On Christian Doctrine 4.29–4.31
Latin text: Migne, PL 34 (Latin text: Migne, Patrologia Latina, digitized by Open Greek and Latin (patrologia_latina-dev, University of Leipzig), CC BY-SA 4.0).English: Claude (claude-opus-5-5), public domain (CC0). Compare: Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, series 1, vol. 2 (1887).
Chapter 4
4.29PL 34:93
Si autem ne hoc quidem potest, ita conversetur, ut non solum sibi præmium comparet, sed etiam præbeat aliis exemplum, et sit ejus quasi copia dicen di forma vivendi. Sunt sane quidam qui bene pronuntiare pos sunt, quidautem pronuntient, excogitare non possunt. Quod si ab aliis sumant eloquenter sapienterquc con scriptum, memoriæque commendent, atque ad popu- 1 um proferant; si eam personam gerunt, non improbe faciunt. Sic enim, quod profecto utile ese, multi pracdicatores veritatis fiunt, nec multi magistri, si uriins veri magistri idipsum dicant omnes, ct nou sint in eis schismata ( I Cor. i, 10 ). Nec deterrendi sunt isti voce Jeremiæ prophetæ, per quem Deus arguit eos qui furantur verba ejus, unusquisque a proxi mo suo. Qui enim furantur, alienum auferunt; verbum autem Dei non est ab eis alienum, qui obtemperant ci: potiusque ille dicit aliena, qui cum dicat bene, vivit malc. Quæcumque cnim bona dicit, ejus excogitari videntur ingenio, sed ab ejus moribus aliena sunt. Eos itaque dixit Deus furari ver ba sua, qui boni volunt vidcri, loqucndo quæ Dei sunt; cum mali sint, facicndo quæ sua sunt. Nec sane ipsi dicunt bona quæ dicunt, si diligenter attendas. Quomodo enim dicunt verbis, quod negant factis? Non enim frustra de talibus ait Apostolus: Confiten tur se nosse Deum, fuctis autem negant. Modo ergo quodam ipsi dicunt, et rursus alio modo non ipsi dicunt, quoniam utrumque verum est quod Veritas ait. De talibus enim loquens, Quœ dicunt, inquit, facite; quæ autem faciunt, facere nolite; hoc esl, Quod ex ore illorum auditis, facite; quod in opere videtis, facere nolite: dicunt enim, inquit, et non faciunt. Ergo quamvis non fa ciant, dicunt tamen. Sed alio loco tales arguens: Hypocritæ, inquit, quomodo potestis bona loqui, cum sitis mali? Ac per hoc et ea quae dicunt, quando bona dicunt, non ipsi dicunt, voluntate scili cet atque opere nrgando quod dicunt. Unde contingit ut homo disertus et malus, sermonem quo veritas pracdicctur, dicendum ab alio non diserto sed bono, ipse componat; quod cum fit, ipse a seipso tradit alienum, ille ab alieno accipit suum. Cum vero boni fideles bonis fidelibus hanc operam commodant, utri que sua dicunt: quia et Deus ipsorum est, cujus sunt illa quae dicunl; et ea sua faciunt, quoe non ipsi com ponere potuerunt, qui secundum ilia composite vivunt.
But if he cannot even do this, let him so conduct himself that he not only gains a reward for himself but also gives an example to others, and his way of living may be, as it were, an abundance of speech.
There are indeed some who can deliver well, but cannot think out what to deliver. If they take from others what has been written eloquently and wisely, commit it to memory, and bring it before the people, they do not act wrongly, if they play that part. For in this way, which is certainly useful, many become preachers of the truth, but not many masters, if they all say the same thing as the one true Master, and there are no schisms among them. Nor should they be deterred by the voice of the prophet Jeremiah, through whom God rebukes those who steal his words, each from his neighbor. For those who steal take away what belongs to another; but the word of God does not belong to another for those who obey it; rather, he speaks another's words who, though he speaks well, lives badly. For whatever good things he says seem to be thought out by his own mind, but they are foreign to his conduct. So God said that those steal his words who wish to seem good by speaking the things that are God's, while they are bad by doing the things that are their own. Nor, if you consider carefully, do they themselves say the good things they say. For how do they say in words what they deny in deeds? For not in vain does the Apostle say of such people: “They profess that they know God, but in deeds they deny him.” In one way, then, they themselves say it, and in another way they do not themselves say it, since both things the Truth says are true. For, speaking of such people, he says, “What they say, do; but what they do, do not do”; that is, “What you hear from their mouth, do; what you see in their work, do not do; for they say,” he says, “and do not do.” So although they do not do, they still say. But in another place, rebuking such people, he says, “Hypocrites, how can you speak good things when you are evil?” And so even what they say, when they say good things, they do not themselves say, denying by will and deed what they say. Hence it can happen that an eloquent but bad man composes a sermon in which truth is preached, to be delivered by another who is not eloquent but good; when this happens, the former hands over from himself what is not his own, and the latter receives from another what is his own. But when good believers lend this service to good believers, both speak their own words: because God is theirs, whose are the things they say; and those who live in accordance with them make their own the things they could not compose themselves.
Matt 23:8–10 (allusion, medium confidence) · 1 Cor 1:10 (allusion, high confidence) · Jer 23:30 (quotation, high confidence) · Titus 1:16 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 23:3 (quotation, high confidence) · Matt 12:34 (quotation, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Those who cannot compose may preach others' sermons without blame, for God's word belongs to those who obey it; a bad man who speaks well speaks words not truly his own.
- Quotations from Jer 23:30, Titus 1:16, Matt 23:3, and Matt 12:34; one Master and no schisms: Matt 23:8–10; 1 Cor 1:10.
Topics: Church office
Cite (SBL): Augustine, Doctr. chr. 4.29 (PL 34:93; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/augustine-doctrina-christiana/4-29/#p-4-29). (abbreviation not yet checked)
BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-augustine-doctrina-christiana-4-29) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude (Opus) from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina (digital text of the Open Greek and Latin project); each batch compared afterwards with the public-domain translation of J. F. Shaw in NPNF¹ 2 (1887).
4.30PL 34:93
Sive autcm apud populum vel apud quoslibet jamjamque dicturus, sive quod apud populum dicen dum vel ab cis qui voluerint aut potuerint legendum, est dictalurns; oret ut Deus sermonem bonum det in os ejus. Si enim regina oravit Esther, pro suae gentis temporaria salute locutura apud regem, ut in os ejus Deus congruum sermonem daret; quanto magis orare debet, ut tale munus accipiat, qui pro aeterna hominum salute in verbo ct doctrina laborat? Illi vero qui ea dicturi sunt quæ ab aliis acceperunt, et antequam accipiant, orent pro cis a quibus accipiunt, ut cis detur quod per eos accipere volunt; et cum acceperint, orent ut bene et ipsi pro ferant, et illi ad quos proferuntsumant; etde prospe ro exitu dictionis eidem gratias agant, a quo id se accepisse non dubitant: ut qui gloriatur, in illo glo rietur, in cujus manu sunt et nos et sermones nostri.
But whether he is about to speak before the people or before any others, or to dictate what is to be spoken before the people or read by those who wish or are able, let him pray that God may put a good word in his mouth. For if Queen Esther prayed, when she was about to speak before the king for the temporal safety of her people, that God would put a fitting word in her mouth, how much more ought one to pray for such a gift who labors in word and teaching for the eternal salvation of human beings? And those who are to say what they have received from others, let them pray, even before they receive it, for those from whom they receive it, that what they wish to receive through them may be given to them; and when they have received it, let them pray that they themselves may deliver it well, and that those to whom they deliver it may take it in; and let them give thanks for the happy outcome of the speech to him from whom they do not doubt they have received it; so that he who glories may glory in him in whose hand are both we and our words.
1 Tim 5:17 (allusion, high confidence) · 1 Cor 1:31 (allusion, high confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Every preacher, whether speaking or dictating his own words or others', should pray before and give thanks after, as Esther prayed before speaking to the king.
- Esther's prayer is in the Greek additions to Esther (Add Esth 14:13, Rest of Esther C 24 in other numbering), which the site counts as extrabiblical. Labor in word and teaching: 1 Tim 5:17; he who glories: 1 Cor 1:31 (2 Cor 10:17); in whose hand are we and our words: Wis 7:16.
Extrabiblical texts: Add Esth 14:13 (Additions to Esther [in RC, EO, ETH canons]; allusion); Wis 7:16 (Wisdom of Solomon [in RC, EO, ETH canons]; quotation)
Topics: Prayer
Cite (SBL): Augustine, Doctr. chr. 4.30 (PL 34:93; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/augustine-doctrina-christiana/4-29/#p-4-30). (abbreviation not yet checked)
BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-augustine-doctrina-christiana-4-30) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude (Opus) from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina (digital text of the Open Greek and Latin project); each batch compared afterwards with the public-domain translation of J. F. Shaw in NPNF¹ 2 (1887).
4.31PL 34:94
Longior evasit liber hic qnam volebam, quam que putaveram. Sed legenti vel audienti, cui gratus est, longus non est: cui autem longus est, per partes eum legat, qui babere vult cognitum; quem vero co guitionis ejus piget, de longitudine non queratur. Ego tamen Deo nostro gratias ago, quod in his qua tuor libris non qualis ego cssem, cui multa desunt, sed qualis esse dcbeat, qui in doctrina sana, id est christiana, non solum sibi, sed etiam aliis laborare studet, quantulacumque potui facultate disserui.
This book has turned out longer than I wished and than I had thought. But to the reader or hearer who finds it welcome, it is not long; and one who finds it long, if he wishes to know it, should read it in parts; but one who is weary of knowing it should not complain of its length. I, however, give thanks to our God that in these four books I have discussed, with whatever small ability I could, not what kind of man I am, who lack much, but what kind of man he ought to be who is eager to labor in sound teaching, that is, Christian teaching, not only for himself but also for others.
Titus 2:1 (allusion, medium confidence)
Notes and citation
Summary: Augustine concludes, thanking God that he has described not himself but what the Christian teacher ought to be.
- Sound teaching: 1 Tim 1:10; Titus 2:1.
Cite (SBL): Augustine, Doctr. chr. 4.31 (PL 34:94; trans. Sophia Scriptura, https://sophiascriptura.com/fathers/augustine-doctrina-christiana/4-29/#p-4-31). (abbreviation not yet checked)
BibTeX · RIS (whole work; this passage's key: sophiascriptura-augustine-doctrina-christiana-4-31) · Report an error
Translation: Translated by Claude (Opus) from the Latin of Migne's Patrologia Latina (digital text of the Open Greek and Latin project); each batch compared afterwards with the public-domain translation of J. F. Shaw in NPNF¹ 2 (1887).