Sermons 72–76
Latin text: Migne, PL 52 (Latin text: Migne, Patrologia Latina, digitized by Open Greek and Latin (patrologia_latina-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).
Chapter 72
72PL 52:403–405
In eamdem. Quod ego modo cum magno tremore dicturus sum, quod vos estis nunc terribiliter audituri, immoterribiliter vocaturi, stupent angeli, pavescunt virtutes, supernum coelum non capit, sol non videt,terra non sustinet, tota non assequitur creatura. Quid ad haec mortale pectus? Quid ad haec mens hominis imbecilla? Quid ad haec humani sensus angustia? Quid ad haec humanae vocis aura? Quid ad istud humana lingua cito tacitura? Hoc Paulus invisibiliter cum vidisset, prodidit non prodendo, dicens: Nec oculus vidit, nec auris audivit, nec in cor hominis ascendit, quæ præparavit Deus diligentibus se (I Cor. II). Hoc Isaias cum suo mox coepissetauditu, ad hoc hominum pervenire posse dubitat vel fidem, dicens: Domine, quis credidit auditui nostro (Isai. LIII)? Hoc Jeremias cum divino concepisset auditu, partus supernorum sensuum non sustinebat, clamans: Ventrem meum, ventrem meum doleo, et sensus cordis mei perturbati sunt (Jerem. IV). Hoc Habacucdivini spiritus perorabat afflatu, cum dicit: Custodivi, et expavit venter meus a voce orationis labiorum meorum; et intravit tremor inossamea;ete subtus me commota est virtus mea (Babac. III). Elevatus virtute Dei sensit suam sub se succubuisse virtutem. Longum est super hoc sacramentum pavoris prosequi, et dinumerare sanctorum exempla: tempus non sinit diu me in hoc timore demorari, coelestis partus impetus non potest tardarenascentium. Dieo ergo, et vos in utero adhuc penetrali voce compello, provida exhortatione præmoneo; ut antequam videatis matrem, vocetiset patrem, ante blandimentamatris, patris tendatis etfestinetisadregnum,ante patris præveniatis ad panemquam matris ad ubera pendeatis. Nec in vos quidquam sibi.autmatris necessitas, aut ætatis tempora vindicent: sed in vobis totum divino patri, totum cælesti respondeat et occurratauctori (Matth. VI). Pater noster qui es in caelis. Hoc est quod pavebam dicere, hoc est quod trepidabam proferre, hoc est quod neque cælestium, neque terrestriumquemquam sinebat servitutis propriae conditio suspicari: cæli et terrae, carnis et Dei repente tantum posse provenire commercium, ut Deus in hominem, homo in Deum; Dominus in servum, servus verteretur in filium, fieretque divinitatis et hu manitatis ineffabili modo una et sempiterna cognatio. Et quidem deitatis erga nos dignatio tantaest,utscire nequeat quid potissimum mirari debeat creatura: utrum quod se Deus ad nostram deposuit servitutem, an quod nos ad suae divinitatis rapuit dignitatem. Hinc est,homo, quod te divinitus adhortatur, aqui tanto nunc uo amore flammatur: quod adhuc in utero voce tuate Deus adoptat in filium; quod te non fieri solum liberum vult ille,sed nasci;quod ipsam propter te manumittit naturam,nequemnaevum, nequam maculam imponat ortus pristinæ servitutis. O vosbeatos, quibus dominari datum est ante quam nasci,an te regnare quam vivere, ante ad Dei Patris gloriam pervenire quam prosapiam propriae vilitatis agnoscere. Ecclesia Felix mater, quæ vos tales respicit, quae cum vir- go permaneat, genuisse tales, et tantos vos taliter I se miramur. Olim partus iste præsedentibus designabatur exemplis. Hinc est quod Jacob in utero matris cum fratre luctatur (Gen, xxv), praeripit et triumphos. Hinc est quod in utero Thamar gemini de primatus honore præliantur, retardant partus, nec ante lucem cupiunt videre quam vincere (Gen. XXXVIII). Hinc est quod Joaunes exsultat ante, et ante suo occurit auctori genitricis ex utero quam procedat (Luc.I). Et si humana pignora sic ante Deo militant, quam nascantur parentibus, quam vivant sæculo; quid mirum si Ecclesiae divina germina, si Deo sua soboles in utero adhuc, quod sit superni germinis jam fatetur? Pater noster qui es in cæli,. Stupor insurgit, Chris tus de Dei patris pectore matrem vocat et fateturin terra; et homo de matris utero patrem vocat,et confitetur in cœlis, Pater noster quies in coelis. Quo te homo repente provexit gratia? quo te rapuitccelestisnatura? ut incarne et in terra positus adhuc, et carnem jam noscias et terram,dicendo: Pater noster qui es in cælis. Qui ergo se tanti Patris filium confitetur et credit, respondeat vita generi, moribus patri, et mente atque actu asserat quod cælestem consecutus est per naturam,Santificetur nomen tuum. Cujus utique genus esse coœpimus, ejus utique censemur et nomine: et ideo petimus ut in nobis illius nominis sanctificatio perseveret,honor et praerogativa nominis, quod sublimavit sic tanti Genitoris celsitudo. dveniat regnum tuum. Nonilli petimus cui num quam defuit regnum, immo qui est ipse regnum, totamque in se regni continet potestatem; sed pui nos vult ad promissam regni gloriam pervenire, monet nos expetere omnibus hoc votis,in hoc vult nos totis mentibus inhiare. Quantum namque est temerarius qui discutit de genere, ignavus est tantum qui non gaudet, æstuat, anhelat, cum promissum intend it et perteneit ad regnum. Fiat voluntas tua sicut in cælo et in terra. Sicut in cælo, sic et in terra; tunc jam totum coelum est, tunc agit Dei mens una omnes,tunc in Christi omnes et in omnibus Christus, quando omnes solius Dei sapiunt, et a faciunt voluntates; tunc omnes unum,immo unus omnes quando Dei spiritus in omnibus vivit unus. Panem nosrum quotidianum da nobis hodie.Sicut in psalmo: Benedictus Dominus de die quotidie (Psal. LXVII); ita hic Panem nostrum quotidianum da nobis hodie. Quotidianumjugem dicimus; jugis panis ille est, qui de coelo descendit: Ego sum panis qui de cœlo descendit (Joan. VI).e Perfectæ ergo beatitudinis est iste panis; hodie,hoc est in praesenti, illius panis cibo jam vivere incipimus,cuj us perpetuitatA, quod est quotidie, saginabimur in futurum. Et dimitlenobis debita nostrasicutet nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris. De supplicantis pectore veniæ fons emanat, et ad veniam refluet: quidquid pietatis exuberat, et effundit in alterum, quando indulget sibi tantum quantum alteri condonaverit. Et dimitteno- bis debita nostra sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris. Satis potest homo misericors, qui cum Deo de nietate confligit, cum tantum sibi dari quantum dederit,quantum donaverit tantum desiderat et donari. Homo, sit semper in pectore tuo venia, si vis crimina non timere, Et ne nos inducas in tentatio. nem. Haec interpretatione indigent, quia tentatio diaboli praevia et amara est ministra ejus: quamdiu vero hoc fragili continemur in corpore, necessario precamur ut in nos nec tentationi pateat aditus, nec diabolo tribuatur accessus. Sed liberanos a malo. Ipse autem Dominus Deus noster liberet nos a malo, et perducat ad omne bonum, qui vi vit et regnat Deus modo et semper, et per inpnita sæcula sæculorum. Amen. a
[On the same.] What I am now about to say with great trembling, what you are now about to hear with awe, or rather to call out with awe, the angels are astonished at, the powers dread, the highest heaven does not contain, the sun does not see, the earth does not sustain, the whole creation does not attain. What is a mortal breast before this? What is the weak mind of man before this? What the narrowness of human understanding? What the breath of the human voice? What the human tongue, soon to fall silent? When Paul had seen this invisibly, he disclosed it by not disclosing it, saying: “Eye has not seen, nor ear heard, nor has it entered the heart of man, what God has prepared for those who love him” (1 Cor 2:9). When Isaiah had begun to hear this, he doubted whether even faith in it could reach human beings, saying: “Lord, who has believed our report?” (Isa 53:1). When Jeremiah had conceived this by divine hearing, he could not bear the birth of heavenly thoughts, and cried: “My belly, my belly, I am in pain, and the thoughts of my heart are troubled” (Jer 4:19). Habakkuk was pleading this by the breath of the divine Spirit when he says: “I kept watch, and my belly trembled at the voice of the prayer of my lips; and trembling entered my bones, and beneath me my strength was troubled” (Hab 3:16). Lifted up by the power of God, he felt his own strength sink beneath him. It would take long to pursue this mystery of fear and to enumerate the examples of the saints; time does not allow me to linger long in this fear; the onrush of the heavenly birth cannot hold back those who are being born. So I speak, and I address you, still in the womb, with a penetrating voice; I forewarn you with provident exhortation, that before you see your mother you should call on your Father; that before your mother's caresses you should strive and hasten toward your Father's kingdom; that you should reach your Father's bread before you hang at your mother's breasts. Let neither a mother's claims nor the stages of age claim anything in you for themselves; but let everything in you answer to and run to meet the divine Father, the heavenly maker. “Our Father who are in heaven” (Matt 6:9). This is what I was afraid to say, this is what I trembled to utter, this is what the condition of their own servitude allowed none of the heavenly or earthly beings to suspect: that so great an exchange could suddenly take place between heaven and earth, between flesh and God, that God should be turned into man and man into God, the Lord into a servant and the servant into a son, and that there should come about, in an ineffable way, one everlasting kinship of divinity and humanity. And indeed the condescension of the deity toward us is so great that creation cannot know what it ought to marvel at most: that God lowered himself to our servitude, or that he carried us off to the dignity of his divinity. That is why, O man, he who is now inflamed with such great love for you exhorts you from heaven: that while you are still in the womb God adopts you as a son by your own voice; that he wants you not only to become free but to be born free; that for your sake he sets nature itself free, so that birth may impose no blemish, no stain of the old servitude. O blessed are you, to whom it is given to rule before being born, to reign before living, to reach the glory of God the Father before recognizing the stock of your own lowliness. Happy mother church, who looks on you as such! We marvel that she, while remaining a virgin, has borne you so, as such and so great. Of old this birth was signified by examples that went before. That is why Jacob wrestles with his brother in his mother's womb (Gen 25:22) and snatches the triumph beforehand. That is why in Tamar's womb the twins fight over the honour of the firstborn, delay the birth, and want to conquer before they see the light (Gen 38:27–30). That is why John leaps for joy and goes to meet his maker before he comes out of his mother's womb (Luke 1:41). And if human offspring thus serve as soldiers of God before they are born to their parents, before they live in the world, what wonder if the divine shoots of the church, God's own offspring, still in the womb, already confess that they are of heavenly stock? “Our Father who are in heaven.” Amazement rises: Christ, from the bosom of God the Father, calls on a mother and confesses her on earth; and man, from his mother's womb, calls on a Father and confesses him in heaven. “Our Father who are in heaven.” To what height, O man, has grace suddenly carried you? Where has the heavenly nature swept you, that, though still placed in flesh and on earth, you already disown flesh and earth by saying, “Our Father who are in heaven”? So let him who confesses and believes himself a son of so great a Father answer to his lineage by his life and to his Father by his conduct, and assert in mind and action what he has obtained as heavenly by nature. “Hallowed be your name.” We are reckoned by the name of him whose lineage we have begun to be; and so we ask that the hallowing of that name may continue in us, the honour and privilege of the name which the loftiness of so great a parent has so exalted. “Your kingdom come.” We do not ask it for him who has never lacked the kingdom, who rather is himself the kingdom and holds in himself the whole power of the kingdom; but he who wants us to come to the promised glory of the kingdom urges us to seek it with all our prayers; he wants us to long for it with our whole minds. For as rash as one who disputes about his lineage is, so slothful is one who does not rejoice, burn and pant as he reaches out and stretches toward the promised kingdom. “Your will be done, as in heaven so also on earth.” As in heaven, so also on earth: then everything is heaven, then the one mind of God moves all, then all are in Christ and Christ is in all, when all savour and do the will of God alone; then all are one, or rather all are one man, when the one Spirit of God lives in all. “Give us today our daily bread.” As in the psalm, “Blessed be the Lord day by day” (Ps 68:19), so here: “Give us today our daily bread.” By daily we mean continual; that bread is continual which came down from heaven: “I am the bread that came down from heaven” (John 6:41). This bread, then, belongs to perfect blessedness; today, that is, in the present, we already begin to live on the food of that bread, on whose perpetuity, which is what “daily” means, we shall feast in the future. “And forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors.” From the breast of the one who prays the spring of pardon flows out and flows back as pardon: whatever love overflows and pours out on another, when one pardons oneself as much as one has pardoned another. “And forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors.” A merciful man is strong enough, who contends with God in love, when he desires to be given as much as he has given and to be forgiven as much as he has forgiven. O man, let pardon always be in your breast, if you wish not to fear your crimes. “And lead us not into temptation.” These words need interpretation, because temptation goes before the devil and is his bitter servant; as long as we are held in this fragile body, we must pray that no entry be open to temptation in us and no access granted to the devil. “But deliver us from evil.” May the Lord our God himself deliver us from evil and lead us to every good, who lives and reigns as God now and always, and through infinite ages of ages. Amen.
1 Cor 2:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 53:1 (quotation, high confidence) · Jer 4:19 (quotation, high confidence) · Hab 3:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 6:9–13 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 25:22 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 38:27–30 (allusion, high confidence) · Luke 1:41 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 68:19 (67:20 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · John 6:41 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Chrysologus speaks of the awe of calling God Father, addresses the candidates as children still in the womb of the virgin church, and briefly explains each petition of the Lord's Prayer.
- “You already disown flesh and earth” renders carnem jam noscias et terram as printed; the sense requires nescias (“do not know”), and the sentence is translated by sense. The sentence on mother church (“We marvel that she…”) is garbled in the digital text; translated by sense. Migne's reference “Matth. VI” stands misplaced after the sentence before the Lord's Prayer.
Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 72 (PL 52:403–405; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/72). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/72
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-72) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.
Chapter 73
73PL 52:405–407
De paschali solemnitate. Hodierna festivitas, fratres charissimi, nobis ve- tera non connectit, nec carnes agni a servat in crastinum: sed dum praeterita præsentibus solemni devotione participat,etPascha nostrurp,Pascharedeunte conjungit, novæ regenerationis ablactat infantiam, quia juxta Apostolum, Vetera transierunt, et ecce facta sunt omnia nova (II Cor. v), Annus Domini perficitur temporibus, non senescit, qui tamdiu suo recurrit in circulo, quamdiu nos ad diem retributionis adducat. Paschalis hodierna solemnitas a larte, quos ante genuit, nuncc repellit, ut solidoris cibi pastu, perfectum Christi roborentur in virum. Fecisse Abrahame epulum magnum,totiusquedomus sum laetitiam suscitasse ablactato Isaac,historia divina referente cegnovimus (Gen. XXI). Etsi senectutis soboles, si sterilis unicus, choris tripudiantibus, cithara et tympano, et toto psalterii resonante concentu, universae familiae corda traxit et commovit in gaudium,quanto magis nos hodie in hymnis spiritualibus convenit exsultare, uel canticis, quando a Virginis in germine ablactatur universa fecundititas? Si Anna Saræ consterilis, puæ lacrymis orationum suarum tamdiu madefecitariditatemsui corporis et naturae, quamdiufuerat lango vitas tempore negata posteritas, Samuelem divine munere susceptum, ablactatum mox divinum refundit in munus, et lætitiamsuam sacrificiorum victimis ad plenitudinem liberationis accumulat (I Reg. I); multo magis nos oportet laudis immolare sacrificium, vota solvere, suavitatis incensum adolere,et tota holocaustorum pinguedine Deo Patri victimas immolare, quando Virgo mater enutrita et ablactata tot numero pignora quot stellas cœli, Patri toto orbe repraesentat, ut impleatur illud propheticum: Benedices coronamanni benignitatis, et campi tui replebentur ubertate (Psal. XL). Nemo ereo otiesum esse credat istud festivitatis nostrae salutare mysterium, nec existimet pannum novum veterinosassuere vestimento, ubi nihilJudaicae vetustatis, novitati conjungimus Christianæ: scientes, Apostolo dicente, novam totam in Christo nobis emersisse creaturam; sed agnitionem divinam supernae virtutis evehimus ad profectum (II Cor. v), ut dum simul nuper nati quid debeant imbuuntur, et ante geniti quantam Deo gratiam de perfectione sua debeantins instruuntur, appendantur collo ii qui modo nati sunt, et pietate tota sub Ecclesiae matris uberibus occupentur, trahamteneris faucibus innocentiae pastum, in opere san cto brachia meditentur extendere, nitantur in cursu fidei tremula firmare vestigia. Numquid sic relinquendi sunt jam nutriti, ut non patris cura, patris manu, patris regantur arbitrio? et ita matris consilio,matrisfide muniantur, ut non humana solum. sed etiam divina prudentia percipiant et praeripiant salutaria? Sic Jacob suo nimis timidus, matris con- silioi satis audax, patris ut praeriperetbenedictionem, plus mysticus quam dolosus incessit (Gen. XXVII); nam primogenitum se mentitus non est,quia ille primus est quem coelestis gratia generat, uon natura mortalis; ille nos sub hircorum pellibus figurabat,qui ut moriamur peccato, hortatu matris Ecclesias mortificati corporis induimur vestimento, et opore agri continuis confessionum fructibus et ubertate redolemus, doneccaecitati Israeliticæ salutariter illudentes, paternam benedictionem toto fidei præripiamus arcano, dicente Apostolo: Cæcitas Israel facta est, donec plenitudo gentium introiret ex parte (Rom. II, 25. i
[On the paschal feast.] Today's festival, dearest brothers, does not join old things to us, nor does it keep the flesh of the lamb until the morning; but while it shares the past with the present in solemn devotion and joins our Pasch to the returning Pasch, it weans the infancy of the new regeneration, because, according to the Apostle, “the old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new” (2 Cor 5:17). The Lord's year is completed in its seasons but does not grow old; it runs round again in its circle for as long as it takes to bring us to the day of retribution. Today's paschal solemnity now takes from milk those whom it bore earlier, so that by feeding on more solid food they may be strengthened into the perfect man of Christ. We know from the account of sacred history that Abraham made a great feast and roused his whole household to joy when Isaac was weaned (Gen 21:8). If the offspring of old age, the only son of a barren woman, with dancing choirs, lyre and drum, and the whole harmony of the psaltery resounding, drew and moved the hearts of the whole household to joy, how much more fitting is it for us today to exult in spiritual hymns and songs, when the whole fruitfulness born of the Virgin is weaned? If Hannah, Sarah's fellow in barrenness, who moistened the dryness of her body and nature with the tears of her prayers for as long as offspring had been denied her through a long time, gave back Samuel, received as a divine gift, as a gift to God as soon as he was weaned, and heaped up her joy with sacrificial victims to the full measure of her deliverance (1 Sam 1), much more ought we to offer a sacrifice of praise, pay our vows, burn the incense of sweetness, and sacrifice victims to God the Father with all the fatness of burnt offerings, when the Virgin mother, having nourished and weaned as many children as there are stars in the sky, presents them to the Father throughout the whole world, so that the prophet's word may be fulfilled: “You will bless the crown of the year of your goodness, and your fields will be filled with abundance” (Ps 65:11). So let no one think that this saving mystery of our festival is idle, or suppose that we sew a new patch onto an old garment, when we join nothing of Jewish oldness to Christian newness, knowing, as the Apostle says, that a whole new creation has arisen for us in Christ (2 Cor 5:17). Rather, we raise divine knowledge to the advance of heavenly power, so that, while the newly born are taught at the same time what they owe, and those born earlier are instructed how much thanks they owe to God for their perfection, those who have just been born may be hung on the neck and be wholly occupied, with all love, beneath the breasts of mother church, may draw the food of innocence with tender throats, may practise stretching out their arms in holy work, may strive to steady their trembling steps on the course of faith. Are those already nourished to be left in such a way that they are not ruled by the father's care, the father's hand, the father's judgment, and so protected by the mother's counsel and the mother's faith that they may perceive and seize what brings salvation not only by human but also by divine prudence? So Jacob, very timid on his own but bold enough through his mother's counsel, went in to snatch his father's blessing, more as a mystery than as a deceiver (Gen 27). For he did not lie in claiming to be the firstborn, because the firstborn is the one whom heavenly grace begets, not mortal nature. He prefigured us under the goatskins: we who, that we may die to sin, at the urging of mother church put on the garment of the mortified body, and are fragrant with the continual fruits of confession and the abundance of the field's work, until, mocking Israel's blindness in a saving way, we seize the paternal blessing in the whole secret of faith, as the Apostle says: “Blindness has come upon Israel in part, until the fullness of the Gentiles comes in” (Rom 11:25).
Exod 12:10 (allusion, medium confidence) · 2 Cor 5:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 4:13 (allusion, medium confidence) · Gen 21:8 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Sam 1:1–28 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 15:5 (allusion, low confidence) · Ps 65:11 (64:12 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 9:16 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 27:1–29 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 11:25 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: At the paschal feast Chrysologus compares those the church bore in baptism earlier, now taken from milk, to weaned children, recalling the feasts for Isaac and Samuel, and reads Jacob's taking of the blessing as a figure of the church.
- “Nor keep the flesh of the lamb until the morning” alludes to Exod 12:10. Migne's reference “Psal. XL” is mistaken; the quotation is Ps 65:11 (LXX 64:12). Jacob's deception (Gen 27) is read allegorically, and the statement about Israel's blindness follows Rom 11:25; both are translated as written.
Topics: Baptism
Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 73 (PL 52:405–407; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/73). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/73
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-73) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.
Chapter 74
74PL 52:407–411
De Resurrectione Christi. Aliquantulum nos tacere, fratres charissimi, et vigiliarumlabor fecit,et coegit, jejunii lassitudo; et ideo hodie reddimus de Dominica Resurrectione sermonem, in qua si divinum est quod ex Virginenascitur Christus,quantum divinius est Christus a mortuis quod resurgit? Quod ergo divinum est,humano non accipiatur auditu. Vespere, inquit, sabbati quæ lucescit in prima sabbati (Matth. XXVIII). Vespera sabbati, hoc nescit dies saeculi, hoc non habet mundi usus. Vesperfinit, anon inchoat diem; tenebrescit vesper, non lucescit; nonin auroram vertitur, quia lucis ortum ignorat.Vespera mater Doctis parturit diem; mutat ordinem, dum agnoscit auctorem; radiat de novitate mysterium, anhelat Creatori servire, non tempori. Vespere, inquit, sabbatiquæ lucescit in prima sabbati, venit Maria Magdalene et altera Maria videre sepulcrum. Sero mulier currit ad veniam, quæ mature cucurrit ad culpam. Vesperequærit Christum, quæin matutinis Adam se noverat perdidisse. Venit Maria et altera Maria videre sepulcrum. Quæ de paradiso perfidiam sumpserat, festinatb fidem sumere de sepulcro: contendit rapere de morte vitam, quæ de vita rapuerat mortem. Venit Maria. Hoc nomen matris est Christi,venit ergo mater in no- mine, venit mulier, ut fieret mater viventium, quæ facta fuerat morientium mater, ut quod scriptum est impleretur:Boc est mater omnium viventium (Gen. III). Venit Maria et altera Marta.Non dixit venerunt, sed venit; sub uno nomine venerunt duæ mysterio, non casu. Venit Maria et alteraMaria. Venitipsa sed altera, altera sed ipsa,ut mulier mutaretur vita, non nomine; virtute,non sexu;et fieret resurrectionis nuntia, quæ interountia et lapsus exstiterat et ruinæ. Venit Maria videre sepulcrum. Ut quam deceperat arboris visus,visus repararet sepulcri; et quam prostraverat illecebrosus aspectus, aspectus salutaris attolleret. Ecce, inquit, terræmotus factus est magnus, angelus enim Domini descendit de cælo. Tremuit terra, non quia angelus descendit de coelo, sed quia ab inferis a Dominator ascendit.Ecceterræmotus factus est ma- gnus. e Movetur chaos, dissiliunt ima terrarum, tremit terra,montium tremunt pondera, orbis fundamenta quatiuntur, corripitur tartarus, sistuntur inferna: addicitur mors quæin reos tendens incurrit in jndicem.dominata servis exarsit in Dominum, sæviens in homines prosilivit in Deum. Merito ergo perit lex tartari, remota sunt inferni jura, potestas mortis ablata est,et in pœnam temeritatis suscita vit mortuos cognitoris injuria deniqueredduntur corpora,redintegraturhomo,vita reparatur, et constat de venia jam totum, quia in auctorem vitæ mox est transgressa sententia. Ecce terremotusfactus est magnus. Modo terræmotus magnus: 0 si tuncvel levis turbo arborem mortiferam dejecisset I 0 si nebulæ fumus illiusmulieristenebrassetaspectum! O si tetra nubes lethalis pomi speciem caligasset! 0 si manus tangens inconcessa tremuisset! O si peccattidiem tenebrasset gnox injusta,et lamenta mundi, et in- crementa mortis,etCreatoris injuriamtunc tulisset! Sed vitiis semper serviunt blandimenta, lenocinantur dulcia delictis, virtutibus vero austera et fortia suntamica. Angelus enim Domini descendit de cœlo. Resurgente Christo, morte pereunte, terrenis redditurccelestecommercium; et mulieri cui fuerat cum diabolo lethaleconsilium, cum angelo colloquium i fit vitale. Angelusenim Domini descendit de cælo, et revolvi! lapidem. Non dixit volvit, sed revolvit lapidem, qui advolutus probavit mortem, et revolutus exstititj resurrectionis assertor.Beatus lapis qui Christum et revelare meruit et velare; beatus qui non minus corda aperitquam sepulcrum; beatusqui dat resurrectionis fidem, fideique resurrectionem,qui divinam carnem resurrexisse testatur. Mutatur hic ordo rerum; mortem, non mortuum,devorat hic sepulcrum, domus mortis mansio fit vitalis;uteri nova forma mortuum concipit,parit vivum. Angelus enim Domini descendit de cœlo, et accedensrevolvit lapidem, et sedebat super eum. Et angelo quae a causa sedendi erat, cui nulla inerat lassitudo! Sed sedebat utndei doctor, ut resurrection is magister: sedebatsuperpetram, ut soliditas sedis daret credentibus firmitatem. Ponebat angelus super petram fundamenta fidei, super quam Christus erat Ecclesiam fundaturus, qui dixit: Tu es Petrus, et super hancpetram ædificabo Ecclesiam meam (Matth.XVI, 18).Erat, inquit, aspectus ejus sicut fulgur,et vestimenta ejus sicut nix (Matth. XVI, 1,2). Ad angeli gloriam non sufficit iulgor,ad coelestem naturam quid fecit vestimentum? Sed splendore tali referebat speciem nostræ resurrectionis et formam, quia resurgentes per Christum,Christie mutantur in gloriam.Pro timore autem ejus exterriti sunt custodes,et facti sunt veluti mortui. Miseri quos tunc percutit pavor mortis,quando securitas redditur vitæ: sed fcrudelitatis ministri, perfidiæ exsecutores alienæ, fiduciam sumere quomodo poterant de supernis? Obsidebant sepulcrum, resurrectioni januas obstruebant, et ne qua posset intrare vita, mors perire, servabant: merito eos angeli i perculit et prostravit adventus. Misera, et sibi semper inimica mortalitas dolet se mori,ne resurgere possit, oppugnat:sepulcrum aperire convenerat,et ad resurgend um quidquid erat|facilitatis afferre ut esset miraculum de facto, de exemplo spes, de reverso res, credulitas de vivendo. Grandis dementia est hoc,hominem nolle credere,quod sibi desideratevenire.Hoc de his custodibus hodie dixisse sufficiat: quid autem nostra fides habeat, ne hodie longum sit, post dicemus, præstante Domino nostro Jesu Christo, qui vivit et regnat cum Patre Deus in saecula sæculorum. Amen.
[On the resurrection of Christ.] The toil of the vigils, dearest brothers, made us keep silent for a little while, and the weariness of fasting compelled it; and so today we render our sermon on the Lord's resurrection. If it is divine that Christ is born of a Virgin, how much more divine is it that Christ rises from the dead? What is divine, then, let it not be received with human hearing. “At the evening of the sabbath,” it says, “which was dawning toward the first day of the week” (Matt 28:1). An evening of the sabbath that dawns: the days of this world do not know this; the world's usage does not have it. Evening ends the day, it does not begin it; evening grows dark, it does not grow light; it does not turn into dawn, because it does not know the rising of the light. Evening, the mother of night, gives birth to the day; it changes its order when it recognizes its author; the mystery shines with newness; it longs to serve the Creator, not time. “At the evening of the sabbath which was dawning toward the first day of the week, Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb.” Late does the woman run to pardon, who ran early to guilt. In the evening she seeks Christ, she who knew that in the morning she had lost Adam. “Mary and the other Mary came to see the tomb.” She who had taken faithlessness from paradise hurries to take faith from the tomb; she strives to snatch life from death, who had snatched death from life. “Mary came.” This is the name of Christ's mother; so the mother came in name; the woman came, so that she might become the mother of the living who had become the mother of the dying, and that what is written might be fulfilled: “This is the mother of all the living” (Gen 3:20). “Mary and the other Mary came.” He did not say “they came” but “she came”: under one name two came, by a mystery, not by chance. “Mary and the other Mary came.” The same woman came, yet another; another, yet the same; so that the woman might be changed in life, not in name, in virtue, not in sex; and that she might become the messenger of the resurrection who had been the go-between of the fall and of ruin. “Mary came to see the tomb”: so that she whom the sight of the tree had deceived the sight of the tomb might restore, and she whom an enticing sight had laid low a saving sight might raise up. “Behold,” it says, “there was a great earthquake, for an angel of the Lord came down from heaven.” The earth trembled, not because an angel came down from heaven, but because the Lord ascended from the underworld. “Behold, there was a great earthquake.” Chaos is moved, the depths of the earth leap apart, the earth trembles, the weights of the mountains tremble, the foundations of the world are shaken, Tartarus is seized, the underworld is brought to a halt; death is condemned, which, reaching for the guilty, ran into the judge; having ruled over servants, it blazed out against the Lord; raging against men, it leapt upon God. Rightly, then, the law of Tartarus perishes, the rights of the underworld are removed, the power of death is taken away; and, as the penalty for its rashness, the injury done to the judge has raised the dead. At last bodies are given back, man is made whole again, life is restored, and everything now rests on pardon, because the sentence soon passed over onto the author of life. “Behold, there was a great earthquake.” Now a great earthquake! Oh, if only then even a light whirlwind had thrown down the deadly tree! Oh, if only the smoke of a cloud had darkened that woman's sight! Oh, if only a black cloud had dimmed the look of the deadly fruit! Oh, if only the hand that touched what was forbidden had trembled! Oh, if only an unseasonable night had darkened the day of sin and taken away the laments of the world, the increase of death and the injury to the Creator! But allurements always serve vices, sweet things pander to sins, while harsh and strong things are friends to virtues. “For an angel of the Lord came down from heaven.” With Christ rising and death perishing, heavenly fellowship is restored to earthly beings; and the woman who had held deadly counsel with the devil now has life-giving converse with an angel. “For an angel of the Lord came down from heaven and rolled back the stone.” He did not say “rolled” but “rolled back” the stone, which, rolled against the tomb, proved the death, and, rolled back, became the witness of the resurrection. Blessed the stone that was found worthy both to reveal and to veil Christ! Blessed, for it opens hearts no less than the tomb! Blessed, for it gives faith in the resurrection and a resurrection of faith, and testifies that the divine flesh has risen! Here the order of things is changed: here the tomb devours death, not the dead man; the house of death becomes a dwelling of life; a new kind of womb conceives a dead man and gives birth to a living one. “For an angel of the Lord came down from heaven and, approaching, rolled back the stone and sat upon it.” And what reason to sit had an angel, in whom there was no weariness? But he sat as a teacher of faith, as a master of the resurrection; he sat on the rock, so that the solidity of the seat might give firmness to believers. The angel was laying on the rock the foundations of the faith on which Christ was to found his church, who said: “You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church” (Matt 16:18). “His appearance,” it says, “was like lightning, and his clothing like snow” (Matt 28:3). For an angel's glory lightning is not enough; and what did clothing do for a heavenly nature? But by such splendour he represented the appearance and form of our resurrection, because those who rise through Christ are changed into the glory of Christ. “For fear of him the guards were terrified and became like dead men.” Wretched men, whom the fear of death strikes at the moment when the security of life is restored! But how could ministers of cruelty, executors of another's faithlessness, take confidence from heavenly things? They were besieging the tomb, blocking the doors against the resurrection, and keeping watch so that no life could enter and death could not perish: rightly the angel's coming struck and laid them low. Wretched mortality, always its own enemy, grieves to die and fights against being able to rise again. It would have been fitting to open the tomb and offer every facility for the rising, so that there might be a miracle from the deed, hope from the example, the reality from the one who returned, belief from his living. It is great madness for a man to refuse to believe what he desires to happen to himself. Let it be enough to have said this today about these guards; what our faith holds we shall say later, so that today may not run long, by the gift of our Lord Jesus Christ, who lives and reigns with the Father, God for ages of ages. Amen.
Matt 28:1–4 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 3:6 (allusion, medium confidence) · Gen 3:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 16:18 (quotation, high confidence) · Phil 3:21 (allusion, low confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: In his first sermon after the Easter vigil Chrysologus reads Matthew's account of the empty tomb: the women undo Eve's fall, the earthquake marks the defeat of death, and the angel seated on the stone teaches the resurrection.
- Migne’s reference “Matth. XVI, 1, 2” for the angel’s appearance should be Matt 28:3.
Notes on the original text
- Digital text corrected (garbled word and stray letter in the digital text (k Meique for fideique)): fidem,k Meique resurrectionem → fidem, fideique resurrectionem.
Topics: Christology, Eschatology
Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 74 (PL 52:407–411; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/74). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/74
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-74) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.
Chapter 75
75PL 52:411–413
De eadem Quantum a vobis ego, 1 metantum peregrinatus est sermo: sed orate, fratres, ut sicut me vobis Deus reddidit, ita mihi dignetur reddere et redonare sermonem. Audistis evangelistam dicentem (Matt. XXVIII): Vespera, inquit, sabbati quæ lucescit in prima sabbati. Quid hic intelligit humanus sensus? Quid hic humana sapit sapientia? Vespera quæ lucescit. Vesper finit, non inchoat diem,nec lucem parturit,sed tenebras; sedhicelementorumauctorelementorum vices mutat, ut in resurrectione Domini totum divinumsentias, nil humanum.Denique resurgente Christofidelibus lucescit vesper, dies infidelibus tenebrescit; discipulisnox mutaturi in diem, Judæis dies vertitur et mutatur in noctem. Ab hora, inquit, sexta, tenebræ factæ, unt super universam terram usque ad horam nonam (Luc. XXIII). Ut ipsa quæ tota est meridiana claritas obscuraretur, et illud quod scriptum est impleretur: Occidet illi sol meridie (Amos VIII); occidet illis, id est,Judaeis; nostris autem: Nox sicut dies il luminabitur (Ps. CXXXVIII). Quia vesper, in profundam semper caliginem vergit, totam tunc Christitetendit et erexit in lucem, ac splendore toto tota mortalium pectora ab inferis Christo resurgente complevit. Vespera sabbati.Quia illuminatur per Christum sabbatum,non deletur.Non enim verit solvere legem, sed adimplere (Mat. v). Illuminatur, ut in die dominicoluceat,clarescatin Ecclesia,quod in synagoga Judseis obscurantibus fuscabatur. Venit Maria Magdalena et altera Maria videre sepulcrum.Præcedunt apostolos ad ministerium feminse, quæ sexu viros, quae ordine discipulos sequuntur: sed non hinc faciunt apostolossegniores,quae non foeminarumformas,sed Ecclesiarum typum deferunt Dominicum ad sepulcrum: Maria, et Maria, sic altera, ut ipsa: ipsa ut altera: 0 altera ipsa Maria, Maria mater Christi: un um nomen P duas geminatur in feminas, quia hic Ecclesia ex duobus populis veniens,una figuratur ex duobus populis, id est, ex gentibus et Judæis, quia primi novissimi etnovissimi primi (Matth. xx). Venit Maria ad sepulcrum, venit ad resurrectionis uterum,venitad vitæ partum, ut iterum Christusex sepulcro nasceretur fidei, qui carnis fuerat generatus ex ventre; et eum quem clausa virginitas vitam protulerat ad præsentem,q clausum sepulcrum ad vitam redderet sempiternam. Divinitatis insigne est clausam virginem reliquisse post partum, de sepulcro clauso exisse cum corpore est divinitatis insigne. Maria et Maria venerunt,ut viderent sepulcrum; vides quia venerunt, non ut Dominum cernerent, sed sepulcrum; nec quaerebant cum mortuis jam viventem, quae Dominum jam resurrexisse credebant. Angelus enim Domini descendit de cælo, et accedensrevolvit lapidem. Revolvit lapidem, non ut egredienti Domino praeberet aditum, sed ut Dominum mundo jam resurrexisse monstraret; conservis ad credendum daret fidem, non ad resurgendum Domino praestaret auxilium. Revolvit lapidem. Revolvitur ad fidem, qui ad perfidiam fuerat advolutus. Revolvit lapidem, ut idem esset vitae titulus, qui acceperat mortis a tenere custodem.Orate, fratres, ut nunc descendat angelus, et totam duritiem nostri cordis evolvat, aperiatsensuum clausa nostrorum, resurrexisse Christum nostris etiam testetur ex mentibus, quia sicut illud cor coelum est, in quo vivit et regnat Christus, itaillud pectus sepulcrum,in quo Christus ad huc habetur mortuus et sepultus.Christi mors sicut fuisse,ita pertransisse credatur: Christushomo passus, mortuus et sepultus fuit; est, vivit, regnat, manet, permanet Deus. Audi Apostolum dicentem: Etsinovimus Christum secundum carnem,sedjam nunc non novimus (II Cor. v).Et: Quod mortuus est peccato,semel mortuus est, quod autem vivit, vivit Deo (Rom. vi); hoc est, vivit Deus. Et accedens revolvit lapidem, et sedebat super eum. Sedebat ad docendam resurrectionem, non ad lassitudinem sublevandam. Cælestis natura ignorat lassitudinem, nescit laborem: sed factus est lapis vas angelicæ sessionis, doctrinæ coelestis cathedra, schola vitae, quia Judæis ad mortis januam, ad cineris servitium, ad triste silentium fueratconstitutus. Erat, inquit, aspectus ejus sicut fulgur, vestimenta autem ejus sicut nix. Vultus claritas a vestium candore separatur,etfacies fulguri, nivi vestis angeli comparatur, quia fulgur de cælo, nix de terra. Audi prophetam dicentem: Laudate Dominum de terra, ignis, granda, nix (Psal. CXLVIIIIn facie ergo angelj ciaritas coelestis servatur naturæ; in veste verofiguratur gratia communionis humanae, et temperatur species angeli colloquentis, utcarnales oculi,etvestium ferant placidam claritatem, et ex fulgore vultus nuntiumsuitremerent,et revererentur auctoris. Prœ timore autem ejus exterriti sunt custodes. Quare ter- riti?Quiacustodiebante crudelitatis studio, non pietatis obsequio. ut, destruitur, stare non potest, quem conscientia destituit, impellit reatus. Hine est quod angelus percellit impios, pios alloquitur et solatur.f Nolite timere vos. Hoc est, giUi timeant: quaerentes non timeant, timeant persequentes. Nolite timere vos, scio enim quod Jesum qui crucifixus est quæritis, non est hic. Hoc est: Ego veni ut instruerem vos, non ut illum eximerem.qui et rerum factor est et est sui suscitator. Non est hic, surrexitenim sicut dixit. Vides quia venit angelus, ut factis assereret servus, quae Dominus prædixerat verbis; et doceret moriendi et vivendi penes illum potestatem fuisse qui ante suam mortem prædixerat resurrectionem: nam utique qui scire potuit, potuit et cavere, sed quia vincere potuit, declinare contempsit, quiaresurgentis gloria sepelivit morientis injuriam. De sequentibus, fratres, sequenti sermone tractabimus, quia protrahere nos et dilatare sermonem adhuc recens itineris prohibuit lassitudo.
[On the same.] As far as I have been away from you, so far has speech been away from me; but pray, brothers, that as God has given me back to you, so he may deign to give back and restore speech to me. You heard the evangelist say (Matt 28): “At the evening of the sabbath,” he says, “which dawns toward the first day of the week.” What does human understanding grasp here? What does human wisdom make of this? “Evening that dawns.” Evening ends the day, it does not begin it; it gives birth not to light but to darkness. But here the author of the elements changes the courses of the elements, so that in the Lord's resurrection you may perceive everything divine, nothing human. In short, as Christ rises, evening grows light for the faithful and day grows dark for the unfaithful; for the disciples night is changed into day, for the Jews day is turned and changed into night. “From the sixth hour,” it says, “darkness came over the whole earth until the ninth hour” (Luke 23:44), so that even the brightness of full noon was darkened and what is written was fulfilled: “The sun will set for him at noon” (Amos 8:9). It will set for them, that is, for the Jews; but for ours: “Night will be lit up like the day” (Ps 139:12). Evening, which always sinks into deep gloom, then stretched out and rose wholly into the light of Christ, and with all its splendour filled the hearts of all mortals as Christ rose from the underworld. “At the evening of the sabbath”: because the sabbath is illuminated through Christ, not abolished. “For he came not to abolish the law but to fulfil it” (Matt 5:17). It is lit up so that it may shine on the Lord's day, and that what was darkened in the synagogue by the Jews' obscuring of it may grow bright in the church. “Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb.” Women go before the apostles to this ministry, women who follow men in sex and the disciples in rank; but they do not thereby make the apostles seem slower, for they bring to the Lord's tomb not the forms of women but the type of the churches: Mary and Mary, another in such a way as to be the same, the same in such a way as to be another; O other Mary who is the same, Mary the mother of Christ. One name is doubled into two women, because here the church, coming from two peoples, is figured as one made of two peoples, that is, of Gentiles and Jews, because “the first will be last and the last first” (Matt 20:16). Mary came to the tomb, came to the womb of the resurrection, came to the birth of life, so that Christ, who had been begotten from the womb for the flesh, might be born again from the tomb for faith; and that the closed tomb might give back to everlasting life him whom closed virginity had brought forth into the present life. It is a mark of divinity to have left the virgin closed after giving birth; it is a mark of divinity to have come out with a body from a closed tomb. Mary and Mary came to see the tomb. You see that they came not to see the Lord but the tomb; nor were they seeking the living among the dead, for they believed that the Lord had already risen. “For an angel of the Lord came down from heaven and, approaching, rolled back the stone.” He rolled back the stone not to give the Lord a way out as he left, but to show the world that the Lord had already risen; to give his fellow servants faith to believe, not to give the Lord help to rise. “He rolled back the stone.” It is rolled back toward faith, which had been rolled against the tomb toward faithlessness. “He rolled back the stone,” so that the very stone which had received the guard who kept death might become the inscription of life. Pray, brothers, that the angel may now come down and roll away all the hardness of our heart, open the closed places of our senses, and testify from our minds too that Christ has risen; because, as the heart in which Christ lives and reigns is heaven, so the breast in which Christ is still held dead and buried is a tomb. Let it be believed that Christ's death, real as it was, has passed away: Christ as man suffered, died and was buried; as God he is, lives, reigns, remains and abides. Hear the Apostle saying: “Even if we have known Christ according to the flesh, yet now we know him so no longer” (2 Cor 5:16). And: “The death he died to sin, he died once; but the life he lives, he lives to God” (Rom 6:10); that is, he lives as God. “And approaching, he rolled back the stone and sat upon it.” He sat to teach the resurrection, not to relieve weariness. The heavenly nature knows no weariness, knows no labour; but the stone became the vessel of the angel's seat, the chair of heavenly teaching, the school of life, since for the Jews it had been set at the door of death, for the service of ashes, for sad silence. “His appearance,” it says, “was like lightning, and his clothing like snow.” The brightness of the face is distinguished from the whiteness of the clothes, and the angel's face is compared to lightning and his clothing to snow, because lightning is from heaven, snow from the earth. Hear the prophet saying: “Praise the Lord from the earth, fire, hail, snow” (Ps 148:7–8). In the angel's face, then, the brightness of the heavenly nature is kept; in his clothing the grace of fellowship with humanity is figured; and the appearance of the angel who speaks is tempered, so that fleshly eyes might bear the gentle brightness of the clothes, and from the brightness of the face might tremble at the messenger and revere the one who sent him. “For fear of him the guards were terrified.” Why terrified? Because they were guarding out of zeal for cruelty, not out of loving service. One whom conscience abandons and guilt drives on is overthrown and cannot stand. That is why the angel strikes down the wicked and speaks to and consoles the devout. “Do not be afraid, you.” That is: let those others fear; let those who seek not fear; let the persecutors fear. “Do not be afraid, you; for I know that you are seeking Jesus who was crucified; he is not here.” That is: I came to instruct you, not to bring him out, who is both the maker of things and the one who raises himself. “He is not here, for he has risen, as he said.” You see that the angel came so that the servant might confirm by deeds what the Lord had foretold in words, and teach that the power of dying and of living lay with him who before his death had foretold his resurrection; for surely he who could foreknow it could also have avoided it; but because he could conquer, he disdained to avoid it, since the glory of the one rising buried the injury of the one dying. Of what follows, brothers, we shall treat in the next sermon, because the weariness of a journey still recent has kept us from prolonging and extending the sermon.
Matt 28:1–6 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 23:44 (quotation, high confidence) · Amos 8:9 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 139:12 (138:12 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 20:16 (quotation, high confidence) · 2 Cor 5:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 6:10 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 148:7–8 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Back from a journey, Chrysologus explains the evening that dawns at the resurrection, the two Marys as a figure of the church from Jews and Gentiles, and why the angel rolled back the stone and sat on it.
- “So that the very stone which had received the guard who kept death” renders a garbled phrase (qui acceperat mortis a tenere custodem); translated by sense. The two Marys are read as one figure of the church; the contrast between Jews and believers at the darkness of Good Friday is translated as written.
Topics: Christology
Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 75 (PL 52:411–413; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/75). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/75
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-75) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.
Chapter 76
76PL 52:413–417
De eadem,dequesecunda CChristi manifestatione facta mulieribus a monumento regredientibus. Superiori sermone Mariam et alteram Mariam Eaclesiæ ex duobus populis venientis figuram diximus habuisse: hoc exsequentibushodie cupimus approbare, si modo nobis vester benignus praebeaturauditus. Respondens, inquit, angelus dixit: Nolite timere vos,scio enim quia Jesum qui crucifixus est, quæritis: non est hic,surrexit eniin sicut dixit. Venite,videte lo- cum ubi positus erat Dominus (Matth. XXVIII). Angelus praedicat nomen, crucem dicit, loquitur passionem, fatetur mortem, sed resurrectionemmox,j mox Dominum confitetur.Et siangeluspost tanta supplicia, post sepulcrum agnoscit Dominum, suam loquitur servitutem,et injuriam passionis totam transisse sentit resurrectionis in gloriam; cur homo aut minoratum Deum in carne judicat, aut in passione existimat ejus defecisse virtutem, autconsumptam dominationem credit servitute? 1 Digne itaque dicit crucifixum, ostendit locum ubi positus erat Dominus, ne alter et non ipse idem resurrexisse crederetur ex mortuis.Etsi Dominuseadem redit in carne,vulnera reportat,ipsaclavorum foraminaresumit,etipsa facit testimonia sui corporis, suæ resurrectionis indi- cia, quae suae fuerant contumelia passionis; quare homo se in alia putat, aut in sua non putat carne redituru,aut carnem servus forte dedignatur suam, oum nostram Dominus non mutarit? Acquiesce homo ipsum te futurum esse in carne tua, ne tu ipse non lis, si in carne surrexeris aliena.Adjecitangelus, dicens Et cito euntes dicite discipulis, quia resurrexit, et præcedet vos in Galilæam, ibi eum videbitis. Angelus hic non feminas, sed Ecclesiam duabus in feminis mittit, a unam mittit, ut eam mittendo sic longe lateque diffundat. Angelushic sponsam mittitad spon- Bum; denique eun tibus illis occurrit Dominus, et salutat eas,dicens: A vete. Occurrit, et non potestate terret, sed praevenit charitatis ardore; non auctori.. tate turbat, sed salutat lege sponsi; non dominantis jure onerat, sed honoratdilectioneconsortis: salutat: Avete. Dixerat discipulis suis ipse: Neminemsa- lutaveritis in via,et quid estquodhicin via tam festivus salutator occurrit? Non exspectat cognosci, intelligi non requirit, non ut interrogetur admittit, sed in salutationem vadit totus, vadit fervens, et suum solvitipse salutatione mandatum? Fecit, fecit, quia totum vincit, et exsuperat vis amoris: simul, quia Christus in Ecclesia se salutat,quam suam fecit esse, et sic viscera sua, suum sic recepit in corpus, dicenteApostolo: At ipse est caput corporisEcclesiae (Colos. I). In istis vero feminis Ecclesiæ figuram mapere plenam res ipsa ostenditevidenter, quia discipulos suos Christus de resurrectione nutantes arguit, trepidantes firmat, ostensionelateris, clavorum cavernis, sumptione cibi, vix revocat ad fidem (Luc. XXIV). Unde et merito in fide parvulos sic pueros appellat, dicendo: Pueri,numquid habetis pulmentarium (Joan. xxi)? ipsamque alibi Mariam flentem quasi ae mortuo, mulierem vocat,atquetangendi se licentiam negat (Joan. xx): istas autem sic perfectas invenit, sic credentes, sicnon de sexu trepidantes, sic mysterio currentes, sic Dominum toto fidei ardore requirentes, ut habendum se tradat eis salutatione tali, dicens, A vete. Angelus dixerat: Scio enim quia Jesum crucifixum quæritis; et requirentibus Christus, avete respondit; alibi autem Mariae e nec tangendi datur facultas (Joan. xx), hic non solum tangendi, sed et tenendi copiatotaconceditur. Illæautem, inquit,accelserunt, et tenuerunt pedes ejus. Istae tenent pedes Christi, quae in Ecclesia typum evangelicaB praedicationis tenent, et merentur ex cursu: ac sic fide tangunt sui vestigia salvatoris, ut ad totius dei- tatis pertingant gloriam, perveniant ad honorem. Illa autem merito audit: Noli me tangere (Ibid.), quæ in terris defiet Dominum, et sic in sepulcro quaerit mortuum, ut eum in cœlis nesciat regnare cum Patre. Noli me tangere, id est, obsequi tactu carnis, quem fidei tactu deberes attingere; necquasi bomi. nem tantum tangere te præsumas in terra, quem Deum nondum sapis in coelestibus adorare; feminea cura desinat, muliebris sollicitudo desistat, virilis credulitas tuam conscendat in mentem, ascensum meum cordis tui capiat latitudo, ut in coelestibus æterna tactus mei beatitudine perfruaris. Juxtaillud prophetas:Beatus vir cujus est auxilium abs te, Domine; ascensus in corde ejus disposuit. (Psal. LXXXIII). In terra non tangit Christum, qui fide in cœlo non conscendit ad Christum. Quod ergo eadem Maria nunc in Mei vertice constituta, nunc in Ecclesiae sublimatafastigio, et tangit Christum, et tenet toto sanctitatis affectu, nuncimbecillitatecarniset femineainfirmitate dejecta dubitat, et tactum sui non mereturauctoris, non facit quaestionem: si quidem illud de figura est, hoc de sexu; illud est de divina gratia, hoc de humananatura. Quia nos idem ipsi cum divina scimus, Dei munus est; cum humana sapimus, cæcamur ex nobis. i Sic beatus Petrus Christum, dum Dei Filium confitetur. Patre revelante, cognoscit; cum negat Christum,carnis sentit et patitur caecitatem (Mat. xx vi). InterhaecJudæi crimina,aut male emuntsua, autdistrahuntpejus aliena, dum peccata taxant pretio. dum pecunia pensant et compensant delicta, dum in sceleribus suis fundunt,quod toto scelere congregaverunt. Sic Judam comparant traditorem Domini sui,et pretio Redemptoris mundi sanguinem pensant; sic aperti sepulchri fidem claudunt sacculo, ut negandæ resurrectionis crimen nummis criminum mercarentur. Pecuniam, inquit. copiosam dederunt militibus, die centes: Dicite quia discipuli ejus venerunt nocte, et furatisunt eum, nobis dormientibus, et si hoc præses audierit, nos suadebinus ei, et securos Vos faciemus. At illi accepta pecunia fecerunt sicut erant edocli; et diffamatum est verbum ist ud apud Judæos usque in hodiernumdiem.Apud Judaeos, numquid apud Christianos? Judaee, quod tuin Judaea obscurabas auro, fide toto claruit eteluxitin mundo: discipuli receperunt,non furati sunt Christum; tu perfidiam comparasti, sed non furatus es veritatem; Judaee, resurrexit Chri- stus,tu pecuniam perdidisti. Sanguis ejus super nos et super filios nostros. Judæe, Christus vivit, tu et te et tuos posteros occidisti.
[On the same, and on Christ's second appearance, made to the women returning from the tomb.] In the previous sermon we said that Mary and the other Mary bore the figure of the church coming from two peoples; today we wish to prove this from what follows, if only you will lend us a kindly hearing. “The angel answered,” it says, “and said: Do not be afraid, you; for I know that you are seeking Jesus who was crucified; he is not here, for he has risen, as he said. Come, see the place where the Lord was laid” (Matt 28:5–6). The angel proclaims the name, speaks of the cross, tells of the passion, confesses the death, but at once, at once confesses the resurrection and the Lord. And if an angel, after such great sufferings, after the tomb, recognizes the Lord, speaks of his own servitude, and perceives that the whole injury of the passion has passed into the glory of the resurrection, why does man either judge God to have been diminished in the flesh, or think that his power failed in the passion, or believe that his lordship was consumed by servitude? Fittingly, then, he says “crucified” and shows the place where the Lord was laid, lest it be believed that another, and not the same one, had risen from the dead. And if the Lord returns in the same flesh, brings back his wounds, takes up again the very holes of the nails, and makes the very insults of his passion into testimonies of his body and signs of his resurrection, why does man think that he will return in another flesh, or not in his own? Or does the servant perhaps disdain his own flesh, when the Lord did not change ours? Accept, O man, that you will be yourself in your own flesh, lest you should not be yourself if you rise in another's flesh. The angel added, saying: “And go quickly and tell his disciples that he has risen, and he goes before you into Galilee; there you will see him.” Here the angel sends not women but the church in two women; he sends one, so that by sending her he may spread her far and wide. Here the angel sends the bride to the bridegroom; and then, as they go, the Lord meets them and greets them, saying: “Hail.” He meets them, and does not terrify them with power but anticipates them with the ardour of charity; he does not disturb them with authority but greets them by the law of the bridegroom; he does not burden them with a master's right but honours them with the love of a spouse. He greets them: “Hail.” He himself had said to his disciples: “Greet no one on the road” (Luke 10:4); why then does he come running on the road as so festive a greeter? He does not wait to be recognized, does not seek to be understood, does not allow himself to be questioned, but goes wholly into greeting, goes fervently, and by a greeting himself releases his own command? He did it, he did it, because the force of love conquers and overcomes everything; and also because in the church Christ greets himself, for he has made her his own and has thus received her as his own heart, his own body, as the Apostle says: “He is the head of the body, the church” (Col 1:18). The matter itself shows clearly that in these women the full figure of the church begins, since Christ rebukes his disciples when they waver about the resurrection, strengthens them when they tremble, and scarcely calls them back to faith by showing his side and the holes of the nails and by taking food (Luke 24). So he rightly calls them children, little ones in faith, saying: “Children, have you any fish?” (John 21:5); and elsewhere he calls Mary herself, weeping as for a dead man, “woman,” and denies her leave to touch him (John 20). But these women he finds so perfect, so believing, so untroubled because of their sex, so running for the mystery, so seeking the Lord with the whole ardour of faith, that he gives himself to them to be held with such a greeting, saying, “Hail.” The angel had said, “For I know that you are seeking Jesus who was crucified,” and to those who sought him Christ answered, “Hail.” Elsewhere Mary is not even given leave to touch (John 20:17); here not only touching but full freedom to hold him is granted. “And they,” it says, “came up and took hold of his feet.” They hold Christ's feet who in the church hold the type of the gospel preaching and earn it by running; and so by faith they touch the footsteps of their Saviour that they reach the glory and come to the honour of the whole Godhead. But that woman rightly hears, “Do not touch me” (John 20:17), who weeps for the Lord on earth and seeks him dead in the tomb in such a way that she does not know that he reigns in heaven with the Father. “Do not touch me”: that is, do not serve with the touch of the flesh him whom you ought to reach with the touch of faith; do not presume to touch on earth as merely a man him whom you do not yet know how to adore as God in heaven. Let a woman's care cease, let a woman's anxiety stop; let a man's belief climb into your mind; let the breadth of your heart take in my ascension, so that in heaven you may enjoy the eternal blessedness of touching me, according to the prophet's word: “Blessed is the man whose help is from you, Lord; he has set ascents in his heart” (Ps 84:5). He does not touch Christ on earth who does not climb up to Christ in heaven by faith. That the same Mary, now placed on the summit of faith and exalted on the height of the church, touches Christ and holds him with all the affection of holiness, and now, cast down by the weakness of the flesh and the frailty of a woman, doubts and does not merit the touch of her maker, raises no difficulty: the one belongs to the figure, the other to the sex; the one is of divine grace, the other of human nature. For when we know divine things, it is God's gift; when we savour human things, we are blinded by ourselves. So blessed Peter, when he confesses Christ as the Son of God, knows him by the Father's revelation; when he denies Christ, he feels and suffers the blindness of the flesh (Matt 26). Meanwhile the Jews either buy their own crimes badly or sell others' worse, putting a price on sins, weighing and paying off offences with money, and pouring out in their crimes what they gathered with every crime. So they buy Judas, the betrayer of his Lord, and weigh out at a price the blood of the world's Redeemer; so they shut up in a purse the evidence of the opened tomb, to purchase with the money of crimes the crime of denying the resurrection. “They gave,” it says, “a large sum of money to the soldiers, saying: Say that his disciples came by night and stole him while we were asleep; and if the governor hears of this, we will persuade him and keep you safe. And they took the money and did as they had been taught; and this story has been spread among the Jews to this day.” Among the Jews; surely not among the Christians? Jew, what you obscured with gold in Judea has shone and gleamed with faith in the whole world: the disciples received Christ, they did not steal him; you bought faithlessness, but you did not steal the truth. Jew, Christ has risen; you have lost your money. “His blood be on us and on our children” (Matt 27:25). Jew, Christ lives; you have killed both yourself and your descendants.
Matt 28:5–10 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 24:39–43 (allusion, high confidence) · John 20:27 (allusion, medium confidence) · Luke 10:4 (quotation, high confidence) · Col 1:18 (quotation, high confidence) · John 21:5 (quotation, high confidence) · John 20:15–17 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 84:5 (83:6 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 16:16–17 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 26:69–75 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 26:14–15 (allusion, high confidence) · Matt 28:12–15 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 27:25 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Chrysologus reads the two Marys as the church, argues from Christ's wounds that we will rise in our own flesh, reconciles Christ's greeting to the women with “Do not touch me,” and denounces the bribing of the guards.
- Chrysologus reconciles Matt 28:9 (the women hold Christ's feet) with John 20:17 (“Do not touch me”) by taking the first as a figure of the church and the second as Mary's human weakness. The closing apostrophe to “the Jew” is polemical; translated as written.
- Christ’s greeting Avete (“Hail”) is taken as an offer to be held, playing on habete (“have”).
Topics: Christology, Eschatology
Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 76 (PL 52:413–417; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/76). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/76
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-76) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.