuisti, sed noluisti, ait. Non posse enim veniam habet, nolle vero contemptus est. Sed soletis requirere quare Dominus noster se gallinae voluit comparare in euangelio, cum et in lege et prophetis aquilae, id est regi alitum, comparatur. Sic enim de eo scriptum est : Sicut aquila protegit nidum suum et renovabitur, sicut aquila in scapulis suis portabit pullos, Dominus Deus protexit eos. Proinde disserendum est cur se Dominus in euangelio non aquilae sed gallinae similem dixerit. Recte utique tunc aquila dicebatur, quia unum nidum et unius generis pullos, id est solius Israel populum contra omnes gentes et nationes protegere dignabatur. Nunc vero gallinae ideo se similem dixerit, quia ex omni genere avium nemo alieni generis ova compressa et calefacta excludit, nemo alieni generis pullos suppositos aut nutrit aut sub ascellis suis servat et pascit, nisi sola gallina. Sic et nemo alius diversarum nationum et alienarum gentium populos sub ascellis crucis suae et sub plumis virtutum suarum colligere potuit et in vitam aeternam calore Spiritus animare caelestique cibo satiare, nisi Xpistus Dei filius vivi, qui non solum filios Israel voluit sub ascellis crucis suae colligere, sed et omnes, ut dixi, gentes et nationes sub protectione alarum suarum redigens ab omni iniuria et periculo defensare dignatur, sicut scriptum est : In umbra alarum tuarum sperabo donec transeat iniquitas. Hunc ergo genitorem, hunc defensorem et salvatorem humani generis noluit agnoscere populus Israel euangelica voce praeconantem, quem et retro noluerat per prophetas audire.

And hear what comparison he added because of this: "The ox knows its owner and the donkey its master's manger, but Israel has not known me, and the people has not understood me." Why does he say this, setting dumb animals, lacking reason, before that people? For they recognize and follow those who feed them and their masters, and give voice when they see or hear them; but the people of the Jews refused to recognize its begetter and lord and the giver of all good things. For it is not said that they did not recognize because they could not, but because they willfully refused, as he says through Jeremiah: "The turtledove and the swallow have known the times of their coming, but my people has not known me." O wretched and detestable stupidity of the people, before whom the ox and the donkey, dumb animals, and the turtledove and the swallow, sweet birds, are set! So too in the Gospel the Lord himself testified with his own voice, saying: "Jerusalem, Jerusalem, how often I wanted to gather your children, as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings, and you would not!" He did not say "and you could not," but "you would not." For inability has pardon; unwillingness is contempt. But you are accustomed to ask why our Lord wished to compare himself to a hen in the Gospel, when in the law and the prophets he is compared to the eagle, the king of birds. For so it is written of him: "As an eagle protects its nest and will be renewed, as an eagle will carry its young on its shoulders, the Lord God protected them." We must therefore discuss why the Lord in the Gospel said he was like not an eagle but a hen. He was rightly then called an eagle, because he deigned to protect one nest and chicks of one kind, that is, the people of Israel alone, against all races and nations. But now he said he was like a hen, because of all kinds of birds none hatches by sitting on and warming the eggs of another kind, none either feeds or keeps and nourishes under its wings the chicks of another kind placed beneath it, except the hen alone. So too no one else could gather the peoples of different nations and foreign races under the wings of his cross and under the feathers of his powers, and animate them for eternal life by the warmth of the Spirit and satisfy them with heavenly food, except Christ, the Son of the living God, who not only wished to gather the sons of Israel under the wings of his cross, but also, as I said, deigns to defend all races and nations, bringing them under the protection of his wings, from every injury and danger, as it is written: "In the shadow of your wings I will hope until iniquity passes." This begetter, then, this defender and savior of the human race, the people of Israel refused to recognize when he preached with the voice of the Gospel, whom formerly too it had refused to hear through the prophets.

Isa 1:3 (quotation, high confidence) · Jer 8:7 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 23:37 (quotation, high confidence) · Deut 32:11 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 103:5 (102:5 LXX) (echo, low confidence) · Matt 16:16 (allusion, medium confidence) · Ps 57:1 (56:2 LXX) (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The ox and donkey that know their master shame unbelieving Israel; Christ compares himself to a hen, not an eagle, because he gathers under the wings of his cross the chicks of other nations too.

  • "As an eagle protects its nest": Deut 32:11 combined with Ps 103:5.
  • Gregory's judgments on the Jewish people follow Isaiah's rebuke, translated as written.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip; leaked footnote mark; leaked footnote mark; leaked footnote number; stray point): subiunxit audite Agnoeit bos → subiunxit audite : Agnovit bos; me non intellexit *. → me non intellexit.; me non cognovit ?. → me non cognovit.; et tu noluisti 3! → et tu noluisti!; Sicut aquila. protegit → Sicut aquila protegit; Dominus Deus protexit eos !. → Dominus Deus protexit eos.; disserendum est. cur se → disserendum est cur se; animare .caelestique → animare caelestique; sub protestatione alarum → sub protectione alarum; 7n umbra alarum tuarum sperabo donec transeat iniquitas ?. → In umbra alarum tuarum sperabo donec transeat iniquitas..

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 16.3 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 175–176; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/16-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-16-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

16.4Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 176–179

Quamobrem subiunxit dicens : Vae genti peccatrici, populo pleno peccatis ! Filii scelerati, dereliquistis Dominum patrem, dum filium ipsius denegastis, qui adhuc apponitis iniquitatem adicientes ad iniquitatem, hoc est dicere : qui ad haec scelera sceleribus cumulatis, dereliquistis Deum patrem et ad iracundiam provocastis semen Israel. Non quod patriarcharum ipsorum Israel ad iracundiam provocaverint, qui ante multos annos quam haec dicerentur iam in pace praecesserant; sed sanctum Israel, id est Xpistum, ad iracundiam non ei credendo provocaverunt. Israel etenim homo videns Deum ex hebraea lingua in latino sermone interpretatur : et quis homo est qui Deum vidit, cum scriptum sit ad Moysen : Non poteris faciem meam videre, nemo enim vidit Deum et vixit? Salvator quoque in euangelio : Deum, inquit, nemo vidit unquam nisi unicus filius, qui est in sinu Patris. Ergo quia Deum nemo vidit nisi unicus filius, merito ipse est Israel, qui et homo secundum carnem natus est et Deum patrem solus ipse, qui filius Dei est, vidit et videt. Hoc est Israel homo videns Deum, quem ad iracundiam non ei credendo provocaverunt. Sed adhuc adiecit : Omne caput in dolore et omne cor in moerore. Caput principes eorum et sacerdotes appellat, cor autem Scribas et Pharisaeos, qui sacrorum mysteriorum arcana populis intimabant. Quos ideo in moerore et dolore dicebat esse conversos, quia ei caput suum Xpistum non esse cognoverant, et cor, quod est sapientia, filium Dei Xpistum esse spreverant. Non est, inquit, ubi malagma imponere neque oleum neque alligaturas : vere haec et merito omnia de illo populo dicebantur, cui non corpus sed anima incredulitatis vitio vulnerata iacebat. Malagma enim et oleum et alligaturae fomenta sunt corporis non animae : ideo eorum animae infirmabantur ; ista medicamenta ad animae curationem adhibere non poterant. Sed si vis animae vulneratae malagma conficere, quod tumores eius comprimat et vitia curet, assume tibi paenitentiam delictorum, qua malagma de bonorum operum pigmento confectum ut eleemosynam indigentibus praebeas ; oleum quoque, id est pinguissimam chrismatis gratiam diligenter infunde; alligaturas vero, id est euangelicae disciplinae vincula stringe. Quae quia ille populus uti nolebat, ideo animae eorum curari non poterant, sicut curatus est ille euangelicus vulneratus, qui cum descendens ab Hierusalem in Hiericho incidisset in latrones, quem, cum Samaritanus euangelicus colligens vulnera eius in vino et oleo refovisset, id est gratiam chrismatis et redemptionem sui sanguinis praestans, et euangeliorum vinculis colligasset, imposuit in iumentum legis, adduxit ad stabulum Ecclesiae, stabulario id est angelo Ecclesiae consignavit, datis ad curam duobus denariis : duo scilicet numismata regalia, id est Patris et Filii inscriptionem habentia. Haec est medicina perfecta, haec ratio curationis quae et corpus et animam potest ab omni infirmitate liberare. Qua, sanctissimi fratres, quantum possumus boni ac beneficii, animum mentemque foveamus, ut vere sani et felices ante conspectum Dei patris omnipotentis esse possitis.

Therefore he added, saying: "Woe to the sinful nation, a people full of sins! Wicked sons, you have forsaken the Lord the Father," when you denied his Son, "you who still add iniquity, adding iniquity to iniquity": that is to say, you who heap crimes on these crimes, "you have forsaken God the Father and provoked to anger the seed of Israel." Not that they provoked to anger the Israel of the patriarchs themselves, who had gone before in peace many years before these things were said; but they provoked to anger the holy Israel, that is, Christ, by not believing him. For Israel, from the Hebrew language, is interpreted in Latin as "a man seeing God": and what man is there who has seen God, since it is written to Moses, "You cannot see my face, for no one has seen God and lived"? The Savior too in the Gospel: "No one," he says, "has ever seen God except the only Son, who is in the bosom of the Father." So, since no one has seen God except the only Son, he himself is rightly Israel, who was both born a man according to the flesh and alone, being the Son of God, has seen and sees God the Father. This is Israel, the man seeing God, whom they provoked to anger by not believing him. But he added further: "Every head is in pain and every heart in grief." By head he means their rulers and priests, by heart the scribes and Pharisees, who conveyed the secrets of the sacred mysteries to the peoples. He said they were turned to grief and pain because they had not recognized Christ as their head, and the heart, which is wisdom, had despised Christ as the Son of God. "There is no place," he says, "to apply a poultice, nor oil, nor bandages": truly and rightly were all these things said of that people, whose soul, not body, lay wounded by the vice of unbelief. For a poultice, oil, and bandages are remedies of the body, not the soul: so their souls were sick; they could not apply these medicines to the cure of the soul. But if you want to make a poultice for a wounded soul, to reduce its swellings and cure its vices, take repentance for your offenses, with which a poultice made of the pigment of good works, so that you give alms to the needy; pour in diligently oil too, that is, the richest grace of the chrism; and bind on bandages, that is, the bonds of gospel discipline. Since that people would not use these, their souls could not be cured, as the wounded man of the Gospel was cured, who, going down from Jerusalem to Jericho, fell among robbers; when the gospel Samaritan, gathering up his wounds, had soothed them with wine and oil, that is, bestowing the grace of the chrism and the redemption of his own blood, and had bound them with the bonds of the Gospels, he set him on the beast of the law, brought him to the inn of the Church, entrusted him to the innkeeper, that is, the angel of the Church, giving two denarii for his care: two royal coins, that is, bearing the inscription of the Father and the Son. This is the perfect medicine, this the method of cure that can free both body and soul from every sickness. With it, most holy brothers, let us cherish our soul and mind with as much good and benefit as we can, so that you may be truly healthy and happy before the face of God the Father almighty.

Isa 1:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 33:20 (quotation, high confidence) · John 1:18 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 1:5 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 1:6 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 10:30 (allusion, high confidence) · Luke 10:34 (allusion, high confidence) · Luke 10:35 (allusion, high confidence) · Rev 2:1 (allusion, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Israel provoked Christ, the true 'Israel' who alone sees God; the untreatable wounds of Isa 1:6 are cured only by repentance, almsgiving, chrism and gospel discipline, as in the parable of the Good Samaritan.

  • A block of meaningless OCR characters at the end of the digital text is removed.
  • "The angel of the Church": the bishop, as in Rev 2–3.
  • Gregory's judgments on the Jewish people follow Isaiah's text, translated as written.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR slip; OCR slip (1 for i); OCR slip; leaked footnote mark; OCR slips; OCR slips; leaked footnote mark; leaked OCR garbage at the end of the section): iam 1n pace → iam in pace; faciem meam eidere, nemo enim vidit Deum et eixit?? → faciem meam videre, nemo enim vidit Deum et vixit?; Deum, inquit, nemo eidit unquam → Deum, inquit, nemo vidit unquam; merito 1pse est Israel → merito ipse est Israel; cor autem Sceribas et Pharisaeos, qui sacrprum → cor autem Scribas et Pharisaeos, qui sacrorum; /Von est, inquit, ubi malagma imponere neque oleum neque alligaturas ! : → Non est, inquit, ubi malagma imponere neque oleum neque alligaturas :; incidisset 1n latrones → incidisset in latrones; CST UE aee M eurn EUR tU S RU RI 711 ico p TRUE LI TM PN WR EL → .

Topics: Christology

Cite (SBL): Gregory of Elvira, Tract. Orig. 16.4 (Batiffol-Wilmart 1900, 176–179; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis/16-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-gregory-elvira-tractatus-origenis-16-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.