Sermons 64–67

Latin text: Migne, PL 52 (Latin text: Migne, Patrologia Latina, digitized by Open Greek and Latin (patrologia_latina-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 64

64PL 52:379–381

De eodem. Singula scripturæ verba si libris singulis mandarentur,nec sic mysteria quæ in ipsis sunt audientibus perlucerent, et quid faciet subitus et brevisser- mo,qui in modum fulguris, priusquam illustret oculos, jam refugit.nec dat lucem videntibus, sed pavorem? Orate ergo, uti quia in sæculi obscuritate versamur, et in carne positi noctis tempus agimus, non diei,lucernam nobis verbi sui Christus accendat, qua prævia mysteriicoelestis ingrediamur obscura, et gradu lento perveniamus ad scientiae divinæ quantam possumus charitatem: sicutilli magi,quimentis suae oculos metientes, non audent splendori solis, aut divinae se committere claritati, sed nocte tenerum stellaelumen tenerioribusoculis assumentes,ad cubile Christi tenerrimum pervenerunt (Joan. XI). Sed jam, sicut promisimus, evangelicæ lectionis quod superest, exsequamur. Martha, inquit, ut audivit quia Jesus venit, occurrit illi. Sic servus non fuit, non proximus,non amicus, certe qui aderatconsolator, ut mulier sola medias per turbas, per castrum totum extra civitatemet luctus tempore, venienti occurreret salvatori? Fratres, in his personis non causæ currunt, sed sacramenta signantur. Mulier currit pro morte,queecucurritad mortem; festinat ad veniam, quæ festinavit ad oulpam; ad redemptorem pium pervenit,seductor pessimus quam praevenit; resurrectionem quærit, quæ quaesivit ruinam; et ipsa quæ mortem viro attulit, ut vitam viro referat, hæc anhelat. Hinc est quod in loco Christus resti tit, exspectavit Christus,quod non intravit turbas,quod non contendit ad dom um,quod non ad sepulcrum divertit, quod non ad Lazarum propter quem venerat, festinavit; sed mulierem sustinet,mulierem remora' tur, mulierem primam suscepit,quam primam suasor infecit; a muliere perfidiam fugat,ad mulierem revocat fidem, ut quae fuit perditionis obsequium, salutis eadem sit ministra; et sit tandem per Deum viventium mater,quae per diabolum diu mater exstitit mortuorum.Et quia mulier fuerat mali caput, causam mortis agit,ut ante crimen diluat quam veniam largiatur,ante causam tollatquam sententiam solvat: et cavet ne vir mulierem, per quam semel deceptus est,participem refugeret ad vitam; ac ne multisc periisset mulier, si ante ad virum Christus Dominus pervenisset. Hinc est, fratres, quod per mulierem nascitur Christus; hinc est quod virum mulier semper ventris sui suscitat de sepulcro, ut doloribus revocet, quem depulit blandimentis, ut flendo reparet quem perdidit manducando. Denique ubi Martha confessa est Christo, et quidquid e fuit culpæ in persona mulieris pia confessione delevit, mittitur ad Mariam,quia sine Maria nec fugari mors poterat,nec vita poterat reparari. Veniat Maria, veniat materni nominis bajula, ut videathomo Christum virginalis uteri habitasse secretum, quatenus prodeant ab inferis mortui, mortui exeant de sepulcris Jesus, inquit, videns Mariam plorantem et Judœos qut cumea venerant plorantes, fremvit spiritu et turbavit selpsum, et dixit: Ubi posuistis illum? Responderunt Domine, veni et vide; et lacrymatus est Jesus. Plorat Maria, plorant Judæi, plorat et Christus; putasne simili compassione? Esto quod Maria soror fleret, quia nec fratrem retinere potuit, nec morti potuit obviare: quae licet esset de resurrectione secura, destitutione tamen solatii praesentis, mora absentiæ tam longæ, tristitia diutinae separationis non potuit nondeflere; simul quiag tam trux,tam funesta.tam crudelisimago mortis, quam vis fidelem mentem non potuit non tangere, non movere. Flebant Judæi et conditionis suæ memores,et futurae vitæ des peratione possessi. Mors cum satis viventibus sit amara, satis turbat ipso exitu-plus conturbatexemplo:mortuum quotiens quis viderit, totiens se morti ej ulat destinatum, Sic de morte non potest non dolere mortalis. Quid horum Christus? et sinihil horum, quareflebat? certe ipse qui dixerat,Lazarus mortuus est, et gaudeo, de quo gaudet mortuo, ipsum cum resuscitat tunc lamentatur; qui cum amittit non flet, cum recipit tunc deplorat; tunc fundit mortales lacrymas, vitæ spiritum cum refundit. Fratres, habet hoc natura corporis humani, ut producat lacrymas vis gaudii, vis mœroris. Quotiens einm viscera, autlae. titiæ, aut tristitiæ nimio arctantur impulsu, oculi in lacrymas mox erumpunt. Hinc est quod Christus nondoloresmortis, a sedillius lætitiæ recordationelacrymavit, qui voce sua, voce una, omnes est mortuos perpetuam suscitaturus ad vitam.Fremit spiritu,et tota se viscerum commotione conturbat, quia adhuc solum Lazarum, et nonjam omnes mortuos suscitabat. Quis ergo ex humana infirmitate existimet hic flevisse Christum,cum cœlestis pater luxuriosum filium non quandiu at, sed quando recipit tunc deplorat (Luc. xv)? Christus recipiens flevit Lazarum, non amittens, denique non quando plorantes videt, tunc plorat Christus; sed quando interrogat, et in respondentibus videt fidci nil manere. dixerat: Ubi posuistis eum? At illi responderunt, Domine, veni et vide. Putaverunt eum nescire ubi positus esset in terra, qui sciebat ubi illum tartara dira retinerent.Ille sic interrogans exigebat fidem, scientiam porrigebat utastantes scirentquod mors,quod sepulcrum,quod corruptio, quod putredo;quod fetor non ex conditione Dei, sed ex delicto hominis hominibus accessisset. Nam cum dicit, Ubi posuistis eum, mulieres increpat, mulieres arguit, hoc est: Quem ego posui in paradiso, in regione vitae, ecce vos ubi posuistis eum. Sed et Judæi ad ignorantiam requirentis respondebant.Domine,veni et vide. Quid? illum jubere morti? quid? ubere illum inferis erederent,qui credebant eum quod erat in oculis non videre, qui de lacrymis ejus taliter disputabant? Qui potuit aperire cæci oculos quomodo facere non potuit, ut hic non moreretur 9 Potuit facere ut non moreretur, sed mori permisit is qui mortuum ad suam gloriam voluit suscitare: permisit ad inferna descendere, ut appare- ret Deus ab inferis hominem cum reducit. Sed, Judaei, apparent corda vestra obstructiora inferis, viscera vestra duriora mortuis, oculi vestri tetriores sepulcris, cum vox quae patefecit tartara vestra non patefecit arcana, cum jussio quæ exsuscitat mortuum mentes vestras non suscitat, cum lex quae illustrat sepulcrum vestram non illuminet caecitatem. Sed ista sufficiant, ut cum Christo resurgentis Lazari gloriam patentius videre possimus. a

[On the same.] If single words of Scripture were committed to single books, not even so would the mysteries in them shine clear to the hearers; and what will a sudden and brief sermon do, which like lightning flees before it lights up the eyes, and gives those who see it not light but fright? So pray that, since we live in the darkness of the world and, placed in the flesh, spend the time of night and not of day, Christ may light for us the lamp of his word, so that with it going before us we may enter the dark places of the heavenly mystery and with slow step come to as much brightness of divine knowledge as we can; like those magi who, measuring the eyes of their mind, did not dare to entrust themselves to the splendour of the sun or the divine brightness, but by night took up the tender light of a star with tender eyes and came to the most tender cradle of Christ (Matt 2). But now, as we promised, let us go through what remains of the Gospel reading. “Martha,” it says, “when she heard that Jesus had come, ran to meet him.” Was there no servant, no neighbour, no friend, certainly some comforter present, that a woman alone should run to meet the coming Saviour through the midst of the crowds, through the whole village, outside the town, and in a time of mourning? Brothers, in these persons it is not mere events that run their course; mysteries are signified. The woman runs for death who ran to death; she hurries to pardon who hurried to guilt; she reaches the loving Redeemer, whom the wicked seducer had reached first; she seeks resurrection who sought ruin; and she who brought death to the man pants to bring life back to the man. That is why Christ stopped in the place, why Christ waited, why he did not enter the crowds, did not make for the house, did not turn aside to the tomb, did not hurry to Lazarus, for whose sake he had come; but he waits for the woman, lingers for the woman, receives the woman first, whom the tempter first infected; he drives faithlessness from the woman and calls faith back to the woman, so that she who was the servant of perdition may be the minister of salvation, and through God may at last be the mother of the living, who through the devil was long the mother of the dead. And since the woman had been the head of evil, he deals with the cause of death, so as to wash away the crime before granting pardon, to remove the cause before annulling the sentence; and he takes care that the man should not reject as partner in life the woman through whom he had once been deceived. In short, the woman would have perished if Christ the Lord had come to the man first. That is why, brothers, Christ is born through a woman; that is why a woman always raises the man from the tomb of her womb, to call back by pains the one she drove away by enticements, to restore by weeping the one she lost by eating. Then, when Martha had confessed Christ and by her loving confession had blotted out whatever guilt lay in the person of the woman, she is sent to Mary, because without Mary death could not be put to flight nor life restored. Let Mary come, let the bearer of the mother's name come, so that man may see that Christ dwelt in the secret of a virgin's womb, so that the dead may come forth from the underworld and the dead go out from their tombs. “Jesus,” it says, “seeing Mary weeping and the Jews who had come with her weeping, groaned in spirit and troubled himself, and said: ‘Where have you laid him?’ They answered: ‘Lord, come and see.’ And Jesus wept.” Mary weeps, the Jews weep, Christ too weeps; do you think it is with a like compassion? Granted that Mary, the sister, wept because she could neither keep her brother nor ward off death: although she was secure about the resurrection, still, at the loss of present comfort, the delay of so long an absence, the sadness of a long separation, she could not but weep; and also because so grim, so deadly, so cruel an image of death could not fail to touch and move even a faithful mind. The Jews wept, both mindful of their own condition and gripped by despair of the future life. Death, bitter enough to the living, disturbs enough by its very departure, but disturbs more by its example: as often as anyone sees a dead man, so often does he wail that he himself is destined for death. So a mortal cannot help grieving over death. Which of these was Christ's case? And if none of these, why did he weep? Certainly he who had said, “Lazarus is dead, and I am glad,” laments over the one whose death made him glad, at the moment he raises him; he who does not weep when he loses him laments when he gets him back; he pours out mortal tears when he pours back the spirit of life. Brothers, the nature of the human body has this property, that the force of joy, like the force of grief, produces tears. Whenever the heart is gripped by an excessive impulse of either joy or sadness, the eyes at once burst into tears. That is why Christ wept, not for the pains of death, but at the recollection of the joy of that day when by his voice, by one voice, he will raise all the dead to everlasting life. He groans in spirit and troubles himself with a whole commotion of heart, because he was still raising Lazarus alone and not yet all the dead. Who then would think that Christ wept here from human weakness, when the heavenly father laments the extravagant son not while he loses him but when he receives him back (Luke 15)? Christ wept for Lazarus on receiving him, not on losing him. Indeed, Christ weeps not when he sees them weeping, but when he asks a question and sees that in those who answer no faith remains. He had said: “Where have you laid him?” And they answered: “Lord, come and see.” They thought that he did not know where he had been laid in the earth, who knew where dread Tartarus held him. By asking in this way he was demanding faith and offering knowledge, so that the bystanders might know that death, the tomb, corruption, decay and stench had come to human beings not from God's ordinance but from man's sin. For when he says, “Where have you laid him?” he rebukes the women, he reproves the women; that is: The one I placed in paradise, in the region of life, see where you have laid him. But the Jews too answered as though the questioner were ignorant: “Lord, come and see.” What? Would they believe that he could command death, could command the underworld, they who believed he did not see what was before his eyes, who argued in this way about his tears? “Could not he who opened the eyes of the blind man have caused this man not to die?” He could have caused him not to die; but he who wished to raise the dead man for his own glory allowed him to die; he allowed him to go down to the underworld, so that he might be seen to be God when he brings a man back from the underworld. But, Jews, your hearts appear more firmly shut than the underworld, your inner parts harder than the dead, your eyes darker than tombs, since the voice that opened Tartarus did not open your hidden places, the command that raises the dead does not raise your minds, the law that lights up the tomb does not illumine your blindness. But let this suffice, so that with Christ we may see more plainly the glory of Lazarus rising.

Matt 2:9–11 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 11:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 3:6 (allusion, medium confidence) · Gen 3:20 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 11:33–35 (quotation, high confidence) · John 11:14–15 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 15:20 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 11:37 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Chrysologus explains why Martha, standing for Eve, meets Christ first, and why Christ wept at Lazarus's tomb: not from grief but from joy at the coming resurrection of all.

  • “Brightness” renders charitatem, probably for claritatem. Migne's reference “Joan. XI” at the magi is misplaced; the allusion is to Matt 2:9–11. The rebuke of “the Jews” at the end refers to the hostile bystanders of John 11:37; translated as written.

Topics: Christology, Eschatology

Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 64 (PL 52:379–381; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/64). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-64) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 65

65PL 52:381–385

De eodem. Quoniam mortem Lazari, Mariæ fletus, lacrymas Marthæ, J udæorura planctus jam perstrinximus sermone geminato,nunc exoneremus animos,abj iciamus curas, exoccupemus sensus, ut resurrectionis tantae gaudio totismentibus et capere et audire possimus. Evangelista venisse ad monumentum sic praedicat Salvatorem. Jesus, inquit, rursus fremensin semetipso, venit ad monumentum: erat autem spelunca et lapissuperposituseratei. Jesus fremens venit ad monumentum. Fremit Christus, ut caro reviviscat; fremit vita, ut mors fugetur; fremit Deus, ut resurgat homo;; fremit indulgentia, ne senteutia contradicat; fremit Christus debellans mortem, quia non potest non fremere,qui singularem rapitde hoste victoriam.Quod autemdixit, Rursus fremens, fremitrursum,utgeminata resurrectionis demonstret insignia: quia voce Christi sicut mortui corpore de sepulcris suscitantur ad vitam,perfidia mortui ad vitam fidei sic resurgunt. Erat,inquit, spelunca. Dixisse suffecerat venisse ad monumentum; quid est quod tantopere speluncam Evangelista commemorat? Spelunca plane, ubi hominem diaboli latrocinium collocavit; spelunca. ubi virum fraus condidit mulieris; spelunca, ubi Dei plasma mortis rapacitas includebat. Et lapis superpositus erat ei. Durae mortis janua durior i durissimo lapide claudebatur: sed plorans quid proficit ad sepulcrum, quando sic duros et congestosj obices non penetrat vox plorantis? Christiani, ploremus Deo pro peccatis nostris, et, mortuis non audientibus,cum gentibus non ploremus. Ait Jesus,tollitelapidem. Inter divinas virtutes humanum Christus requirit auxilium? non sufficit amovere lapidem, qui mortem sufficit effugare? sepulcri claustra reserare non valet, qui portas tartari prævalet aperire? Dixerat per prophetam: Auferam cor lapideum de carne eorum, et dabo eis cor carneum (Ezech. XI); praecipit ergo ut Judæi ex se cor lapideum tollant,evol vant perfidiae saxum, silicem duræ incredulitatis excludant,quatenus animae per infidelitatem mortuae de sepulcro pectoris prosilirent: et non tantum surrexisse Lazarum,quantom se Lazaro consurrexisse gauderent. Tollite lapidem. Tollite miseræ humanitatis obsequium,utdivinitatisbeataed opera nunc clarescant. Tollite lapidem Quem posuistis vos, ut hominem quem ego posui, nuncreponam. Respondit Martha:Jam fetet.Mulier, et quod fetet cujus est? Jam fetet. Modo ad te pertinet, quod a te venit:: ad sepulcrum non sentires fetorem,si in paradiso suasorem noluisses audire. Jam fetet. Quod perditori fetet non fetet Creatori. Jam fetet.Quod horretalieni operiseversor,amator sui operis non abhorret. Sed dicendo sic, testaris mortem, quam tu, mulier, intulisti; fetorem clamas, ut plena mors audientibus innotescat, quatenus quod resurget Lazarus, redeuntis sit spiritus, non latentis. Divinae virtutis sit, non sit artis humanae; neque Judsei, qui non dicunt in principe dæmoniorum ejicere dæmones (Matth. IX) iterum dicant nos non imperio Dei, sed humano praesidio mortuos suscitare. Jam fet et, quatriduanus est. Dicet et tempus, ut sciant quia auctor est temporum,cui tempora nulla praescribunt. Jam fetet, quatriduanus est. Dicendo sic, e exaggerat desperationem, ut qui adsunt videant quia Deus est, qui sic vitam mortuisdesperatissalutem, fetentibusdatvigorem. Elevatis, inquit, oculis sursum. Elevat oculos sursum, ut nobis formam supplicandi tribuat, non sibi viam praeparetimpetrandi: namque sursum re- spicit,quisemper est sursum cum Patre, semperPater in ipso est, el ipse est semper in Patre: Ego, inquit, in Patre, et Pater in me est, (Joan. XIV); Pater, inquit, gratias tibiago,quia audisti me. De praestito agit gratias; et quod Pater audierit, hoc dicitur; quod Filius petierit, hoc tacetur. Fratres, inter Patrem et Filium audiendi estaffectio, non est necessitas supplicandi;charitas assensus est,non est austeritas jussionis; ibi amore gerunturomnia, ubi non indigetur obsequio, sicut ex sequentibus elucescit. Pater,gratias ago tibi, quia audisti me: ego autem sciebam quia semper me audis. Vocat in vocandi cura, ubi fiducia certa est audiendi. Aut quid ibi facit petendi labor, ubi praestandi est causa communis? Nemo ergo sic H'ilium minoret precibus,ne Patrem circa salutem ho- minum sicmmoret. Quare autem sic loquatur Filius, ipse aperit,sic dicendo: Pater, gratias ago tibi quia audislime: ego autem sciebam quia semper me audis; sed propter populum dixi, ui circumstat. Videtis quia loquendo talia suum Patrisque affectum tollit, prodit, panditgratiam,' loquitur unitatem.Dixerat: Omnia quæ habet Pater,mea sunt (Joan.XVI); et si sua sunt omnia,quomodo petit? Qui de suo petit, quod petit, non necessitatis est, sed amoris. Pater, gratias ago tibt quia audisti me: ego autem sciebam quia semperme audis; sed propter populum dixi, qui circumstat, ut credant quia tu me misisti. Missum se dixit, ut populi sciant de coelo venisse Christum, non recessisse de coelo.Sicergomittitur, sic etquod habetaccipit,quomodojunde venerat non recessit; sic ergo et Filius quod habetaccipit,et Pater quod dederit non amittit. Fratres, et quod auditur, et quod mittitur, et quod venit,et quod accipit,et quod nascitur,et quod patitur,et quod moritur, et quod resurgit, non est hoc divinitatis suæ, infirmitatis hoc nostræ est, nostræ est hoc naturæ: quod totum causa nostri tulit in nostro corpore, non propter se in sua pertulit majestate. Sed ad proposita redeamus.Quid cst quod dicit, Pa ter, gratias ago tibi, quia audisti me Quid est? Ubi Christus coepit inferi pulsare fores, portas tartari submovere, januas aperire mortis, gehennæ solvere legem vetustam deturbare antiquissimum us poenarum,reposcere Lazarianimam, ab inferis viam reditus innovare, occurit ei tartari totafurens potestas, præferens edictum superni principis, excelsi regis portans decretum, gestans latam tot saeculis Deo loquente sententiam;et videns hominem sciscitabatur quis iste esset, quid auderet, quid sibi vellet,cur so- Ius. aut sine tremore tremendos mortis lacessat et incessat accessus. Cui dicenti quis esset, responderunt prophetica voce,ministri resurrectionis, angeli. Ipse est rex gloriæ, ipse est fortis et potens in prælio (Ps. XXIII). Sed refert tartarus: Ego regem gloriæ in coe- lestibus scio omnibus potestatibus cœlicis præsidere, cujus nutum tota sufferre non potest creatura;hunc autem video de terrenis unum,concretum limo,corpore mortali septum, et in ipso habitu hominis,hominibus viliorem, et ad summam cito dandum sepulcro,subdendum meæ protinus esse ditioni.Sed persistentibus angelis et repetentibus: Ipse est Dominus virtutum, ipse est rex gloriæ;ipse coeli praesul,ipse creator mundi,ipse salvatorsoeculi,ipse redemptor omnium,et de qua furis tu,lator ipse sententiae,ipse tuum calcaturus caput,ipse tuum contriturus imperium,ipse te suo judicio perditurus,qui reos jussus capere, attrahis innocentes, sanctos diripis,ipsi Dei Filio comminaris.Redde ergo unum,priusquam multos cogaris exsolvere. Sed tartarus adhuc ista non credens, per consuetos nuntios recurrit ad cœlum, hæc invidiosa interpellatione deploratus: Ego,Domine,et si extremus creaturæ tuae,et si tristi servitio mancipatus praecepta tua in violabili lege servo, pervigilo, ne quis sententiæ tuae vetustum jus, novus temerator immutet, sed apparuit homo, qui dicitur Christus, tuumse Filium jactans,sacerdotes tuos notat,scribas tuos arguit,sabbatatuaviolat, legem tuam solvit,et animas exemptas carne,et poenae jam meaeque custodiae deputatas, ad corpora, in quibus scelerate vixerant,redire compellit;et tantis quolidie procedit ausibus, ut Lazarum jam carcere nostro clausum,jam lege nostra vinctum, jam jure nostro manentem,effractis claustris inferi conetur eruere: autcito subveni, aut si patefeceritsemel januas,omnes, quos tot saeculis servavimus, nunc amittis. Ad hæc Filius de sinu Patris respondit: Paterjustum est utcarcer non innocentes teneat, sed nocentes;poena nonjustoscruciet,sed injustos. Quamdiu sub uniushominis culpa, propter Adae solius noxam, patriarcbas,prophetas, martyres, confessores, virgines, viduas, in castitate conjugii permanentes, omnes ætates, utrumque sexum, certe parvulos nescientes bonum vel malum,hic carnifex ad se trahere crudeli infestatione non cessat? Pater, egomoriar,ut non moriantur omnes: Pater, ego Adæ debitum solvam,ut per me tibi vivant qui perAdammoriunturinferno; Pater, propter senlentiam tuam ego meum sanguinem fundam, tantum est utad te tuaredeatcreatura,pretium chari tibi sanguinis mei redemptio sit omnium mortuorum.Ad haec totius Trinitatis consensus, et Lazarum præcepit exire et tartarus ad reddendos omnes mortuos Christo ussus estobedire: hinc est quod Filius clamat: Pater, gratias tibi ago, quia audisti me (Joan.XI,4-2). Testatur Apostolus quod Christus advocatus noster sit apud Patrem; denique quando sedet, conjudicat Patri; quando stat, officio fungitur advocati. Tunc Christus, peracta advocatione, clamat voce magna: Lazare veniforas. Tunc tartarus, ligatis manibus et pedibus, Lazarum retulit ad superna: timens et tremens,ne dum solvit,ne dum moras facit,ne dum tardius refert un um,omnes cogeretur afferre. Sic fact us est vi vorum relator,qui raptor esse consueverat mortuorum. Nam quare Christus vincula inferni dirupit, mortis ligamenta dissolvit,nisi ut nobis monstraret inferni tremendam servitutem? Nam si de Moysi corpore diabo- lus angelo contradixit,quomodo non tartarus Christo de vita et de resurrectione Lazari contradicet?Orate, fratres, ut qui gustum resurrectionis Lazaro propinante suscepimus,redeunte Christo universalis resurrectionis voces mereamur audire.

[On the same.] Since in two sermons we have already touched on the death of Lazarus, Mary's weeping, Martha's tears and the lamentation of the Jews, let us now unburden our minds, cast off our cares and free our senses, so that with our whole minds we may grasp and hear the joy of so great a resurrection. The Evangelist proclaims the Saviour's coming to the tomb in this way: “Jesus,” he says, “again groaning in himself, came to the tomb; it was a cave, and a stone had been laid upon it.” Jesus came groaning to the tomb. Christ groans so that flesh may come to life again; Life groans so that death may be put to flight; God groans so that man may rise; mercy groans so that the sentence may not stand in the way; Christ groans as he overthrows death, because he who snatches a unique victory from the enemy cannot but groan. As for the words “again groaning,” he groans a second time to show the twofold signs of the resurrection: as at Christ's voice those dead in body are raised from their tombs to life, so those dead in faithlessness rise to the life of faith. “It was,” he says, “a cave.” It would have been enough to say that he came to the tomb; why does the Evangelist take such care to mention a cave? Plainly a cave, where the devil's robbery had placed man; a cave, where the woman's deceit had buried the man; a cave, where the greed of death had shut in God's handiwork. “And a stone had been laid upon it.” The door of harsh death was closed, more harshly still, with the hardest stone. But what does one who weeps at a tomb accomplish, when the voice of the weeper does not pierce barriers so hard and so piled up? Christians, let us weep to God for our sins, and let us not weep with the pagans over the dead, who do not hear. “Jesus said: Take away the stone.” Amid his divine mighty works does Christ ask for human help? Is he not able to move a stone who is able to drive away death? Is he not strong enough to unbar a tomb who prevails to open the gates of Tartarus? He had said through the prophet: “I will take away the heart of stone from their flesh and give them a heart of flesh” (Ezek 11:19). So he commands the Jews to take the heart of stone out of themselves, to roll away the rock of faithlessness, to shut out the flint of hard unbelief, so that souls dead through unbelief might leap out of the tomb of the breast, and might rejoice not so much that Lazarus had risen as that they had risen together with Lazarus. “Take away the stone.” Take away the service of wretched humanity, so that the works of blessed divinity may now shine out. “Take away the stone” that you placed, so that I may now restore the man whom I placed. “Martha answered: He already stinks.” Woman, and whose doing is it that he stinks? “He already stinks.” What came from you now belongs to you: you would not perceive a stench at the tomb if you had refused to listen to the persuader in paradise. “He already stinks.” What stinks to the destroyer does not stink to the Creator. “He already stinks.” What the overthrower of another's work shudders at, the lover of his own work does not shrink from. But by speaking thus you bear witness to the death which you, woman, brought in. You cry out the stench, so that the fullness of death may become known to the hearers, and so that Lazarus's rising may be the return of a spirit that had departed, not of one that lay hidden; that it may be the work of divine power, not of human art; and that the Jews, who say that he casts out demons by the prince of demons (Matt 9:34), may not say again that we raise the dead not by God's command but by human aid. “He already stinks; it is the fourth day.” She names the time too, so that they may know that he is the author of times, on whom no times impose limits. “He already stinks; it is the fourth day.” By speaking thus she heightens the despair, so that those present may see that it is God who in this way gives life to the dead, salvation to those beyond hope, vigour to those who stink. “Lifting his eyes,” it says, “upward.” He lifts his eyes upward to give us a pattern of supplication, not to prepare for himself a way of obtaining; for he who looks upward is always on high with the Father; the Father is always in him and he is always in the Father: “I,” he says, “am in the Father, and the Father is in me” (John 14:10). “Father,” he says, “I give you thanks because you have heard me.” He gives thanks for what has been granted; that the Father heard is said; that the Son asked is passed over in silence. Brothers, between Father and Son there is the affection of hearing, not the necessity of supplicating; there is the assent of love, not the severity of command; there everything is done by love, where no deference is needed, as becomes clear from what follows: “Father, I give you thanks because you have heard me; and I knew that you always hear me.” He calls without the trouble of calling, where there is sure confidence of being heard. Or what is the labour of asking doing where the cause of granting is shared? So let no one diminish the Son by his prayers in such a way that he likewise diminishes the Father in the matter of human salvation. Why the Son speaks thus, he himself discloses, saying: “Father, I give you thanks because you have heard me; and I knew that you always hear me; but I said it for the sake of the people standing around.” You see that by saying such things he lifts up and makes known his own and the Father's affection, he lays open grace, he speaks of unity. He had said: “All that the Father has is mine” (John 16:15); and if all things are his, how does he ask? When someone asks from what is his own, what he asks comes not from need but from love. “Father, I give you thanks because you have heard me; and I knew that you always hear me; but I said it for the sake of the people standing around, that they may believe that you sent me.” He said that he was sent, so that the peoples might know that Christ had come from heaven, not that he had left heaven. He is sent, then, in the same way as he receives what he has: in such a way that he did not leave the place from which he came. So the Son receives what he has, and the Father does not lose what he has given. Brothers, that he is heard, that he is sent, that he comes, that he receives, that he is born, that he suffers, that he dies, that he rises: this belongs not to his divinity but to our weakness, to our nature. All this he bore for our sake in our body; he did not undergo it for his own sake in his majesty. But let us return to our subject. What does he mean when he says, “Father, I give you thanks because you have heard me”? What? When Christ began to knock at the doors of the underworld, to thrust back the gates of Tartarus, to open the doors of death, to undo the law of Gehenna, to overturn the most ancient right of punishment, to demand back the soul of Lazarus, to open anew a way of return from the underworld, the whole raging power of Tartarus met him, holding up the edict of the supreme Ruler, bearing the decree of the King on high, carrying the sentence pronounced by God's own voice so many ages before. And seeing a man, it asked who he was, what he dared, what he wanted, why he alone, without trembling, was attacking and assailing the dread approaches of death. When it asked who he was, the angels, ministers of the resurrection, answered in the prophet's words: “He is the King of glory, he is strong and mighty in battle” (Ps 24:8). But Tartarus replies: “I know that the King of glory in the heavens presides over all the heavenly powers, whose nod the whole creation cannot bear; but this one I see is one of the earthly, formed from mud, enclosed in a mortal body, and in this very human condition more lowly than men; in short, he is soon to be given to the grave and straightway made subject to my rule.” But the angels persisted and repeated: “He is the Lord of hosts, he is the King of glory” (Ps 24:10); he is the ruler of heaven, the creator of the world, the saviour of the age, the redeemer of all; he is himself the giver of the sentence on which you rely in your rage; he will tread on your head, he will crush your empire, he will destroy you by his judgment, you who, ordered to seize the guilty, drag in the innocent, plunder the saints, and threaten the very Son of God. Give back one, then, before you are forced to release many. But Tartarus, still not believing this, runs back to heaven by its usual messengers and makes its lament in this spiteful petition: “Lord, though I am the lowest of your creation, though bound to a grim service, I keep your precepts by an inviolable law; I keep watch lest some new violator change the ancient right of your sentence. But a man has appeared called Christ, who boasts that he is your Son; he censures your priests, refutes your scribes, violates your sabbaths, dissolves your law, and compels souls released from the flesh and already assigned to punishment and to my custody to return to the bodies in which they lived wickedly. Every day he goes on to such daring that he is now trying to break the bars of the underworld and drag out Lazarus, who is already shut in our prison, already bound by our law, already held under our right. Either come quickly to help, or, if once he opens the doors, you will now lose all whom we have kept for so many ages.” To this the Son replied from the bosom of the Father: “Father, it is just that the prison hold not the innocent but the guilty, that punishment torment not the righteous but the unrighteous. How long, under the guilt of one man, for the offence of Adam alone, will this executioner not cease with cruel hostility to drag to himself patriarchs, prophets, martyrs, confessors, virgins, widows, those who remain in the chastity of marriage, all ages, both sexes, even little ones who know neither good nor evil? Father, I will die, so that all may not die; Father, I will pay Adam's debt, so that through me those may live to you who through Adam are dying in hell; Father, because of your sentence I will shed my blood, provided only that your creation returns to you; let the price of my blood, dear to you, be the redemption of all the dead.” At this, by the consent of the whole Trinity, Lazarus was commanded to come out, and Tartarus was ordered to obey by giving back all the dead to Christ. That is why the Son cries: “Father, I give you thanks because you have heard me” (John 11:41–42). The Apostle testifies that Christ is our advocate with the Father; so when he sits he judges together with the Father, and when he stands he performs the office of advocate. Then Christ, his pleading complete, “cries with a loud voice: Lazarus, come out.” Then Tartarus, with hands and feet bound, brought Lazarus back to the world above, fearing and trembling lest, while it was loosing him, while it delayed, while it was slow to give back one, it should be forced to bring out all. So he who used to be the robber of the dead became the restorer of the living. For why did Christ burst the chains of the underworld and undo the bonds of death, if not to show us the dreadful servitude of the underworld? For if the devil disputed with the angel about the body of Moses, how would Tartarus not dispute with Christ about the life and resurrection of Lazarus? Pray, brothers, that we who have received a taste of the resurrection, with Lazarus handing us the cup, may be found worthy, when Christ returns, to hear the voices of the universal resurrection.

John 11:38–44 (quotation, high confidence) · Ezek 11:19 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 3:6 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 9:34 (allusion, high confidence) · John 14:10 (quotation, high confidence) · John 16:15 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 24:8 (23:8 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 24:10 (23:10 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 3:15 (allusion, medium confidence) · 1 John 2:1 (allusion, high confidence) · Jude 9 (allusion, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: On the raising of Lazarus, Chrysologus explains Christ's groaning and his thanksgiving to the Father, and imagines Tartarus protesting to heaven until the Son pleads for the dead and Lazarus is released.

  • The dialogue between Tartarus, the angels, the Father and the Son is Chrysologus's own dramatization. “Christ is our advocate with the Father” alludes to 1 John 2:1, which Chrysologus ascribes to “the Apostle.” The dispute over the body of Moses is from Jude 9. “That we raise the dead” (nos… suscitare) is as printed; the subject is probably Christ.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (stray asterisk in the digital text): mortuis* non → mortuis non.

Topics: Christology, Eschatology, Trinity

Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 65 (PL 52:381–385; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/65). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-65) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 66

66PL 52:385–389

De divite et Lazaro. Duas hodie a duobus evangelistis editas, ita recitari fecimus lectiones,ut sermoni nostro vester intellectus occurreret,paterent abdita. Lazari resurgentis occasio,cur alterius nos Lazari compulerit facere mentionem, ex sequentibus audietis: modo inhumani divitis et Lazari pauperis stupendas vices, pavendassuccessiones.conditiones admodum lamentandas in medium producere et afferre gestimus, quia dives qui participempauperem in nobis præsentibus audire contempsit, in futuris malis compatientem pauperem non meruit invenire: nec ardens aquæ refrigerium percepit, æstuanti pauperi fame panis refrigerium qui negavit. Cum esset, inquit, in tormentis elevavit oculos suos,etviditAbraham de longe,et Lazarum in sinu ejus (Luc.XVI). Gratis respicit modo a Lazarum sursum, qui ante deorsum Lazarum videre despexit. De talibus dixit propheta: Oculos suos statuerunt declinarein terram (Ps. XVI). Cum esset in tormentis. Pungit pœna, quæ non pcenitudo compunxit, et vexant tormenta,quem Lazari vulneranon moverunt: nec gratis aculeos percipit pœnarum, qui in purpura volutabatur ingratus. ViditA braham de longe. Longe illi erat Abrabam, cui non fuerat proximus pauper. Vidit Abraham divitiarum consortem, sed inhumanitatis exsortem, et Abraham dives, sed plus humanitate quamcensu,tudivesinhumanitate tua major tuis divitiisextitisti; Abraham sibi peregrinus, civis hospitum fuit; tu palatia possidens, tectum pauperi non dedisti;Abraham dum servos suscipit,dominum sicrecepit,et cunctis hominibus ponens panes, ipsum Dominum suam suscepit ad mensam; tu dum singulari pauperi negas micas, stillam refrigerii perdidisti. Et ipse clamans dixit. Sic clamat ibi,qui hic clamantes contempsit audire,ibi cassa vox est, istic inanis est clamor. Audi propbetam dicentem: In inferno autem quis confitebitur tibi (Psal. VI)? In inferno quis misericordiæ locus? in tormentisquaesepes veniae, et in hora sententiæ tem- pusindulgentieequis requirit? Pater Abraham,miserere mei. Crudelis fili, quam misericordiam petis quam tibi negando pauperi tu negasti? Et mitte Lazarum. Miser fili, si Lazarus ad tuam mensam venisset, tu ad istum discubitum non venisses. Ut intingat extremum digiti sui in aquam. Qui claudit man um pauperi, extremi stipem digiti sic deposcit, et sitit aqueeguttam,qui vinilacus,ne guttam daret, inclu- sit. Ut intingat extremum digiti sui. Qui divitias suas non miserando pauperi dedit,sibi misericordiam sic minorat. Et refrigeret linguam meam, quiacruciorin hac flamma. Quasi reliquum corporis ab incendio haberetimmune:sed lingua plus ardet, quæ misericordia ut fieret, jubere neglexit; in linguamajus sentit incendium, quæ maledixit pauperi, misericordiam contradixit; lingua in tormentis prima est, quæ derogandopauperi,pauperis blasphemavit auctorem. Sed audiamus jam quid responderit Abraham. Fili, inquit, recordare, quia recepisti bona invita tua, et Lazarus similiter mala. Nemo putet, audiendo ista, quia dives pro bonis receperit bona, quando hinc magis reus est, quod cum a Deo pro malis receperit bona,bona pro nobis Deo reddere contempsit. Nam de divitiis tantis nec victum dedit pauperi,nec sacrificium Deo minima oblatione dependit. Atpauper dives vulnere, censu nudus, exutus corpore, vestitus poenis,animam quam solam non tenebant vulnera, Deo in hostiam jugiter offerebat. Hine est, quod recipit pro doloribus requiem,pro opprobrio gloriam, pro contumeliis honorem, pro despectu gratiam, pro poenis immortalitatem, pro vulneribus præmia, pro sitirefrigerii fontem, pro fame coelestis mensae delicias sempiternas,et quem divitis angulus non cepit, sinus divinæ consolationis includit. Tu, dives, fulgens quondam purpura, nunc tegere fimo, pro coccino vestire flammis,pro molli discubitu sustine tormentorumdura,pro lautis ferculis epulare pœnas, copias inopia compensa, ebrietates siti digere, pro odoribus aspergere fetore:et cui astiterunt voluptatis obsequia, astent ibi ministerianunc poenarum, quia ista tibi despiciendo pauperem taliter tu muta- Iti. Adjecit autem Abraham, dicens: In his omnibus in ter nos et vos chaosm magnum firmatum est, ut qui volunt hinc transire ad vos non possint, neque inde huc transmeare.Dicendo sic,h tam justos quam injustos ante adventum Domini apud inferos fuisse declarat, et a discretos locis tantum, non regionibus aperit fuisse divisos. Postquam vero Dominus resurgens a mortuis, aperuit infernum, patefecit cœlos, paradisi claustra reseravit, dedit sanctis paradisi intrare requiem, ad coeli gloriam pervenire. Ista qui sic credit, intelligit qu id mortalibus veniens donaverit Christus. Insipienter ergo dives putat apud inferos mutari loca, quando hic agendo homo bene vel male ibi sibi terminum aut pœnæ aut quietis indicit. Slultus in vita dives, stultior invenitur in poena; et qui bonorum suorum nescivit tempus, nec malorum suorumtempus miserandus agnoscit. Rogo te, pater. Modo rogas, modo tibi tempus patiendi est, non rogandi. Rogo te, pater Quid? Ut mittas Lazarum in domum patris mei. Ante quam bene jacuitLazarus adillam januam, in qua fame sua inhumanitatis tuæ titulos fixit, ubi postestuos suis ulceribus laureavit, ubi sanie sua 8 pinxit micas tuas. Patere ergo stare vices, jam depone dolos; lucet quia tu Lazarum non potes sic videre: scitur, scitur, quia plus te felicitas Lazari quam gehennæ torquet incendium. Respondit Abraham: Habent Moysen etprophetas, audiant illos. Hoc est, si Moysen, qui regna Ægypti elementis secum militantibus trivit (Exod. vn), quisiccavitmare Exod. XIV), qui duravitfluctus,qui lapidesin iluenta convertit (Exod.XVII), qui solem texit nube, qui noctem luce radiavit [Exod. XIII), qui cælum fecitpluere carnes, rorare panes (Num. XVI), non solum non audierunt, sed et occidere sunt moliti, isti Lazarum dignabuntur audire,quem tot vulnera sepiunt,quot Moysen cinxere virtutes? patere et me sentire quod genui, et tu patere quæ fecisti. Non, pater Abraham. Vere, non pater, quia non erat Abrahee filius, sed gehennæ. Non, pater Abraham, sed si quis ierit a mortuis ad eos, pœnitentiam agent.f Hoc dives de corde omnium dicit, hoc de desideriis cunctorum petit, hoc de votis omnium loquitur mundanorum,omnes enim susurrare consuevimus: 0 si quis veniret a mortuis, et quod ibi agitur hic referret, omnes crederent ei. Certe, ut dubitantes dicerent. Quis inde venit, unde nemo venit? Post mortem quod sit aliquis, quis probabit? Omnes audita loquimur, dictis insinuatasentimus: nam quid veri fides habeat, mersum est in profundum.Sed perfidiæ, non ignorantiæ esse quod sic loquimur,cum ita credimus, hodie beati Joannis evangelistæ lectio secuta monstravit. Nam sicut dives petit, Deus pro Lazaro Lazarum misit. Sed quid missus,quid desideratus,quid resurgens profecerit, patienter audite. Cogitaverunt, inquit, principes sacerdotum, ut Lazarum interficerent, quia multi propter illum abibant ex Judaeis, et credebant in Jesum (Joan. XII). Quasi ad hoc desideratus advenerit, utiteratæ mortis pericula sustineret. Nolunt, nolunt referre visa, qui voluntauditanon credi. Scimus, scimus, et vitam parari bonis, et malis tormenta præparari: sed dum vitiis capti virtutum tempus nolumusadvenire, fingimus nescire quod scimus,et post mortem quid sit nolumus ad inferis venire qui dicat, cum de coelo Christus veniens, et ab inferis ipse rediens, et quid bono!; in coelo maneat, et quid malos exspectet in inferno,et verbo docuerit, et firmaverit exemplo. Sedforte ideo nec ista credimus,nec Christumvolumusadvenire,quia mundum transire nolumus, immo non quia mundum transire nolumus, sed quia dolemus vitia præterire. Christus venit non vitam fugare,sed mortem; mortem fugare, non vitam; mundum revocare, non tollere; vitia perdere, non suam disperdere creaturam. Sedorate,fratres, ut veniens nos inveniat tales, quales regni sui cupit et praecipit esse consortes.

[On the rich man and Lazarus.] We have had two readings, issued by two evangelists, read today in such a way that your understanding might go out to meet our sermon and hidden things might be laid open. Why the occasion of Lazarus's rising compelled us to mention another Lazarus you will hear in what follows. For now we long to bring out into the open the astonishing changes of fortune of the inhuman rich man and of poor Lazarus, their fearful reversals and their most lamentable conditions; because the rich man who scorned to hear the poor man asking for a share in the present life did not deserve to find the poor man sharing his suffering in the evils to come; nor did he, burning, receive the refreshment of water, who denied the refreshment of bread to the poor man burning with hunger. “When he was in torment,” it says, “he lifted up his eyes and saw Abraham far off, and Lazarus in his bosom” (Luke 16:23). In vain does he now look up at Lazarus above, who before disdained to look down at Lazarus below. Of such the prophet said: “They set their eyes to bow down to the earth” (Ps 17:11). “When he was in torment.” Punishment stings the one whom repentance did not sting to compunction; torments harass the one whom the sores of Lazarus did not move; and not without cause does he feel the goads of punishment who rolled ungratefully in purple. “He saw Abraham far off.” Abraham was far from him to whom the poor man had not been near. He saw Abraham, a sharer in riches but having no share in inhumanity. Abraham was rich, but more in humanity than in wealth; you, rich man, were greater in your inhumanity than in your riches. Abraham, himself a stranger, was a fellow citizen to his guests; you, possessing palaces, gave the poor man no roof. Abraham, while receiving servants, in this way received the Lord, and setting loaves before all men, received the Lord himself at his table; you, while denying crumbs to one poor man, lost a drop of refreshment. “And he cried out and said.” So he cries out there who here scorned to hear those who cried out; there the voice is empty, here the cry was in vain. Hear the prophet saying: “In hell who will confess to you?” (Ps 6:5). In hell what place is there for mercy? In torments what hope of pardon? And who looks for a time of indulgence at the hour of sentence? “Father Abraham, have mercy on me.” Cruel son, what mercy do you ask, when you denied it to yourself by denying it to the poor man? “And send Lazarus.” Wretched son, if Lazarus had come to your table, you would not have come to this place at table. “To dip the tip of his finger in water.” He who closes his hand to the poor man thus begs the alms of a fingertip, and he thirsts for a drop of water who shut up vats of wine so as not to give a drop. “To dip the tip of his finger.” He who did not give his riches to the poor man in pity thus lessens mercy for himself. “And cool my tongue, for I am tormented in this flame.” As if he had the rest of his body free from the burning! But the tongue burns more, which neglected to order that mercy be done; the tongue feels the greater burning, which cursed the poor man and spoke against mercy; the tongue is first in torments, which by disparaging the poor man blasphemed the poor man's maker. But now let us hear what Abraham answered. “Son,” he says, “remember that you received good things in your life, and Lazarus likewise evil things.” Let no one, hearing this, think that the rich man received good things in return for good, since he is all the more guilty in this: though he received good things from God in return for evil, he scorned to give good things back to God on our behalf. For out of such great riches he neither gave food to the poor man nor paid God a sacrifice of even the smallest offering. But the poor man, rich in sores, naked of wealth, stripped of body, clothed in pains, continually offered to God as a sacrifice the soul, which alone the sores did not hold. That is why he receives rest for pains, glory for reproach, honour for insults, favour for contempt, immortality for punishments, rewards for wounds, a spring of refreshment for thirst, the everlasting delights of the heavenly table for hunger; and him whom a corner of the rich man's house did not take in, the bosom of divine consolation encloses. You, rich man, who once shone in purple, now be covered in dung; instead of scarlet be clothed with flames; instead of a soft couch endure the hardness of torments; instead of sumptuous dishes feast on punishments; pay for your abundance with want; digest your drunkenness with thirst; instead of perfumes be sprinkled with stench; and you whom the services of pleasure attended, let the ministers of punishment now attend you there, because you yourself exchanged these things for yourself in this way by despising the poor man. “And Abraham added, saying: Besides all this, between us and you a great chasm has been fixed, so that those who wish to cross from here to you cannot, nor can they cross from there to here.” By speaking thus he declares that both the righteous and the unrighteous were in the underworld before the Lord's coming, and he shows that they were divided only by being set apart in places, not in different realms. But after the Lord, rising from the dead, opened the underworld, laid open the heavens and unbarred paradise, he granted the saints to enter the rest of paradise and to come to the glory of heaven. Whoever believes this understands what Christ by his coming has given to mortals. Foolishly, then, does the rich man think that places can be changed in the underworld, since a man, by acting well or ill here, appoints for himself there the end either of punishment or of rest. Foolish in life, the rich man is found more foolish in punishment; and he who did not know the time of his good things, wretched man, does not recognize the time of his evils either. “I ask you, father.” Now you ask; now is the time for you to suffer, not to ask. “I ask you, father.” What? “That you send Lazarus to my father's house.” Before, Lazarus lay well enough at that door, on which by his hunger he fixed the inscriptions of your inhumanity, where he crowned your doorposts with the laurels of his sores, where with his pus he painted your crumbs. Allow the reversal to stand, then; lay aside your tricks now. It is plain that you cannot bear to see Lazarus like this; it is known, it is known that Lazarus's happiness torments you more than the fire of Gehenna. “Abraham answered: They have Moses and the prophets; let them listen to them.” That is: if they not only did not listen to Moses, who crushed the kingdom of Egypt with the elements fighting on his side (Exod 7), who dried up the sea (Exod 14), who made the waves stand firm, who turned rocks into streams (Exod 17), who covered the sun with a cloud and made the night radiant with light (Exod 13), who made the sky rain meat and drop bread like dew (Num 11), but even tried to kill him, will they deign to listen to Lazarus, who is hedged about by as many wounds as the mighty works that surrounded Moses? Allow me to experience what I have begotten, and you endure what you have done. “No, father Abraham.” Truly not father, because he was not a son of Abraham but of Gehenna. “No, father Abraham, but if someone goes to them from the dead, they will repent.” This the rich man says from the heart of all, asks from the desires of all, speaks from the wishes of all who belong to the world; for we are all in the habit of whispering: “Oh, if only someone would come from the dead and report here what is done there, everyone would believe him!” Surely, so that the doubters might say: “Who has come from there, from where no one comes? Who will prove that anyone exists after death? We all speak of what we have heard; we feel what has been instilled by words; for whatever truth faith holds is sunk in the deep.” But that our speaking thus, even while we believe these things, comes from faithlessness and not from ignorance, today's reading that followed, from blessed John the Evangelist, has shown. For as the rich man asked, God sent a Lazarus in place of Lazarus. But what the one who was sent, longed for and risen achieved, listen patiently. “The chief priests,” it says, “planned to kill Lazarus, because on his account many of the Jews were going away and believing in Jesus” (John 12:10–11). As if he had come, though longed for, only to undergo the dangers of a second death! They do not want, they do not want to report what they have seen, who want what they have heard not to be believed. We know, we know both that life is prepared for the good and that torments are prepared for the wicked; but while, captured by vices, we do not want the time of virtues to come, we pretend not to know what we know, and we do not want anyone to come from the underworld to tell what there is after death, when Christ, coming from heaven and himself returning from the underworld, has both taught by word and confirmed by example what remains for the good in heaven and what awaits the wicked in the underworld. But perhaps we neither believe these things nor want Christ to come because we do not want the world to pass away; or rather, not because we do not want the world to pass away, but because we are grieved to leave our vices behind. Christ comes not to drive away life but death; to drive away death, not life; to call the world back, not to take it away; to destroy vices, not to destroy his own creation. But pray, brothers, that when he comes he may find us such as he desires and commands the sharers of his kingdom to be.

Luke 16:19–31 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 17:11 (16:11 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 18:1–8 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 6:5 (6:6 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Exod 7:14–25 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 14:21–29 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 17:6 (allusion, high confidence) · Exod 13:21–22 (allusion, high confidence) · Num 11:31 (allusion, medium confidence) · Exod 16:13–15 (allusion, medium confidence) · John 12:10–11 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Chrysologus contrasts the rich man's inhumanity with Abraham's hospitality, explains the reversal of their fates, and shows from the plot to kill the raised Lazarus that unbelief, not lack of evidence, keeps people from believing.

  • “On our behalf” renders pro nobis as printed; pro bonis (“in return for the good things”) may be meant. On the righteous and unrighteous both in the underworld before Christ, divided only by place, Chrysologus follows a common early view of Luke 16:26. The sky that “rained meat and dropped bread like dew” combines Num 11:31 and Exod 16:13–15.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (dropped letter in the digital text (utari for mutari)): apud inferos utari loca → apud inferos mutari loca.

Topics: Eschatology, Ethics

Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 66 (PL 52:385–389; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/66). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-66) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.

Chapter 67

67PL 52:389–393

In orationem Dominicam. Accepistis auditum fidei, fratres charissimi, for.mam Dominicae orationis audite. Christus breviter orare docuit, qui cito vult postulata præstare. Aut quid petentibus se non dabit, qui seipsum. non petentibus dedit? Aut in respondendo quam facit moram qui in dictandis precibus vota supplicum sic praevenit? Hodie quod audituri estis stupent angeli, miratur coelum, pavet terra, caro non fert, auditus non capit, non attingit mens, totasustinere non potest creatura: ego dicere non audeo, tacere non possum. Deus det ut et vos audire possitis, et ego dicere. Quid est magis tremendum, quod se dedit terris Deus, aut quod vos dat coelo; quod societatem carnis intratipse,autquod vosfacit consortium divinitatis intrare; quod mortem sumit ipse aut quod vos resumit ex morte; quod ipse in vestram nascitur servitutem,autquod vos sibi gignit inlibe. ros; quod suscipit paupertatem vestram, aut quod vos sibi facit hæredes, sui unici coheeredes? Est uti- que terribilius quod terra transfertur in cælum, homodeitatemutatur, servitutissors dominationis jura sortitur.Sedhocquamvis metuendum sit,tamen quia causa non docentem respicit,sed jubentem, accedamus, filioli, quo vocat charitas, trahit amor, iovitat affectio: Deum patrem viscera sentiant, vox personet, loquatur lingua, spiritus clamet, et totum quod est in nobis, respondeat gratiae, nontimori;quiaqui udicem mutavit in patrem,amari voluit, non timeri. Pater noster qui es in cœlis (Matth. VI). Hoc cum dicis, non sic habeas, quasi non sit in terris; non sic accipias, quasi sit loco clausus, qui claudit omnia, sed intellige esse tibi genus e coelo,cujus Pater habetur in cælo; et age ut, vivendo sancte,sancto respondeasPatri. Dei filium ille se probat, qui vitiis non obscuratur humanis, qui divinis virtutibus elucescit. Sanctificetur nomen tuum, Cujus genussumus, ejus censemur et nomine: rogamus ergo ut nomen ejus quod in se et per se sanctum est sancti.. ficetur in nobis; nomen enim Dei aut honoratur0 ex nostro actu, aut ex nostris actibus blasphematur. Audi Apostolum dicentem: Nomen Dei per vos bla- sphematurin gentibus (Rom. ii). Veniat regnum tuum. Et quando non regnavit Deus? Petimus ergo ut qui sibi regnavit semper,modo regnet in nobis, ut et nos in illo regnare possimus. Regnavit diabolus, regnavit peccatum,regnavitmors,et fuit diu captiva mortalitas: petimus ergo ut, regnanteDeo, pareat diabolus, e deficiat peccatum, moriatur mors,captivitas captivetur, ut nos liberi perpetuam regnemus in vitam. Fiat voluntas tua sicut in cælo et in terra. Hoc est regnum Dei, quando et in coelo, et in terra Dei voluntas est sola, quando in omnibus hominibus Deus mens est, Deus vivit, Deus agit, Deusregnat. Deus est totum, ut juxtaillud Apostoli:Sit Deusomnia in omnibus vobis (I Cor.XV).Panem nostrum quotidianum da nobis hodie.Qui patrem se nobis dedit,qui sibi nos adopta vitin tilios, qui rerum nos fecithæredes, qui nos nomine sublimavit, qui nos suo et honore donavit et regno, ipse nos ut panem quotidianum postulemus addixit. In regno Dei, inter munera divina, quid quæerit paupertas humana? tam bonus,tam pius, tam largus Paterpanem filiis non nisi postulatus indulget? Et ubi est illud: Nolite solliciti esse quid manducetiS, aut quid bibatis, aut quid vestiamini (Matth. VI)? Hoc petere jubet quod prohibetcogitare, quatenus cælestis paterh coelestem panem, cœlestes filii ut postulemus, hortatur. Ipse dixit: Ego sum panis, qui de cælo descendi (Joan. VI). Ipse est panis, qui satus in Virgine, fermentatus in carne, in passione confectus, in fornacecoctus sepulcri, in Ecclesiis conditus, illatus altaribus, cælestem cibum quotidie fidelibus subministrat. Et dimitte nobis debitanostra,sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris. Homo, i si sine peccato esse non potes, et vis semper dimitti tibi totum, dimitte semper; quantum vis dimitti tibi, dimitte tantum; quoties vis dimitti tibi, toties tu dimitte; immo quia vis totum dimitti tibi, totum dimitte: homo, intellige quia remittendo aliis tuj tibi veniam dedisti. Et ne nos inducas ie tentationem. Quia in sæculo est ipsa vita tentatio. Tentatio, inquit, ille, est vita hominis (Job. vu).Rogemus ergo ut nos a arbitrio nostro non relinquat,sed in omni actu paterna nos pietate constringat, et in vitae tramite cœlesti mode ratione confirmet. Sed libera nos a malo. A quo maio? a diabolo quippe,ex quo est omne malum. Rogamus liberari nos a malo, quia malo,qui non caruerit, frui non potest bono. ° Si adhucnon nati,si adhuc in utero constituti, panem petunt, expetunt regaum,d quare fit quœstio, quod semper Dei Filius in Dei patris mansitarcano?Si Ecclesiagenerat,ratio non est, est coeleste mysterium; quod in Patre Deo,Dei Eilius fuerit, quomodo humana ratiocinatione tractetur non est,non est humano modo divinitas aestimanda.A udisti Deum, nil terrenum cogites, nil humanum: audisti Patrem Chtisti, hoc per substantiam crede; audisti patrem tuum, hoccrede per grauam: ille ut esset Filius habuit semper, te esse tilium dedit modo, Sic ergo te filium scito, ut servum te esse non neseias; sic audi ad Christi similitudinem te reductum, ut semper te Christo cognoscas esse subjectum.

[On the Lord's Prayer.] You have received the hearing of faith, dearest brothers; now hear the form of the Lord's Prayer. Christ taught us to pray briefly, because he wants to grant our requests quickly. Or what will he not give to those who ask him, who gave himself to those who did not ask? Or what delay will he make in answering, who in dictating the prayers so anticipates the wishes of those who pray? What you are about to hear today the angels are astonished at, heaven marvels at, earth trembles at; flesh does not bear it, hearing does not take it in, the mind does not reach it, the whole creation cannot sustain it. I do not dare to say it; I cannot keep silent. May God grant that you may be able to hear and I to speak. Which is more awesome: that God gave himself to the earth, or that he gives you to heaven; that he himself enters into fellowship with flesh, or that he makes you enter into partnership with divinity; that he himself takes on death, or that he takes you back out of death; that he himself is born into your servitude, or that he begets you as free children for himself; that he takes on your poverty, or that he makes you his heirs, co-heirs of his only Son? It is surely more awesome that earth is carried over into heaven, that man is changed by deity, that the lot of servitude obtains the rights of lordship. But though this is to be feared, since the matter rests not with the one who teaches but with the one who commands, let us draw near, little children, to where charity calls, love draws, affection invites. Let our hearts feel God as Father, our voice sound it, our tongue speak it, our spirit cry it, and let everything that is in us respond to grace, not to fear; because he who changed the judge into a father wanted to be loved, not feared. “Our Father who are in heaven” (Matt 6:9). When you say this, do not take it as though he were not on earth; do not understand it as though he who encloses all things were enclosed in a place; but understand that you have a lineage from heaven, since your Father is held to be in heaven, and act so that by living holily you may answer to a holy Father. He proves himself a son of God who is not darkened by human vices but shines with divine virtues. “Hallowed be your name.” We are reckoned by the name of him whose lineage we are; so we ask that his name, which in itself and through itself is holy, be hallowed in us; for God's name is either honoured by our conduct or blasphemed because of our actions. Hear the Apostle saying: “The name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles because of you” (Rom 2:24). “Your kingdom come.” And when did God not reign? So we ask that he who always reigned for himself may now reign in us, so that we too may be able to reign in him. The devil has reigned, sin has reigned, death has reigned, and mortality was long held captive. So we ask that, with God reigning, the devil may perish, sin may fail, death may die, captivity may be taken captive, so that we, set free, may reign into everlasting life. “Your will be done, as in heaven so also on earth.” This is the kingdom of God: when both in heaven and on earth God's will alone prevails, when in all people God is the mind, God lives, God acts, God reigns, God is everything, according to the Apostle's word: “That God may be all in all” in you (1 Cor 15:28). “Give us today our daily bread.” He who gave himself to us as Father, who adopted us as sons for himself, who made us heirs of all things, who exalted us with his name, who gave us his honour and his kingdom, he himself has bound us to ask for daily bread. In the kingdom of God, amid divine gifts, what does human poverty seek? Does so good, so loving, so generous a Father grant bread to his children only when he is asked? And where is that saying: “Do not be anxious about what you will eat, or what you will drink, or what you will wear” (Matt 6:31)? He commands us to ask for what he forbids us to worry about, because the heavenly Father urges us, as heavenly children, to ask for the heavenly bread. He himself said: “I am the bread that came down from heaven” (John 6:41). He is the bread which, sown in the Virgin, leavened in the flesh, kneaded in the passion, baked in the oven of the tomb, stored in the churches, brought to the altars, daily supplies heavenly food to the faithful. “And forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors.” O man, if you cannot be without sin and want always to be forgiven everything, always forgive; as much as you want to be forgiven, so much forgive; as often as you want to be forgiven, so often forgive; or rather, since you want everything forgiven you, forgive everything. O man, understand that by forgiving others you have given pardon to yourself. “And lead us not into temptation.” For in this world life itself is temptation: “The life of man,” he says, “is a temptation” (Job 7:1). So let us ask that he not leave us to our own choice, but hold us fast in every act with fatherly love and strengthen us on the path of life with heavenly guidance. “But deliver us from evil.” From what evil? From the devil, of course, from whom comes all evil. We ask to be delivered from evil, because one who is not free of evil cannot enjoy the good. If those not yet born, still placed in the womb, ask for bread and seek the kingdom, why is there any question about how the Son of God always remained in the secret of God the Father? If the church gives birth, this is not a matter of reason; it is a heavenly mystery. How the Son of God was in God the Father is not to be handled by human reasoning; divinity is not to be estimated in a human way. You have heard “God”: think nothing earthly, nothing human. You have heard “Father of Christ”: believe this by substance. You have heard “your Father”: believe this by grace. He always had it that he was Son; to you he has now given to be a son. So know yourself a son in such a way that you do not forget that you are a servant; so hear that you have been brought back to the likeness of Christ, that you always recognize yourself to be subject to Christ.

Matt 6:9–13 (quotation, high confidence) · Rom 2:24 (quotation, high confidence) · Eph 4:8 (allusion, low confidence) · 1 Cor 15:28 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 6:31 (quotation, high confidence) · John 6:41 (quotation, high confidence) · Job 7:1 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Handing the Lord's Prayer to candidates for baptism, Chrysologus explains each petition and distinguishes Christ's sonship by nature from theirs by grace.

  • The hearers are candidates for baptism, who have just received the Creed; Chrysologus calls them “not yet born” because their birth from the church in baptism is still to come. The bread “brought to the altars” is the Eucharist. Job 7:1 is quoted in the Old Latin form (temptatio, “temptation”).

Topics: Prayer, Baptism, Eucharist

Cite (SBL): Peter Chrysologus, Serm. 67 (PL 52:389–393; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/peter-chrysologus-sermones/67). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-peter-chrysologus-sermones-67) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina 52 (digital text, Open Greek and Latin; corrections logged). No public-domain English exists; sermons in FOTC 17, 109 and 110 (Ganss; Palardy) were checked against them privately after translation, the others re-read against the Latin.