On Humility and Obedience, and Trampling Down Pride (complete)
Pseudonymous: Printed in PL 18 under the name Novatus Catholicus (a 'sentence of Novatus'); the ascription and date are uncertain, and the monastic setting (an abbot and his brothers) points to the later 4th century or after; Migne dates it 'anno Domini incerto'. Check CPL and the date before publishing.
Latin text: PL 18 (Latin text: Migne, PL 18, digitized by Open Greek and Latin, University of Leipzig (patrologia_latina-dev), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0).
Chapter 1
1PL 18
Saecularibus aliter in Ecclesia loquimur, aliter vobis loqui debemus. Illis loquimur aliquando res quae sonum habent, et virtutem non habent, delectantur enim tamquam infirmi sonis verborum, non virtute Dei. Vos autem in nomine Christi, non in hoc delectamini; sed vultis audire salutis verbum, in quo vocati estis; et has vestes lugubres in mundo induistis exspectantes meliores apud Deum, Nostis jam et sapitis. Jam multum tempus hic habetis adversus quem vobis est colluctatio, adversarius vester non est foris, sed intus est in visceribus: et in ipsis membris nostris habemus obluctatorem. Si enim caro concupiscit adversus spiritum, et spiritus adversus carnem, ut non ea quae volumus faciamus ( Gal. v, 17 ); videtis quia intus est adversarius iste. Adversarius autem iste non vincitur nisi humilitate et charitate: quia et ipse Dominus noster Jesus Christus diabolum non vicisset, nisi humiliatus fuisset; humiliatus autem non necessitate, sed charitate. Si enim non amasset, humilis factus non fuisset. Amore nostri factus est humilis. Si ergo qui fecit coelum et terram, mare et omnia quae in eis sunt (Psalm. cxlv, 4 ), Dominus angelorum omnium, qui creavit omnia, propter nos humilis factus est; quare nos propter nosmetipsos recusamus humilitatem? Via ergo salutis non est nobis pervia, nisi humiliatis. Cum coeperis humilitatem, quaere eam propter Deum et propter ipsam congregationem sustine. Et in ipsa congregatione quamvis aequales sitis, unusquisque alterum superiorem sibi existimare debet, tametsi non sit superior. Non illud facit, nisi (??) humilitatem habuerit. Non est necessarium servis Dei aliud praemium, nisi humilitas: quia humilitas, si fuerit in homine, facit illum obedientem. Obediens vero qui fuerit, vel qui obedientiam sectatur, non hominibus obedit, sed Deo.
We speak to people of the world in the church in one way; to you we ought to speak in another. To them we sometimes speak things that have sound but not power, for, like the weak, they delight in the sounds of words, not in the power of God. But you, in the name of Christ, do not delight in this; you wish to hear the word of salvation to which you have been called, and you have put on these garments of mourning in the world, waiting for better ones with God. You already know and understand. You have already had a long time here against the one with whom you have your struggle; your adversary is not outside but inside, in your very bowels; and in our very members we have an opponent. For if the flesh lusts against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh, so that we do not do what we wish, you see that this adversary is within. But this adversary is not overcome except by humility and love; for our Lord Jesus Christ himself would not have overcome the devil had he not been humbled; and humbled not by necessity but by love. For had he not loved, he would not have been made lowly. For love of us he was made lowly. If, then, he who made heaven and earth, the sea and all that is in them, the Lord of all the angels, who created all things, was made lowly for our sake, why do we refuse humility for our own sake? So the way of salvation is not open to us unless we are humbled. When you have begun humility, seek it for God's sake, and for the sake of the community itself, bear with it. And in the community itself, though you are equals, each ought to consider the other his superior, even if he is not superior. He does not do this unless he has humility. No other reward is needed by the servants of God but humility; for humility, if it is in a man, makes him obedient. And he who is obedient, or who pursues obedience, obeys not men but God.
Gal 5:17 (quotation, high confidence) · Ps 146:6 (145:6 LXX) (quotation, high confidence) · Phil 2:3 (allusion, high confidence) · Phil 2:8 (allusion, medium confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Addressing monks, the preacher says the enemy within is overcome only by humility and love, after the example of Christ who humbled himself for love of us; humility makes one obedient to God.
- The digital text marks some uncertain characters with (??); they are read by sense here and below. The references in round brackets are Migne's and are not translated. Gal 5:17; Ps 146:6 (LXX 145:6); Phil 2:3, 8.
Topics: Christology, Ethics, Humility and pride, Monastic life
Cite (SBL): Ps.-Novatus, Humil. 1 (PL 18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/1). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/1
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ps-novatus-humilitate-1) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the original (PL 18); no public-domain English or FOTC volume, so re-read against the original.
Chapter 2
2PL 18
Sic enim Dominus ait: Qui vos audit me audit: qui me audit, (??) eum qui me misit (Luc. x, 16). Abbas Pater est, sequentes fratres Patriarchae sunt. Et quicumque est alius inter vos, qui forte bonam habet vitam, mel orem continentiam, meliores vigilias, meliorem custodiam corporis, et ipse propter imitationem Pater est. Haec ergo agite inter vos, ut primum humilitatem custodiatis, non ut hominibus humilos videamini, sed. Deo. Illa est vera humilitas, quae Deo, non hominibus, demonstratur. Nam humilitas quae hominibus monstratur, fictio est, non humilitas, quod a servis Dei omnino alienum esse debet. Non quidem arbitror, quia sint tales iti vobis; sed ne surrepat talis morbus, admoneo. Homines enim sumus, et hominibus loquimur. Idcirco primum humilitatem fratribus vestris monstrare debetis propter imitationem; ut fundata sit ipsa humilitas intus in corde secundum Deum. Cum fuerit enim humilitas fundata in corde tuo propter Deum, tunc dat illi Deus, id est fratri tuo, ut intelligat et imitetur humilitatem tuam. Nam si non fuerit humilitas fundata in corde tuo; ostendit Deus fratri tuo, quia ficta est humilitas tua. Prima ergo via salutis haec est: humilitatem tenere simplicem propter Deum, non propter hominem: non placere inde hominibus, sed placere inde Deo. Humilitatem sequatur obedientia, et obtemperetis vobis ipsis, sicut sibi obtemperant membra. Numquid cum consilio obtemperant membra, et non naturali charitate? si pes offenderit, manus (??)curit, ne totum corpus laedatur, ut cadat. Sicut ait Apostolus: Si patitur unum membrum, compatiuntur omnia membra ( I Cor. xii, 26 ). Unde ergo, nisi ex charitate? Si ergo dilexeritis vos invicem, nulla erit conturbatio. Scandala nemo patiatur;
For so the Lord says: “He who hears you hears me; he who hears me [hears] him who sent me.” The abbot is father; the brothers who follow are patriarchs. And whoever else among you perhaps has a good life, better self-control, better vigils, better guarding of the body, he too is a father because of the example he gives. Do these things among yourselves, then: first, guard humility, not so as to seem humble to men, but to God. That is true humility which is shown to God, not to men. For the humility that is shown to men is pretence, not humility, which ought to be wholly foreign to the servants of God. I do not think there are such among you; but I warn you so that such a disease may not creep in. For we are men, and we speak to men. Therefore you ought first to show humility to your brothers for their imitation, so that humility itself may be founded inwardly in the heart, according to God. For when humility has been founded in your heart for God's sake, then God grants him, that is, your brother, to understand and imitate your humility. But if humility has not been founded in your heart, God shows your brother that your humility is feigned. This, then, is the first way of salvation: to hold humility simply for God's sake, not for man's; not to please men by it, but to please God. Let obedience follow humility, and obey one another as the members obey one another. Do the members obey by deliberation, and not by natural love? If the foot stumbles, the hand runs to help, lest the whole body be hurt and fall. As the apostle says: “If one member suffers, all the members suffer with it.” From what, then, except from love? If, then, you love one another, there will be no disturbance. Let no one suffer offence,
Luke 10:16 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 Cor 12:26 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: True humility is shown to God, not paraded before men; it should be followed by obedience and mutual love, as the members of a body help each other.
- Luke 10:16; 1 Cor 12:26. The sentence runs on into the next section.
Topics: Ethics, Humility and pride, Monastic life
Cite (SBL): Ps.-Novatus, Humil. 2 (PL 18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/2). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/2
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ps-novatus-humilitate-2) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the original (PL 18); no public-domain English or FOTC volume, so re-read against the original.
Chapter 3
3PL 18
non propter sibum, non propter potum, non propter vestimentum, non propter vigilias, non propter opera, non propter coquinam, non propter ministerium. Jam cum vos invicem dilexeritis, si quis aliquid faciat, quod non debet; charitas illa non permittit ut offendatis. Habete ergo, fratres, humilitatem et obedientiam, quam sequitur pax, ut sitis filii pacis: Quia charitus, sicut a(??)t Apostolus, vinculum est perfectionis (Col. iii, 14 ). Cum quis habuerit humilitatem, Christum imitatur, qui humilis factus est propter nos. Cum quis habuerit obedientiam, Christum imitatur, qui obediens factus est usque ad mortem ( Phil. ii, 8). Cum quis habuerit charitatem, Christum imitatur: quia Deus charitas est (I Joan. v. 16). Sed prius elaborate, ut intus vitia vestra vincatis. Fiat pax primo animae et cordis cum praecepto Dei; ut adversus consuetudinem corporis atque fragilitatem duo sint victores, praeceptum Dei, et consensus tuus. Casus enim talis est, medicus, aegrotus et aegritudo. Si iste aegrotus se cum aegritudine dederit, vincitur medicus, efficiuntur duo adversus unum, atque superatur medicus. Si ergo aegrotus cum medico se dederit, vincitur infirmitas. Medicus Christus est; aegroti nos sumus; aegritudinis morbus, consuetudo peccati est. Jam qui ex parte renunciavit saeculo, quamvis vivat In saeculo, attendat ubi debeat inhaerere; utrum morbo an medico. Si medico non inhaeserit, laborat medicus. Ideo nobis Evangelium in saeculo clamat et dicit: Esto consentiens adversario tuo cito, dum es cum illo in via (Matth. v, 25 ). Non nos docet, ut simus consentientes adversario diabolo; sed docet, ut consentientes simus adversario, praecepto divino, quod adversatur malis nostris, et adversatur consuetudini nostrae, adversatur iniquitatibus nostris. Si consentimus, facti sumus concordes cum praecepto Dei, et accipimus quasi jugum Dei;
not on account of food, not on account of drink, not on account of clothing, not on account of vigils, not on account of work, not on account of the kitchen, not on account of service. Once you love one another, if anyone does something he ought not, that love does not allow you to take offence. Have, then, brothers, humility and obedience, which peace follows, so that you may be sons of peace; for love, as the apostle says, is the bond of perfection. When someone has humility, he imitates Christ, who was made lowly for us. When someone has obedience, he imitates Christ, who became obedient unto death. When someone has love, he imitates Christ, for God is love. But first labour to overcome your vices within. Let there first be peace of the soul and heart with God's command, so that against the habit and frailty of the body there may be two victors: God's command and your consent. For the case is like this: a physician, a sick man and a sickness. If the sick man gives himself over to the sickness, the physician is beaten; two are made against one, and the physician is overcome. But if the sick man gives himself to the physician, the illness is overcome. The physician is Christ; we are the sick; the disease of the sickness is the habit of sin. So let one who has partly renounced the world, though he lives in the world, look where he ought to cling: to the disease or to the physician. If he does not cling to the physician, the physician labours. Therefore the gospel cries out to us in the world and says: “Agree quickly with your adversary while you are with him on the way.” It does not teach us to agree with the adversary the devil, but teaches us to agree with the adversary that is God's command, which opposes our evils, opposes our habit, opposes our iniquities. If we consent, we are made of one heart with God's command, and we receive as it were God's yoke;
Col 3:14 (quotation, high confidence) · Phil 2:8 (quotation, high confidence) · 1 John 4:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 5:25 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Love, humility and obedience imitate Christ; the soul must side with Christ the physician and God's command against the sickness of sinful habit.
- Col 3:14; Phil 2:8; 1 John 4:16 (cited as 5:16 in the printed reference); Matt 5:25. The sentence runs on into the next section.
Topics: Ethics, Christology, Love of God and neighbour, Humility and pride
Cite (SBL): Ps.-Novatus, Humil. 3 (PL 18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/3). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/3
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ps-novatus-humilitate-3) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the original (PL 18); no public-domain English or FOTC volume, so re-read against the original.
Chapter 4
4PL 18
propter quod ait Dominus: Venite ad me omnes qui laboratis et onera(??)i estis, et ego reficiam vos. Tollite jugum meum, quia leve est, et sarcina mea levis est (Matth. xi, 28). Ecce quid tam leve? Denique considera quemadmodum qui aliquid habent in hoc mundo timent ne rapiatur. Quomodo timent ne quod acquisierunt perdant? Quibus modis torquentur, quasi sub gravissimo pondere sollicitudinem habendo? Vos autem non aliud laboratis, nisi ut hoc faciatis quod abbas praecipit. Jam sub jugo es: non cogitas ubi vivas; quia n(??)c debes cogitare. Est qui te regat: est qui tibi curam ferat. Omnino ad vos cogitatio cibi et vestimenti nec pertinere debet. Quod dederit abbas, sic puta quasi Deus dederit: ipsa est enim vera humilitas. Sed forte unus plus habet, et alter minus; et hoc tamquam a Deo factum habete. Sed unus sedet ad alteram mensam; si sic jubet abbas, si sic probaverit, sic habete quasi Deus jusserit. No(??)o inde interreges, ut dicas; eras ego ibi sessurussum. Nolo ut facias con(??)uetudinem ut tibi des illam necessitatem. Si forte non est quod detur, aut non videtur ut detur; sic habe, aut quia non est quod detur, aut visum est non expedire ut detur. Ista, tratres, si servaveritis, prorsus vitam aeternam habebitis. Nolite permittere vos verbis malis agi. Si forte aliquis infirmus cadit, ut loquatur perversa; statim cohibete illum: statim dicite: Noli facere, noli, frater, peccas. Debetis enim, propter quod in unum estis, et abbatem unum habetis, e vos vobis abbates esse. Numquid unus, quia duos oculos et duas aures habet, abbas potest omnes audire, aut omnes videre? aut non habet necessitatem alicubi exire et aliquid providere?
for which reason the Lord says: “Come to me, all you who labour and are burdened, and I will refresh you. Take my yoke, for it is light, and my burden is light.” Behold, what is so light? Consider, in short, how those who have something in this world fear that it will be snatched away. How they fear to lose what they have acquired! In what ways they are tormented, carrying anxiety as under a most heavy weight! But you labour for nothing else but to do what the abbot commands. You are already under the yoke; you do not think where you are to live, because you ought not to think of it. There is someone to rule you; there is someone to care for you. The thought of food and clothing ought not to concern you at all. What the abbot gives, consider it as if God had given it; for that is true humility. But perhaps one has more and another less; take this too as done by God. One sits at another table: if the abbot so orders, if he so approves, take it as though God had ordered it. I do not want you to ask questions about it, so as to say, “Tomorrow I shall sit there.” I do not want you to make a habit of it, so as to impose that necessity on yourself. If perhaps there is nothing to give, or it does not seem good to give, take it so: either there is nothing to give, or it has seemed not expedient to give. If you keep these things, brothers, you will surely have eternal life. Do not let yourselves be driven by evil words. If perhaps someone weak falls so as to speak perverse things, restrain him at once; say at once: “Do not do it, do not, brother; you are sinning.” For since you are in one place and have one abbot, you ought also to be abbots to one another. Can one man, because he has two eyes and two ears, as abbot hear all or see all? Or has he no need to go out somewhere and provide something?
Matt 11:28–30 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: The monk under the abbot's light yoke is freed from worldly anxiety; he should accept what the abbot gives as from God, and the brothers should correct one another as abbots to each other.
- Matt 11:28–30.
Topics: Church office, Monastic life
Cite (SBL): Ps.-Novatus, Humil. 4 (PL 18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/4). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/4
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ps-novatus-humilitate-4) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the original (PL 18); no public-domain English or FOTC volume, so re-read against the original.
Chapter 5
5PL 18
Vos vobis abbates estote; et quomodo metuistis abbatem praesentem, metuite et abse(??)em, quia praesens est Deus. Omnino hoc timete, hoc metuite, quia Deus semper praesens est. Et si unus curam fert tantis: quanto magis vos omnes ferre debetis; ne inveniat unde irascatur, unde doleat, unde offendatur, unde ingemiscat, unde putet quia peribit labor ejus tanti temporis? Haec enim tunc nobis poterunt prodesse, si habuerimus humilitatem, obedientiam et charitatem. Vi(??) alia ad Deum non est, nisi humilitas, obedientia et charitas. Ipse est via, veritas, et vita. Nam cruciari, jejunare biduo, triduo, quatriduo, septimanas facere frequenter, inde superbiunt fratres, putantes quia quod ipsi faciunt, alius facere non potest: infinitum putant esse quod alius non potest facere: aut ambulat nudo pede, et arbitratur quoniam ipse solus hoc potest facere: aut forte nec bibit nec ipsam aquam mixtam; exercitatio temporalis est, quia semper illud facere non potest. Sed cogitet magis humilitatem, cogitet pietatem, charitatem, obedientiam. Propter enim frangendas vires corporis, propter domandum sangulnem et carnem debet arripere ista quasi bonus athleta; sed non inde glorietur, ne perdat quod fecit Nam Pharisaeus ille qui ascendit in templum orare, numquid opera, quae numerabat, modica erant? Immensa erant; jejunare bis in Sabbato; decimas omnium rerum suarum pauperibus dare; non facere fraudem; adulterium non committere, infinitum est: sed quoniam jactavit illud in superbiam, totum quod fecit, superbia fuit (Luc. xviii, 9 et seq.) Propterea David dicit: Non veniat mihi pes superbiae, et manus peccatoris non moveat me. Ibi ceciderunt omnes qui operantur iniquitatem (Psalm, xxxv, 12). Ubi ceciderunt? In lapsu superbiae. Inde enim cecidit diabolus, per superbiam lapsus est. Omnino ergo non admittatur ad servos Dei superbia. Qui ergo jam aliter vivit, vitamque suam melius instituit, non sit quemadmodum ille Pharsaeus. Publicanus autem humiliatus non audet nec oculos ad coelum levare, et sententia Domini collandatus redit ad domum suam justificatus magis quam ille Pharisaeus. Expertum namque habemus, et in ipsis sanctis scripturis, et in fratribus nostris, quia quicumque viam humilitatis tenuit, proficit, et non perit.
Be abbots to yourselves; and as you feared the abbot when present, fear him also when absent, for God is present. Above all fear this, dread this, that God is always present. And if one man bears the care of so many, how much more ought all of you to bear it, so that he may not find cause to be angry, to grieve, to be offended, to groan, to think that his labour of so long a time will perish? For these things will profit us only if we have humility, obedience and love. There is no other way to God but humility, obedience and love. He himself is the way, the truth and the life. For to torment oneself, to fast for two, three, four days, often to keep whole weeks, makes brothers proud, thinking that what they themselves do another cannot do; they think it something immense that another cannot do. Or one walks barefoot and thinks he alone can do this; or perhaps one does not even drink mixed water; it is a temporary exercise, because he cannot always do it. But let him think rather of humility, of piety, love, obedience. For to break the strength of the body, to tame blood and flesh, he should take these up like a good athlete; but let him not glory in them, lest he lose what he has done. For that Pharisee who went up into the temple to pray, were the works he listed small? They were immense: to fast twice a week, to give tithes of all his goods to the poor, not to commit fraud, not to commit adultery is a great thing; but because he flaunted it in pride, all that he did was pride. Therefore David says: “Let not the foot of pride come to me, and let not the hand of the sinner move me. There all who work iniquity have fallen.” Where have they fallen? In the fall of pride. For thence the devil fell; he fell through pride. Let no pride at all, then, be admitted among the servants of God. He, then, who now lives differently and has ordered his life better, let him not be like that Pharisee. But the tax collector, humbled, did not dare even to raise his eyes to heaven, and, praised by the Lord's sentence, went back to his house justified rather than that Pharisee. For we have found by experience, both in the holy Scriptures themselves and in our brothers, that whoever has kept the way of humility makes progress and does not perish.
John 14:6 (quotation, high confidence) · Luke 18:9–14 (allusion, high confidence) · Ps 36:11–12 (35:12-13 LXX) (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Fasting and austerities are useful to tame the flesh but become pride if boasted of, like the Pharisee's works; the only way to God is humility, obedience and love.
- John 14:6; Luke 18:9–14 (“fast twice in the sabbath” = twice a week); Ps 36:11–12 (LXX 35:12–13; Migne's reference reads 35:12). The preacher's paraphrase of the Pharisee's works goes beyond the gospel wording (e.g. tithes “to the poor”).
Topics: Fasting, Ethics, Humility and pride
Cite (SBL): Ps.-Novatus, Humil. 5 (PL 18; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/5). (abbreviation not yet checked)
Permanent link: https://sophiascriptura.com/p/ps-novatus-humilitate/5
BibTeX · RIS · CSL-JSON (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-ps-novatus-humilitate-5) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude from the original (PL 18); no public-domain English or FOTC volume, so re-read against the original.