Latin Translation of Basil's Hexaemeron 8.1–8.8

Latin text: PL 53 (Latin text: Migne, Patrologia Latina, vol. 53, digitized by Open Greek and Latin (patrologia_latina-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).

Show

Chapter 8

8.1PL 53:946a

Et dixit Deus: Ejiciat terra animam secundum genus: quadrupedes, et serpentes, et bestias secundum genus. Et factum est sic. Venit præceptio passim gradiens, et recepit terra proprium a cursum. Ibi jussit aquas ejicere reptilia animarum vitarum: hic, Ejiciat terra animam vivam. Putasne ergo est animata tellus, ei locus præbebitur vaniloquis Manichæis, animam terræ dandi? Non omnimodis, quia dixit, Ejiciat, quod in ipsa erat, eduxit, sed Deus qui præceptionem dedit, etiam virtutem terra tribuit educendi. Neque enim cum audisset, ut herbam germinaret feni, et lignum fructuosum, latens intra se videlicet, herbam feni tantum protulit, nec palmas, aut esculos, aut cypressos, in suis abstrusa sinibus, ad superna produxit; sed sermo divinus nascentium profecto creator est. Germinet terra, non ut quod habebat, educeret; sed ut quod non haberet assumeret, Deo scilicet operationis ei præbente virtutem. Sic et modo: Ejiciat animam: non eam quae recondita erat in terra, sed quæ illi a Deo collata est per mandatum. Deinde in contrarium Manichaeis sermo vertendus est. Si enim animam quam habebat tellus eduxit, exanimis ipsa facta est. Sed corum quidem detestabilitas nota subinde est. Illud sane videamus, cur aquæ jussæ sunt reptilia vivarum animarum producere, tellus autem animam vivam. Arbitramur igitur eo quod natura natantium imperfectam quodammodo putatur habere vitam: ob hoc quia crassiores sunt aquæ. Nam denique tardior auditus cst animantibus in aqua degentibus, et visas hebetior, ut pote per aquam cernendo, nec ulla apud eos memoria, vel opinatio, vel agnitio est proximorum. Declarat ergo sermo divinus, quia vita carnalis aquariorum moderatur animi motionibus. Nam in terrigenis bestiis, quæ vitam perfectiorem sortitæ sunt, animus corporis obtinet principatum. Etenim sensus earum vegetior est, manifestaque animalia cum praesentium maximam curam gerant, tunc diligenter memoriam custodiunt transactorum. Unde considerandum est e quod pi- scium quidem corpora animala produxit aqua: reptilia enim animarum vivarum produxit, ut ScriptuM significat, in terrestribus autem anima corpus regens. generari præcepta est, ut pote quae plus vivificæ virtutis assumpserint, quanquam ipsa quoque terrestria sint irrationabilia, tamen unumquodque eorum multo per naturalem vocem super animi passione significat. Nam et lætitiam et moTorem, et inediam, et separationem suorum, variasque molestias voce declarant, cum aquaria non solum muta. sed etiam immitia sint et indocta, et ad omnem vitæ societatem prorsus hominibus intractabilia. Recognovit bos possessorem suum, et asinus præsepe domini sui (Isai. I, 3), piscis vero nunquam potuit cognoscere nutrimenta præstantem. Intelligit asinus et hominis consuetam vocem, novit iter quod sæpius ambalavit, interdumaque dux fit agitatori suo, cum erravcrit, ad audiendum ita vehementer acutus, ut nullum ei possit de terrcstribus comparari. Camelus habet semper tenacem memoriam malorum; et ad iracundiam gravis, et perseverans est. Denique si fuerit percussus, diu dis- simulato dolore, cum reperit opportunum tempus. illatam protinus reponit injuriam. Sed hunc nulla do marinis belluis imitatur. Audite igitur, iracundi homi nes, qui recordationem dudum læsionis acceptæ pro virtute maxima affectatis, cui belluae similes habeamini, quando proprium bilem, tanquam aliquam scintillam cinere sopitam, usque eo retinetis in cordibus, quousque nacti occasionem, stimulos doloris, velut igniculum parvum, fomite nutritum suscitetis in flammam.

"And God said, Let the earth bring forth the living soul according to its kind: four-footed animals, and creeping things, and beasts according to their kind. And it was so." The command came, advancing step by step, and the earth received its own course. There he commanded the waters to bring forth creeping things with living souls; here, "Let the earth bring forth the living soul." Do you think, then, that the earth is animate, and will room be given to the foolish-talking Manichaeans to grant a soul to the earth? By no means: because he said "Let it bring forth," it did not bring out what was in it; rather God, who gave the command, also gave the earth the power to bring forth. For when it heard that it should sprout the grass of hay and the fruitful tree, it did not bring forth only grass of hay hidden within itself, nor did it bring up palms, oaks, or cypresses hidden in its bosom; but the divine word is truly the creator of growing things. "Let the earth sprout": not that it should bring out what it had, but that it should receive what it did not have, God supplying it with the power of working. So too now: "Let it bring forth a soul": not one stored up in the earth, but one conferred on it by God through his command. Then the argument can be turned against the Manichaeans: if the earth brought out the soul it had, it was itself left soulless. But their detestable teaching is well known. Let us see rather why the waters were commanded to produce creeping things with living souls, but the earth a living soul. We think, then, it is because the nature of swimming things is thought to have a life in some way imperfect, because the waters are thicker. For indeed hearing is slower in animals living in water, and sight duller, since they see through water; and they have no memory, no imagination, no recognition of those near them. The divine word, then, declares that the bodily life of water creatures governs the movements of their soul. But in land animals, which have received a more perfect life, the soul holds the rule over the body. For their senses are livelier, and these animals, while taking the greatest care of present things, also carefully keep the memory of past ones. So we must consider that the water produced bodies of fish that are animate (for it produced "creeping things with living souls," as Scripture shows), but in land animals a soul ruling the body was commanded to be generated, since they received more of life-giving power. Although land animals too are irrational, yet each of them signifies much about the feeling of its soul by its natural voice. For they show by their voice gladness and grief, hunger, separation from their own, and various troubles, while water creatures are not only mute but also untameable and unteachable, and utterly unmanageable by human beings for any fellowship of life. "The ox knows its owner, and the ass its master's crib" (Isa 1:3); but a fish could never recognize the one who supplies its food. The ass understands even the accustomed voice of a man; it knows the road it has often walked, and sometimes becomes a guide to its driver when he has lost his way; it is so keen of hearing that none of the land animals can be compared to it. The camel always has a tenacious memory of injuries, and is heavy and persistent in anger. If it has been struck, it hides its pain for a long time, and when it finds an opportune time, it at once repays the injury done to it. But none of the sea monsters imitates it. Hear, then, angry men, who cultivate the remembrance of an injury received long ago as if it were the greatest virtue, what beast you are like, when you keep your own bile in your hearts like a spark buried in ash, until, finding an occasion, you stir up the stings of resentment, like a little fire fed with tinder, into a flame.

Gen 1:24 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 1:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 1:11 (allusion, medium confidence) · Isa 1:3 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: God's word gave the earth power to bring forth animals, not a soul of its own as the Manichaeans claim; land animals have a fuller life than fish, and the camel's grudge rebukes vindictive men.

  • Gen 1:24 in the LXX form; Gen 1:20. Isa 1:3. The Manichaeans held that soul (particles of light) is mixed in all matter.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): Et facfum est sic → Et factum est sic; Ejiciat lerra → Ejiciat terra; animatatellus → animata tellus; Manicbxis → Manichæis; sed Dens qui → sed Deus qui; quod habcbat → quod habebat; operalionis ci → operationis ei; signiticat → significat; bominibus iutractabilia → hominibus intractabilia; habcimm → habeamini.

Topics: Heresy, Ethics

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.1 (PL 53:946a; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-1). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-1) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.2PL 53:946c

Ejiciat terra animam vivam. Cur terra producit animam vivam? ut differentiam discas animæ pecoris hominisque. Et paulo quidem inferius cognosces quomodo anima sit hominis constituta: nunc vero audi de anima mutorum, quia secundum Scripturam, cunctorum animalium aniina sanguis est proprius. Sanguis autem gelatus converti solet in carnem, caro autem corrupta redit in terram. Merito ergo tabida est anima jumentorum. Ejiciat terra animam vivam. Vide consequentiam animæ ad sanguinem, sangui- nis ad carnem, carnis ad terram. Iterumque resolvens hæc, redi repedando per eadem, id est de terra ad carnem, a carne in sanguinem, a sanguine in animam, et invenies quia pecorum animus terra est. Nec eam opineris antiquiorem esse substantiae corporalis illorum: nec a exspectare, ut cum corpore dissolvatur. Fuge garrulitates anxias philosophorum, qui asserere non erubescunt suas canumque animas similem tenere speciem. Siquidem profitentur etiam mulieres se quondam pisces fruticesque fuise. Ego autem si fuerunt aliquando pisces, quod non credam; tamen dum ista scriberent, irrationabiliores piscibus habebantur. Ejiciat terra animam vivam. Quare igitur passim currente sermone, subito non brevi tempore conticuerim, credo mirari nonnullos astantium, quan- quam studiosissimos auditores non arbitror causas ignorare silentii; quippe qui respectu nutuque inter se vicissim, ad memoriam nos eorum, quae intermisimus reduxerunt. Certam enim partem creaturæ non vilissimam pene præterivimus indiscussam. Ejiciant aquæ reptilia animarum vivarum, secundum genus, et volatilia volantia sub firmamento caeli. Dixeramus superius de natantibus, quantum tempus permiserat vespertinum; hodie transimus ad examinationem terrestrium, Sed interea nos in narratione media volucres effugerunt. Quapropter imitandi sunt nobis obliviosi viatores, qui cum aliquid in mansione reliquerint pretiosum, quamvis maximam partem viæ progrediendo confecerint, revertuntur: dignum laborem suae negligentiae perferentes: sic et nobi per eumdem quem venimos callem redeundum est. Neque enim contemptibile est quod omisimus: ut pote quae tertia portio sit animalium creaturæ. Nam tria genera sunt animantium, terrestrium, volatilium, marinorum. Ejiciant, inqnit, aquæ reptilia animarum vivarum secundum genus, et volatilia volantia sub firmamento coeli secundum genus. Cur igitur ex elemento maris, avibus quoque nativitatem tribuit? Quia velut affinitas quædam volucribus habetur et piscibus. Sicut enim pisces aquam secant motibus alarum in priora tendentes, caulæ vero gubernaculo flexus dirigunt proprios, ita et aves aerem pennis creduntur natando perrumpere. Ergo quoniam una proprietas in genere utroque natandi est, e eadem illis etiam suppetit ex aqua cognatio. Quorum hæc differentia est, quia nullus alitum sine pedibus esse potest, ut pote qui pastum consequuntur e terra, et ob hoc necessario pedum potiuntur obsequio. Raptoribus autem etiam unguium acies, ad convectandas prædas accommodata est. Nam cæteris tam propter alimoniae quæstum, quam propter aliam vitæ dispensatinem pedum ministeria sunt tributa. Paucæ vero avium pedes inutiles habent, neque gressui neque venatui opportunos, sicut hirundines, meropesque, quibus esca solo præbetur ex aere. Sed hirundo solet volare depressior, terramque pene contingere, ut per hoc usum pedum videatur explere.

"Let the earth bring forth the living soul." Why does the earth produce the living soul? So that you may learn the difference between the soul of a beast and that of a man. A little further on you will learn how the soul of man was constituted; but now hear about the soul of dumb animals: that according to Scripture the soul of every animal is its own blood. And blood when congealed usually turns into flesh, and flesh when corrupted returns to earth. Rightly, then, the soul of beasts of burden is perishable. "Let the earth bring forth the living soul." See the sequence of soul to blood, blood to flesh, flesh to earth. And again, undoing these, go back through the same steps, from earth to flesh, from flesh to blood, from blood to soul, and you will find that the soul of beasts is earth. Do not think it older than the substance of their body, nor expect it to survive when the body is dissolved. Flee the anxious chatter of the philosophers who are not ashamed to assert that their own souls and those of dogs have a like form. For they even profess that they were once women, fish, and shrubs. But if they ever were fish, which I would not believe, yet while they wrote these things they were more irrational than fish. "Let the earth bring forth the living soul." Why, while my discourse was running on freely, I suddenly fell silent for some time, I think some of those present are wondering; although I do not think the most attentive hearers are ignorant of the cause of the silence, since by glances and nods to one another they have brought us back to the memory of what we left out. For we nearly passed over undiscussed a certain part of creation, and not the least. "Let the waters bring forth creeping things with living souls according to their kind, and flying things flying under the firmament of heaven." We spoke above about swimming creatures, as far as the evening time allowed; today we are passing to the examination of land animals. But meanwhile, in the middle of our account, the birds escaped us. So we must imitate forgetful travellers who, when they have left something precious at an inn, go back, though they have covered the greatest part of the road, bearing the labour their negligence deserves; so we too must return by the same path by which we came. For what we left out is not contemptible, being the third portion of the animal creation. For there are three kinds of animals: of land, of air, and of sea. "Let the waters," it says, "bring forth creeping things with living souls according to their kind, and flying things flying under the firmament of heaven according to their kind." Why, then, did he give birth to the birds too from the element of the sea? Because there is a kind of kinship between birds and fish. For as fish cut the water with the motions of their fins, pressing forward, and direct their turns with the rudder of the tail, so birds are believed to break through the air with their wings as if swimming. Since, then, both kinds have the one property of swimming, the same kinship from the water belongs to them. Their difference is this: no bird can be without feet, since they get their food from the earth and so necessarily enjoy the service of feet. To the birds of prey sharp claws are also given, suited for carrying off their prey; to the others the service of feet is given both for seeking food and for the rest of the management of life. A few birds have useless feet, suited neither for walking nor for hunting, like swallows and bee-eaters, whose food is supplied only from the air. But the swallow usually flies low and almost touches the ground, so that by this it seems to make up for the use of feet.

Gen 1:24 (quotation, high confidence) · Lev 17:11 (allusion, high confidence) · Deut 12:23 (allusion, high confidence) · Gen 1:20 (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The soul of animals is their blood and returns to earth, unlike man's; against transmigration, and returning to the omitted birds, which share with fish the motion of swimming.

  • 'The soul of every animal is its blood': Lev 17:11, 14; Deut 12:23. The philosophers who claim to have been fish and shrubs are Empedocles and the Pythagoreans (transmigration); the Latin 'they were once women, fish and shrubs' corresponds to Empedocles' line 'I was once a boy, a girl, a bush, a bird, a fish' (frag. 117), quoted by Basil.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): consequenliam animac → consequentiam animæ; caruis ad terram → carnis ad terram; canumqae → canumque; animam vivant → animam vivam; intermisinus → intermisimus; Ejiciant equæ → Ejiciant aquæ; vesperti.um → vespertinum; coufecerint → confecerint; alaruni → alarum; potiunlur → potiuntur; Pauce vero → Paucæ vero.

Extrabiblical texts: Empedocles, frag. 117 (Empedocles (fragments); allusion)

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.2 (PL 53:946c; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-2). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-2) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.3PL 53:948a

Sunt sane multa genera quæ, si quis eo modo voluerit explicare quo nos piscium multitudinem pro parte descripsimus, inveniet unum quidem avium cunctarum generate vocabulum, sed plurimas in bis differentias, vel habitus, vel magnitudinis, vel colorise Nam et morum, et actuum, et victus nimia diversitate distinctæ sunt. Quidam autem affectaverunt nominibus circa eas uti variis, ut tanquam per inusitata sigilla novæ inauditæque nuncupationis proprietas in singulis volucrum generibus agnoscatur. Sed nobis sufficiens est significatio, ad qualitatem cujusque generis contemplandam, ususque communis Scriptune, quæ mundas irnmundasque discernit. Aliud enim est genus earum quae carne vescuntur, aliaque forma, suis congruens moribus: habent enim falcatos ungues, obuncum rostrum, volatum pernicem, quo præda citius capiatur, discerptaque pedibus, facilem cibum sugg<*ral capto.-i. Alia species est earum quæ seminibus nutriuntur, et alia earum qw pro alimonia percipiunt quidquid casus obtulent. Et in his rursus maxima differentia est. Quædam enim sunt gregales, exceptis prædatricibus: quarum nulla cum aliis preter coitum sociatur. Aliæ sunt communiter viventes, sicut columbae, sturni, grues, et graculi: ex quibus quædam sine ducibus habentur, semetipsas regentes, aliæ sub moderamine continentur, ut grues. Est etiam in eis alia discretio, secundun. quam certas videras advenas esse, alias indigenas. Nonnullas hieme compellente, causa pastus, ad peregrina discedere. Plurimas mansuetas fieri, et patientes: exceptis infirmioribus, quæ propter nimiam timiditatem, contrectationem manus nequeunt tolerarc. Aliae inter homines diversantur, iisdem quibus illi domiciliis commanentes, aliæ lucis desertis ut montibus delectantur. Est etiam avibus magna differentia vocum, et sua cuique proprietas. Sunt enim quædam loquaces et garrulæ, aliæ taciturnæ: nonnullæ canone atque clamosx, certæ stridulæ, nullumque penitus habentes cantum. Aliæ naturaliter æmulatrices sunt, vel ex hominum traditionibus eruditæ. Aliæ unicum, nunquamque mutabilem sonum vocis habent. Lascivus est gallus, diligens pavo, libidinosa columba, domesticaque gallina. Dolosus et zelotypus perdix; interdumque venantibus hominibus, ad alioram captum malitiose consentiens; et omnino multiplex in illis actuum morumque discretio est.

There are indeed many kinds. If anyone wished to describe them in the way we partly described the multitude of fish, he would find one general name for all birds, but very many differences among them in form, size, or colour. For they are distinguished by a very great diversity of habits, activities, and food. Some have chosen to use various names for them, so that by unusual marks of new and unheard-of naming the property of each kind of bird might be recognized. But for us the meaning is sufficient for contemplating the quality of each kind, together with the common usage of Scripture, which distinguishes clean and unclean. For one kind is that of those that eat flesh, with a form suited to their habits: they have curved claws, a hooked beak, and swift flight, so that the prey may be caught more quickly and, torn by their feet, provide easy food to the captor. Another species is that of those that feed on seeds, and another of those that take for food whatever chance offers. And among these again there is a very great difference. For some are gregarious, the birds of prey excepted, none of which associates with others except for mating. Others live in common, like doves, starlings, cranes, and jackdaws; of these some have no leaders and govern themselves, others are held under direction, like cranes. There is also another distinction among them, by which you may see some to be migrants and others natives. Some, compelled by winter, depart abroad for the sake of food. Very many become tame and patient, except the weaker ones, which because of their excessive timidity cannot bear the handling of a hand. Some live among human beings, dwelling in the same houses with them; others delight in lonely places, like mountains. There is also among birds a great difference of voices, and each has its own property. For some are talkative and chattering, others silent; some tuneful and loud, others shrill, with no song at all. Some are naturally imitators or are trained by human teaching. Others have a single, never-changing sound of voice. The cock is wanton, the peacock attentive, the dove lustful, as is the domestic hen. The partridge is crafty and jealous, and sometimes maliciously helps hunters in the capture of others. And in general there is a manifold distinction of activities and habits among them.

Lev 11:13–19 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Birds differ in form, food, social life, migration, tameness and voice, and Scripture classes them as clean and unclean.

  • Clean and unclean birds: Lev 11:13–19; Deut 14:11–20.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): eo mouo voluerit → eo modo voluerit; pi cium → piscium; signiflcatio → significatio; obuacu:n rostrum, volatom → obuncum rostrum, volatum; timilitatem → timiditatem; colnmanentes → commanentes; proprictas. Sunt cnim qu;rdam loquaccs → proprietas. Sunt enim quædam loquaces; venanlibus → venantibus.

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.3 (PL 53:948a; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-3). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-3) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.4PL 53:949a

Sunt et certa animalia urbana, si tamen urbali tatis est ad unum communemque finem, operatio- a in perducere singulorum: sicut in apibus est videre, quibus communis habitatio est, et volatus, et unus labor omnibus, et quod maximum est, sub regibus et ducibus unaquaeque proprium munus exercet. Nec prius audent campos patentes appetere, quam suum principem viderint volasse. Rex autem apud eas non constituitur a populo, nam sæpe suffragia multitudinis imperite solent indignos ad culmen imperiale provehere, nec regnum sorte præstatur. Sunt enim irrationabiles exitus urnæ, quippe qure sæpius infimo cuique potestatum decernit insiia. Sed nec ex parentum hæreditate imperialia sceptra traduntur, quoniam principum liberi per voluptates et delicias facile corrumpuntur, et vecordes efficiuntur ac stulti. Sed naturae judicio, qui dignus fuerit, infulas a accipit principatus, non minus pro- ceritate membrorum quam lenitate morum caeteris præstans, et babet spicula quædam, sed his ad læsionem non utitur aliorum. Ita leges quasdam tacitus eis natura praescripsit, quibus retinentur ad inferenda tormenta supplicibus. Ipsre vero apes si secutæ non fuerint instituta regnantium, propria pœnitudine castigantur. Nam si pupugerint aliquem, dimittunt animam cum aculeo simul in vulnere. Audiant hæc Christiani, quibus mandatum est, nulli malum pro malo reponere, sed in bonitate superare malitiam. Quamobrem imitamini mores apium: quæ nulli n:olestiam facientes, nec aliena patrimonia rapientes, fingunt quidem favos constructos ex floribus, mel autem de humore roscido, qui arborum foliis insidet, ore collectum in cereis recondunt cellis.Nam denique liquidius habetur mel, quod primo percipitur, deinde paulatim tempore procedente digestum, ad suam spissitudinem suavitatemque revertitur. Non immerito ergo tantarum laudum apes gloriam consequun- tur: utpete quas laboriosas et sapientes vocitavit antiquitas. Ita studiose victum proprium reponentes, quarum usus, tam regibus quam privatis remedia salutis impertit. Et sic, quia sic sapienter horrea mellis ædificant. In tenera enim membrana crebras thecas, sibique contiguas exstruunt: ut earum condensatio tenuissimæ textu compaginationis arctata, et fulta velut quibusdam repogulis opus omne contineat. Unumquodque vero spiramen mutuo strictum nexu sustentatur ab alio, et subtilissima forulorum interseptione discluditur: qui binis aut ternis super- se sunt ordinati tegminibus. Neque enim directas vel simplices cavernarum profunditates efficere maluei unt, ne sui pondere stipatus humor manaret ex- Irinsecus. Disce quomodo geometriæ affectatio. sa- pientissimis apibus comparata postponitur. Sex enim angulis totidemque lateribus, cerarum fistulæ continentur, nec tamen erectæ sunt, ne fundus videlicet laboraret, si juncturarum vacuus foret auxilio. Sed i: feriores illi sex anguli, sedes et firmamentum quoddam superjectis habentur: quo e tolerabiliter pondus superpositum subvectarent, humoremque rcconditum in cavationibus singulis conservarent.

There are also certain civic animals, if indeed it belongs to civic life to bring the work of individuals to one common end, as can be seen in bees. They have a common dwelling and a common flight, one labour for all, and, what is greatest, each carries out its own task under kings and leaders. They do not dare to seek the open fields before they have seen their prince take flight. Their king is not appointed by the people, for the votes of an unskilled multitude often raise the unworthy to the summit of rule; nor is the kingship granted by lot, for the outcomes of the urn are irrational and often award the insignia of power to the lowest; nor are the royal sceptres handed down by inheritance from parents, since the children of princes are easily corrupted by pleasures and luxuries and become senseless and foolish. Rather, by the judgment of nature, the one who is worthy receives the insignia of rule, surpassing the others no less in size of body than in gentleness of character; and he has a sting, but does not use it to harm others. So nature has silently prescribed certain laws for them, by which they are restrained from inflicting torments on suppliants. But the bees themselves, if they have not followed the ordinances of their rulers, are punished by their own repentance; for if they sting someone, they leave their life together with the sting in the wound. Let Christians hear this, who are commanded to repay no one evil for evil, but to overcome evil with goodness. Imitate, then, the ways of bees, which, troubling no one and seizing no one else's property, build their combs from flowers, and store in waxen cells the honey gathered with their mouths from the dewy moisture that settles on the leaves of trees. For the honey that is first gathered is more liquid; then, gradually, as time goes on, it is digested and returns to its own thickness and sweetness. Not undeservedly, then, do bees obtain the glory of such praises, since antiquity called them laborious and wise. So diligently do they store their own food, whose use gives remedies of health to kings and private persons alike. And so wisely do they build their storehouses of honey. For in a thin membrane they build close-set cells adjoining one another, so that their density, held together by the finest texture of joining and supported as if by certain bars, contains the whole work. Each opening, bound by a mutual tie, is supported by another and shut off by a very fine partition of compartments, which are arranged in two or three layers above one another. For they did not choose to make straight or single depths of cavities, lest the liquid, pressed by its own weight, should leak out. Learn how the pursuit of geometry is surpassed when compared with the most wise bees. For the tubes of the wax are bounded by six angles and as many sides, and yet they are not set straight on one another, lest the bottom should be strained if it lacked the help of joints; but those six lower angles serve as a seat and a kind of support for those placed above, so that they may bear the weight above them tolerably and preserve the liquid stored in each cavity.

Rom 12:17 (allusion, high confidence) · Rom 12:21 (allusion, high confidence) · Prov 6:8 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Bees live as a commonwealth under a king chosen by nature, who has a sting but does not use it, a lesson in not repaying evil; their honeycomb surpasses geometry.

  • 'Repay no one evil for evil, but overcome evil with good': Rom 12:17, 21. 'Laborious and wise' alludes to Prov 6:8 LXX (the added praise of the bee).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): sub rcgibus et ducibus unaquaeque proprium munus excrtt → sub regibus et ducibus unaquaeque proprium munus exercet; snffragia → suffragia; vecordes rofficiuntur → vecordes efficiuntur; tacitns → tacitus; dimittuat aniam → dimittunt animam; finguat quidem → fingunt quidem; Non homerito → Non immerito; apbus comparata → apibus comparata; tolcrabiliter → tolerabiliter.

Topics: Ethics

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.4 (PL 53:949a; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-4). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-4) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.5PL 53:950b

Quis igitur volatilium valeat diligenter cunctas proprietates exponere? Vel quemadmodum grues excubias vicissim noctu suscipiunt, quarum aliis corpora sopore curantibus, nonnullæ tuitionem illis perhibent vigilando. Quae cum statutum sibi tempus excubandi peregerint, ipsae quidem clamore dato, quiescere incipiunt, aliæ vero sorte succe- dunt. Hunc autem ordinem et in volatu custodiunt, dum diversis vicibus operam ductandi coguntur explere. Ciconiæ sane non procul distant ab his, quibus rationabilis collata prudentia est. Nam uno tempore simul omnes adveniunt, itemque sub uno signo cunctæ pariter ad longinqua discedunt. Suffragantur autem eis cornices, quas et proficiscentes. honorifice prosequuntur, et sicut mihi videtur auxilium praestant illis, adversus quasdam volucres pugnaturis. Cujus rei certum est documentum: primum quidem, quia cornix eo tempore penitus non videtur: deinde quod sauciæ redeuntes, manifestissima præliorum signa demonstrant. Quis, rogo, illis hospitalitatis jura mandavit? Aut quis sub comminatione præcepit ut ciconias in procinctu positas suo non destituerent comitatu? Audiant hæc avari homines, qui negata peregrinus adventantibus humanitate, januas suas claudunt, et nec tectis eos succedere noctis aut biemis tempore patiuntur. Liberalitas vero quæ senibus ciconiis a junioribus exhibetur sufficeret hominum filios, si mallent advertere, amatores suorum reddere genitoruin. Quis enim tam insipiens est, ut non se a censeat ignominia notari, cum avibus irrationabilibus cultu postponitur pietatis? Illæ parentes suos ætate confectos pennisque eorum vetustate dejectis, circumstantes, propriis plumis fovent, alimoniamque convectant, et in volatu quod potuerint, binc inde se supponentes, senectæ lassitudinem consolantur, alarum suarum eas auxilio sustentantes. Quae res per omnes ubique gentes ita percrebuit, ut hodie remuneratio delati beneficii apud Græcos άντιπελάργωσις nominetur. Quapropter nemo se penitus obtentu paupertatis excusans, de vita propria desperet, quamvis nullæ domi suppeditent facultates, dum ingeniosam contemplatur hirundinem. Illa enim in fabricando nido paleas quidem ore comportat, limum autem pedibus ferre non valens, alarum summitates humectat in fluvio, deinde in cinere volutata, cæmenti usum videtur explere. Paulatimque surculos inter se luto apposito, velut quadam glute conjungens, suos educat pullos. Quorum si quispiam oculos effoderit, habet eorum mater a natura sibi traditam medicinam, qua mox ad sanitatem fetuum suorum reducat aspectum. Hæc te videlicet hortabuntur, ne ad improbitatem velis egestatis occasione converti, ncc in pessimis artibus spem vivendi collocans, immunis bonitatis exsorsque reddaris, sed ad Deum confugias: qui cum hirundini tam magna donaverit, quanto majora præstabit his qui eum tota mentis intentione implorant? Alcyon avicula est quædam in littoribus marinis fetare consueta, quæ super ipsam arenam ponit ova, eo tempore quo mare multis gravibusque ventorum flatibus. ommovetur: sed tamen omnes tunc tempestates procellæque sedantur per integros septem dies, quibus avis memorata cubare narratur: nutriendorumque gratia pullorum, postquam fuerunt de ovis educti, septem dies alios illi Deus magnorum largitor adjecit, quos dies nautici diligentius observantes, alcyonios eos vocant. Hæc tibi præscripta sunt, super remediis indubitanter a Deo salutaribus deprecandis. Quid enim non mirabile fiat tui causa, qui ad imaginem Dei factus es, cum propter avem parvulam maximum formidolosumque mare videas tempestuoso tempore fieri tranquillum, divina præceptione ire- natum?

Who, then, could carefully set forth all the properties of birds? Or how cranes take turns keeping watch at night: while some of them refresh their bodies with sleep, others protect them by keeping awake; and when these have completed their appointed time of watch, they give a cry and begin to rest, while others succeed by lot. They keep this order in flight too, being obliged in turns to fulfil the task of leading. Storks are not far from these, endowed with a reasonable prudence. For they all arrive at one time, and likewise at one signal all depart together to distant lands. Crows accompany them, escorting them honourably as they set out, and, as it seems to me, giving them help when they are about to fight against certain birds. Of this there is sure proof: first, that the crow is not seen at all at that time; then, that they return wounded, showing very plain signs of battles. Who, I ask, commanded them the laws of hospitality? Or who ordered them under threat not to abandon the storks with their company when they were ready for the march? Let greedy men hear this, who deny kindness to strangers who arrive, shut their doors, and do not allow them to come under their roofs at night or in winter. And the generosity shown to old storks by the young would be enough to make the children of men lovers of their parents, if they chose to notice it. For who is so foolish as not to think himself branded with disgrace when he is ranked below irrational birds in the practice of filial piety? They stand around their parents, worn out with age, whose feathers have fallen out from age, and warm them with their own plumage, bring them food, and in flight, as far as they can, put themselves beneath them on this side and that, relieving the weariness of old age by supporting them with their wings. This has become so widely known among all nations everywhere that today the repayment of a kindness received is called among the Greeks antipelargosis. Therefore let no one, excusing himself on the pretext of poverty, despair of his own life, even if he has no means at home, when he contemplates the ingenious swallow. In building its nest it carries straw in its mouth, but being unable to carry mud with its feet, it wets the tips of its wings in a river, and then, rolling in dust, seems to supply the use of mortar. Little by little, joining twigs to one another with mud placed between, as if with glue, it rears its chicks. If anyone gouges out their eyes, their mother has a medicine handed down to her by nature, by which she soon restores the sight of her young to health. These things will urge you not to turn to wickedness on the occasion of want, nor, placing your hope of living in the worst arts, to become empty of goodness and without share in it; but to flee to God, who, since he has given such great things to the swallow, how much greater things will he give to those who implore him with the whole intention of their mind? The halcyon is a small bird accustomed to breed on the sea shores; it lays its eggs on the very sand at the time when the sea is stirred by many heavy blasts of wind; yet all storms and tempests are then calmed for seven whole days, during which this bird is said to sit; and for the rearing of the chicks, after they have come out of the eggs, God, the giver of great things, added another seven days, which sailors observe carefully and call halcyon days. These things are prescribed for you, so that you may pray to God without doubting for saving remedies. For what wonderful thing would not be done for your sake, who were made in the image of God, when you see the greatest and most fearful sea, for the sake of a tiny bird, made calm in stormy weather, bridled by divine command?

Gen 1:27 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 6:26 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Cranes keeping watch, storks caring for their aged parents, the resourceful swallow and the halcyon whose brooding calms the sea teach vigilance, hospitality, filial piety, and trust in God.

  • 'Antipelargosis' (ἀντιπελάργωσις, 'counter-storking', repaying kindness) is given in Greek letters. 'Made in the image of God' alludes to Gen 1:27.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): non vidctur → non videtur; humanitale → humanitate; Liberalilas → Liberalitas; a censcat → a censeat; cullu postponitur → cultu postponitur; benclicii → beneficii; birundinom → hirundinem; ad Deum coafugias → ad Deum confugias; largilor → largitor; atcyonios → alcyonios; maxiinum → maximum.

Topics: Ethics

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.5 (PL 53:950b; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-5). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-5) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.6PL 53:951d

Turturem ferunt si quando casu aliquo separetur a conjuge, nullatenus coire cum altero, sed memoria prioris connubii perdurante, contractum secundæ copulationis abnuere. Audiant mulieres quomodo apud aves irrationabiles continentia viduitatis frequentibus nuptiis antefertur. Aquila in educandis pullis propriis injusta fertur esse. Duobus enim procreatis, unum verberibus alarum mulctatus' projicit in terram, alterum retentatum fovet. Ita propter victus inopiam cogitur negare quem genuit, nec tamen eum sinit interire ossifragus, sed assumptum propriis applicat pullis, et studiose nutrit. Tales sunt nonnulli parentes hominum, qui paupertatem causati suos exponunt liberos, vel hæreditatis sortem, non æquam constituunt inter eos. Quibus quoniam pares causas præstitere nascendi, justum esset ut his vivendi etiam parem tribuerent portionem. Ne velis ergo prædatricum avium mores æmulari, quæ cum viderint pullos suos jam volatui e confidentes, de nidis eos præcipites exturbant atque projiciunt, nullam penitus illis curam deinceps impendentes. Laudatur e contra circa natos cornicis affectio, quos et volantes prosequitur, et escam largiter subministrat. Certæ vero volucres, ad nutriendos fovendosque fetus, masculorum juvamine non utuntur. A!i;c sane earum quæ altius volitant steriles ommino sunt, sicut vultu- res, quos asserunt sine coitu generare, præcipue cum sint longævi. Nam vitain eorum centum annis manere affirmant. Sit igitur hæc tibi pars historiæ notata de avibus, ut cum videris aliquos cachinnantes, propter ineffabile mysterium catholicae Me!, quod quasi impossibile sit, alienumque naturæ virgi. nem peperisse, statu virginitatis integro custodito, cogites quia ille qui dignatus est in stultitia prædicationis salvare credentes, idem quoque nobis innumerabiles causas ex natura sumptas ad fidelitatem mirabilium præstitit.

They say that the turtledove, if it is ever separated from its mate by some mishap, never unites with another, but, the memory of its first marriage remaining, refuses the contract of a second union. Let women hear how among irrational birds the continence of widowhood is preferred to repeated marriages. The eagle is said to be unjust in rearing its own young. For when it has hatched two, it beats one with blows of its wings and throws it to the ground, and keeps and cherishes the other. So, because of scarcity of food, it is compelled to disown the one it begot. Yet the bone-breaker does not let it perish, but takes it up, adds it to its own chicks, and nourishes it carefully. Such are some human parents, who on the pretext of poverty expose their children, or do not set an equal share of inheritance among them. Since they gave them equal causes of being born, it would be just for them to give them also an equal portion for living. Do not, then, imitate the ways of birds of prey, which, when they see their chicks now confident in flight, drive them headlong out of the nests and throw them out, bestowing no further care at all on them. On the other hand, the affection of the crow for its young is praised: it follows them when they fly and supplies food generously. Certain birds do not use the help of males in rearing and cherishing their young. Some of those that fly higher are altogether without intercourse, like vultures, which they say generate without mating, especially since they are long-lived; for they affirm that their life lasts a hundred years. Let this part of the history of birds, then, be noted by you, so that when you see some people laughing at the ineffable mystery of the catholic faith, as if it were impossible and contrary to nature for a virgin to give birth while her virginity was kept intact, you may consider that he who deigned to save those who believe through the foolishness of preaching has also provided us with countless reasons drawn from nature for faith in wonders.

1 Cor 1:21 (quotation, high confidence) · Isa 7:14 (allusion, medium confidence) · Matt 1:23 (allusion, medium confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The faithful turtledove commends widowhood over remarriage; the eagle's neglect rebukes parents who expose or disinherit children; vultures said to breed without mating make the virgin birth credible.

  • The praise of the widowed turtledove that refuses a second union is addressed to widows and is translated as written. The exposure of children was practised in antiquity. 'Through the foolishness of preaching': 1 Cor 1:21. 'Fidei' (faith) is read for the garbled 'Me!' of the digital text (uncertain).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): cum allero → cum altero; viduitatis f. equentibus → viduitatis frequentibus; proceatis → procreatis; retentalum → retentatum; caasat! suos exponunt libero, vel hærelitatis → causati suos exponunt liberos, vel hæreditatis; inter cos → inter eos; prætstere → præstitere; de uidis → de nidis; largitcr → largiter; Cfrtæ vero → Certæ vero; cachinuantes → cachinnantes.

Topics: Marriage, Divorce and remarriage, Christology, Ethics

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.6 (PL 53:951d; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-6). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-6) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.7PL 53:952a

Ejiciant aquæ reptilia vivarum animarum, et volatilia volantia super terram sub firmamento cæli. Volare ideo jussæ sunt super terram, quia victus omnibus e terra suppeditat. Sub firmamento autem cœli dixit, propter illa quæ supra disseruimus. Cœlum aute hic intelligere debemus, a cernendo dictum: Graece enim ρανός vocatur πό οὺ ςὰσθαι.Nam comparatione corporis ætherei, aer ite, qui super nos est, ex vaporibus terræ concretus et crassus efficitur. Habes igitur polum decoratum, terram formosissimam, mare opulentissimum, aerem repletum avibus: quæ omnia ex nihilo ad hanc vitam Dei præceptione producta sunt. Et alia multa quæ nunc consulto sermo præteriit, ne in hisdem diutius commoratus, modum disputandi videretur excedere. Tu autem cuncta hæc tecum ipse reputans, et intente sapientiam Dei, quæ in omnibus habetur, inquirens, nunquam a delicias admirando, nec Conditorem glorificando desistas. Habes etiam volatilia nocturna et diurna. Vespertiliones enim et noctuæ lucifugæ sunt. Ergo si quando te minime sopor oppresserit, sufficiet te conversationis eorum examinatio, vitæque proprictas ad prædicandam sapientiam Creatoris impellere, quomodo luscinia vigilat ovis incubans omni tempore noctis cantilenam trahendo, quomodo etiam vespertiliones non minus quadrupedes sunt quam pennatæ, quas etiam solas ex avibus omnibus dentes habere conslat; et catulos procreare feruntur; aut in aere non plumis, sed quadam membrana pellita volare. Est etiam illis mutua inter se magnaque dilectio per naturam. Nam velut setæ quædam piscatoriae de alternis hærent nexibus: quod in hominibus utique videmus non facile provenire, quorum nonnulli separati ah aliorum conversationibus singularitate et solitudine delectantur. Quomodo etiam noctuarum oculis similes habentur sæcularis sapientiæ professores. Nam et illarum aspectus noctibus quidem acrior est, exorto autem sole cæcatur, sicut istorum cum sit acutissimus ad contemplandam vanitatem sensus, erga inquisitionem veræ lucis hebescit. Interdiu autem facile tibi est admirationem Conditoris undique attrahere; quemadmodum gallus domesticus homines ad labores compellit et opera, claraque voce proclamans, solem procul advenire significat. Anserum quoque genus, quam vigilans habetur et providum, ct cito sentiens quæ tentantur occulte! Ii quondam urbem Romam nocturnis hostium liberasse dicuntur insidiis: quos per occultos aditus latenter ingredi molientes arcemque pervadere, festinanter prodidere clama; do. In quo autem genere propria miracula non usquequaque natura demonstrat? Quis vulturibus futuram nuntiat hominum mortem, quos contra se ella gesturos, mox catervæ vulturum proscquuntur, armorumque instructione vel apparatu, qualis sit exitus habendus intelligunt? Quod quidem non procul est rationis humanæ. Quemadmodum etiam tibi locustarum expeditiones aperiam? Quæ sub uno signo I ropriis egressae de sedibus in spatioso campo castra constituunt, et non ante subjecta contingunt, quani datur eis divina præceptio. Quomodo etiam mergus insatiabilem vescendi patitur orexim, per quam vulueribus sui ventris remedia sanitatis acquirit. 0 virtutis admiratio cœlestis! quæ rabiem famis in usum medicaminis reformavit. Quanta quoque ratio est in cantibus cicadarum, quæ sub ardenti sole plus resonant tractu acris impulsae, qui per earum pectus illabitur dum respirant? Sed jam sentio sermonem nostruni noa minus miraculis volatilium superari, quam si experirer ipse pernicitatem suam meis pedibus antcire. Sane cum videris apes et vespas, considcra quia nullus eis spiritus aut pulmo subest, sed semper ex aere nutriuntur. Denique si oleo tactæ fuerint, continuo perimuntur, utpote præclusis carum spira mentis: et si aceto « rursus illas aspereris, reviviscunt, venarum videlicet meatibus patefactis. Ita nihil quod supersit, aut desit nostris utilitatibus, fecit Deus. Iterum si aquariorum genus examinare volucris, invenies in illis aliam dispositionem. Pcles enim non habent fissos ut corvus, nec uncos ut aquila, sed latos atque membraneos, ut natantes facile supererantur undis, tanquam remis quibusdam pedum nisibus repellentes aquam. Item si consideres quomodo cycnus in altum guttur extendens, ab imo fundo trahit alimoniam, tunc advertere poteris sapientiam Creatoris, qui ob hoc illi longiora colla quam pedes adhibuit, ut tanquam setam quamdam porrigens se in profundum, reconditum possit invenire nutrimen.

"Let the waters bring forth creeping things with living souls, and flying things flying above the earth under the firmament of heaven." They were commanded to fly above the earth because food for all comes from the earth. He said "under the firmament of heaven" because of what we discussed above. "Heaven" we must understand here as named from "seeing": for in Greek it is called ouranos, from horasthai. For in comparison with the ethereal body, this air above us is made condensed and thick from the vapours of the earth. You have, then, the sky adorned, the earth most beautiful, the sea most rich, the air filled with birds: all of which were brought from nothing into this life by God's command. And there are many other things that the discourse has now deliberately passed over, lest by lingering longer on the same things it seem to exceed the measure of discussion. But you, reckoning all these things over with yourself and searching intently for the wisdom of God that is in all things, never cease from wondering at his delights and glorifying the Creator. You have also birds of night and of day. Bats and owls shun the light. So if ever sleep does not overcome you, the examination of their way of life and the property of their living will suffice to move you to proclaim the wisdom of the Creator: how the nightingale keeps watch as it sits on its eggs, drawing out its song all night long; how bats are no less four-footed than winged, the only ones of all birds known to have teeth; they are said to bear live young, and to fly in the air not with feathers but with a kind of skinny membrane. They also have by nature a great mutual love for one another; for like a fisherman's chain they cling to one another in links, something we see does not easily happen among human beings, some of whom, separated from the company of others, delight in singularity and solitude. How too the professors of worldly wisdom are like the eyes of owls: for their sight is keener at night but is blinded when the sun has risen, just as these men's sense, though very sharp for contemplating vanity, is dull for the search of the true light. By day it is easy for you to draw wonder at the Creator from every side: how the domestic cock drives men to their labours and works, and, crying out with a clear voice, announces the sun coming from afar. And how watchful and provident the race of geese is, and how quick to sense secret attempts! They are said once to have saved the city of Rome from the night ambush of enemies who were trying to enter secretly by hidden approaches and to seize the citadel; the geese quickly betrayed them by their cackling. In what kind does nature not show its own wonders everywhere? Who announces to vultures the coming death of men? When men are about to wage war against one another, flocks of vultures at once follow them, and from the array and equipment of the arms they understand what outcome there will be. This is not far from human reasoning. How shall I tell you of the expeditions of locusts? At one signal they go out from their own homes and pitch camp in a broad plain, and do not touch what lies below them until the divine command is given them. How too the cormorant suffers an insatiable appetite for eating, by which it gains a remedy of health for the wounds of its belly. O wonder of heavenly power, which has turned the madness of hunger into the use of medicine! And how much reason there is in the songs of cicadas, which sound more loudly under the burning sun, driven by the drawing of the air that slips through their chest as they breathe! But now I feel that our discourse is no less overcome by the wonders of birds than if I tried to outrun their swiftness with my own feet. When you see bees and wasps, consider that they have no breath or lung, but are always nourished from the air. If they are touched with oil, they die at once, since their breathing passages are closed; and if you sprinkle them again with vinegar, they revive, the passages of their veins being opened. So God has made nothing superfluous and nothing lacking for our benefit. Again, if you wish to examine the kind of water birds, you will find another arrangement in them. For they do not have split feet like the raven, nor hooked ones like the eagle, but broad and webbed, so that they may easily float on the waves, pushing back the water with the strokes of their feet as with oars. And if you consider how the swan, stretching its throat on high, draws its food from the very bottom, you will be able to notice the wisdom of the Creator, who gave it a neck longer than its feet for this reason, so that, reaching down into the deep as if letting down a line, it may find the food hidden there.

Gen 1:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Prov 30:27 (echo, low confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: Birds of night and day, bats, owls, cocks, geese, vultures, locusts, bees and water birds each show the Creator's wisdom; owls picture worldly sages blind to the true light.

  • Gen 1:20. The etymology of ouranos is in Greek letters (garbled) in the Latin. The geese of the Capitol: Livy 5.47. The locusts' marching without a king echoes Prov 30:27.

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR; OCR (reading uncertain)): et rolatilia → et volatilia; Sub frmamento autem cœi → Sub firmamento autem cœli; terram furmosissimam → terram formosissimam; Dei freceptione → Dei præceptione; nuquam a deiicias → nunquam a delicias; Conditiorem → Conditorem; Lrgo si → Ergo si; sapienliam → sapientiam; inquisilionem → inquisitionem; non procui est ralionis → non procul est rationis; fecit Dcu:. → fecit Deus.; inveuics → invenies.

Extrabiblical texts: Livy, 5.47 (Livy, History of Rome; allusion)

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.7 (PL 53:952a; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-7). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-7) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.

8.8PL 53:954b

Igitur simpliciter inspecta verba Scripturæ syllabæ quædam videntur esse: Ejiciant aquæ volatilia volantia super terram sub firmamento cæli. Si considerata fuerit vis verborum, tunc Conditoris mirificatio declaratur, qui futuras avium differentias longe prævidit, easque secundum genus a se discrevit. Dies me profecto deficiet, si cuncta vobis aeria miracula referre voluero. Verumtamen terra nos vocat ad inspiciendas bestias, et pecudes ac serpentes. Parata est enim similia piscibus et volatilibus quadrupedum et virgultorum genera demonstrare: Ejiciat terra animam vivam. Quid dicitis, qui Paulo apostolo de resurrectione non creditis, cum videatis certa de aereis animantibus figuram propriam commutare, sicut Indiacum vermem, qui est corniger, primo in i verucæ se speciem transformantem, deinde fieri bombulionem, nec tamen in eo schemate persistentem, sed membranis mollioribus i ac latioribus plumescentem aligerum reddi? Itaque vos, matronæ, quando sedetis eorum revolventes opera, id est stamina quæ Seres huc dirigunt ad confectionem vestium delicatarum. reminiscimini hujus animalis refigurationem, ut evi- ceus de resurrectione capiatis exemplum, eL nihil dubitetis de reformatione corporis, quam Paulus exponit. Sed jam sentio me modum disputationis excedere. Etenim si al multitudinem respexero relatorum, ia infinitum videbor sermone a prolapsus. Sin autem oculos ad diversitatem creaturæ convertero, nec exordium narrationis arbitror assumpsisse. Verumtamen non est utile vos praeterire transcursu. Quid enim facietis usque ad vesperam? A pransoribus certe non urgemini, nec conviviorum apparatus abire vos admonet, quoniam tempus jejunandi est. Quapropter si placet, abstinentiam corporis in voluptates animi convertamus. Sæpius utique corporibus paruist s, hos saltem dies deputemus usibus animorum, sicut scriptum est: Delectare in Domino, et da- bit tibi petitiones cordis tui (Psul. XXXVI, 4). Si divitias amas, opes tibi præsto sunt spirituales id est, judicia Dei vera, justificata in semetipsa, desiderabilia super aurum et lapidem pretiosum (Psal. XVIII, 10). Si edax et gulosus es, habes verba Domini dulciora super mel et favum (Ibid.). Nunc si dimisero vos cœtumque dissolvero, alii mox vestrum currunt properanter a! aleam, in qua juratio et contentio vehemens, et lucrandi cupiditas habetur, astatque dæmon obscenus. modo hunc erigens exsultatione victoriæ, faciensque adversarium tristem, modo illum alacrem superbumque demonstrans. Quid juvat corpore jejunare, si animus multis pravitatum millibus oneratur? Porro qui non ludit tesseris, sed vacat, quas non vanitates ex ore depromit, aut quid non percipit auribus exsecrandum? Ita otiositas sine timore Dei magistra nequitiæ est. Et quidem præsumo aliquid vobis utilitatis ex his quae locuti sumus acquiri. Quod si secus fuerit, lamen peccato vos vacuos commoratio loci hujuscemodi perficiet. Quantoque plus vos in Ecclesia Domini retentamus, tanto magis a malorum cogitationibus separamus. Sufficientia sunt quæ disseruimus apud aequissimum cognitorem, si tamen non ad copiosas creaturæ divitias, sed ad parvitatem no- stræ possibilitatis aspexerit, vel ad mensuram super lætitia capienda præsentium. Sit itaque terminus lic matutini convivii, ne ultra modum ingesta satietas fastidium vespertinæ vobis epulationis injiciat. Dominus sane, qui creaturæ suæ copiis cuncta complevit, et qui in rebus omnibus mirabilium suorum nobis æterna monimenta præbuit, cumulet mentes nostras gaudio spiritali in Christo Jcsu, cui gloria et honor nunc et semper, et in sæcula sæculorum. Amen.

Looked at simply, the words of Scripture seem to be a few syllables: "Let the waters bring forth flying things flying above the earth under the firmament of heaven." But if the force of the words is considered, then the wonder-working of the Creator is declared, who long foresaw the future differences of birds and distinguished them from one another according to their kind. The day would surely fail me if I tried to tell you all the wonders of the air. But the earth calls us to look at beasts, cattle, and serpents. For it is ready to show kinds of four-footed animals and plants like the fish and birds: "Let the earth bring forth the living soul." What do you say, you who do not believe the apostle Paul about the resurrection, when you see certain creatures of the air change their own shape, like the horned Indian worm, which first transforms itself into the form of a caterpillar, then becomes a cocoon, and does not stay in that shape either, but, growing feathers of softer and broader membranes, becomes winged? So you, ladies, when you sit unwinding their works, that is, the threads that the Seres send here for making delicate garments, remember the transformation of this animal, so that you may take a clear example of the resurrection, and may not doubt at all the remaking of the body that Paul expounds. But I feel that I am exceeding the measure of discussion. For if I look at the multitude of things related, I shall seem to have slipped into infinity in my speech; but if I turn my eyes to the diversity of creation, I think I have not even made the beginning of the account. Yet it is not useful to let you go in haste. For what will you do until evening? You are certainly not pressed by guests at a meal, nor does the preparation of banquets warn you to go away, since it is a time of fasting. So, if you please, let us turn the abstinence of the body into the pleasures of the soul. You have often obeyed your bodies; let us at least assign these days to the uses of the soul, as it is written: "Delight in the Lord, and he will give you the requests of your heart" (Ps 37:4). If you love riches, spiritual wealth is at hand for you, that is, "the judgments of God, true, justified in themselves, more desirable than gold and precious stone" (Ps 19:9–10). If you are a lover of good food and a glutton, you have the words of the Lord, "sweeter than honey and the honeycomb" (ibid.). Now if I dismiss you and break up the assembly, some of you at once run off in haste to the dice, where there is swearing and violent contention and the greed of gain, and a filthy demon stands by, now raising up this one with the exultation of victory and making his opponent sad, now showing that one lively and proud. What good is it to fast in body if the soul is burdened with many thousands of wickednesses? And as for one who does not play at dice but is idle, what vanities does he not bring out of his mouth, or what accursed thing does he not take in with his ears? So idleness without the fear of God is a teacher of wickedness. And indeed I presume that some benefit is gained by you from what we have said. But if not, yet staying in this place will keep you free from sin. And the longer we keep you in the Lord's church, the more we separate you from thoughts of evil. What we have said is enough before the most just Judge, if he looks not at the abundant riches of creation but at the smallness of our ability, or at the measure of the gladness to be taken from present things. Let this, then, be the end of the morning feast, lest a fullness taken in beyond measure bring you disgust for the evening banquet. And may the Lord, who has filled all things with the abundance of his creation and who in all things has given us eternal monuments of his wonders, fill our minds with spiritual joy in Christ Jesus, to whom be glory and honour, now and always, and for ages of ages. Amen.

Gen 1:20 (quotation, high confidence) · Gen 1:24 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 15:35–54 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 37:4 (36:4 Vulg.) (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 19:9–10 (18:10-Ps Vulg.) (quotation, high confidence)

Notes and citation

Summary: The silkworm's transformation is a natural pledge of the resurrection; in Lent the hearers should feast their souls on God's word rather than dice and idle talk.

  • Paul on the resurrection: 1 Cor 15:35–54. The 'Seres' are the Chinese, source of silk. The fast is Lent, when Basil preached these homilies. Ps 37:4 (Vulgate 36:4); Ps 19:9–10 (Vulgate 18:10–11).

Notes on the original text

  • Digital text corrected (OCR): considcrala → considerata; acreis → aereis; aligcrum → aligerum; quæ Sercs huc → quæ Seres huc; exjonit → exponit; exccdere → excedere; videhor → videbor; abirc pos → abire vos; usihus animo! uni → usibus animorum; Si elax et gulusus → Si edax et gulosus; coctumque <!issolvero → cœtumque dissolvero; modo hunc crigens → modo hunc erigens; discrunnus → disseruimus.

Topics: Eschatology, Fasting

Cite (SBL): Eustathius, Hex. 8.8 (PL 53:954b; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis/8-8). (abbreviation not yet checked)

BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-eustathius-hexaemeron-metaphrasis-8-8) · Report an error

Translation: Translated by Claude from the Latin of the staged edition (digital text; corrections logged). No public-domain English translation exists and no FOTC volume covers this work, so each batch was re-read against the Latin.